Yeah, sweating copper pipes always has that little moment of truth—been there plenty of times myself. As for the environmental angle, I've seen some articles floating around about copper vs PEX. Seems like copper's upfront impact (mining, refining) is pretty heavy, but since it lasts practically forever and can be recycled, it balances out somewhat. PEX is easier to work with, but disposal and plastic waste are legit concerns. Honestly, it's probably a toss-up environmentally...pick your poison, I guess.
"Honestly, it's probably a toss-up environmentally...pick your poison, I guess."
Yeah, that's the tricky part. But cost-wise, isn't PEX usually cheaper overall? I'm leaning towards it myself—anyone had issues long-term, like durability or leaks after a few years?
PEX is definitely cheaper upfront and easier to handle if you're DIYing it. I've had mine for about 4 years now with zero issues. But I'll be honest, I've heard a couple horror stories—usually from improper installations or fittings failing. If you go with PEX, just make sure you use quality fittings and a reliable crimp tool. Like you said:
"pick your poison, I guess."
But personally, I'd say PEX's ease and affordability outweigh the small risk. Good luck!
I've been leaning toward PEX myself for an upcoming bathroom reno, mostly because copper seems intimidating for a newbie. But hearing about these fitting failures makes me pause a bit... Do you think most of these horror stories come down to user error, or is there something inherently risky about certain brands or types of fittings? Curious if anyone's had better luck with specific brands or methods.
I redid the plumbing in my 1920s place a couple years back and went with PEX. Honestly, most fitting issues I've seen come down to rushed installs or cheap fittings. I stuck with Uponor expansion fittings—bit pricier, but zero leaks so far... knock on wood.