Remodeling discussions and local services.

Swapping out old faucets and toilets - what brands actually last?

551 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

- Had the same debate when I started my reno - tempted by some of those “statement” faucets, but the reviews scared me off.
- Ended up with Moen for the kitchen and Delta in the bathroom. Both have held up, even with hard water.
- Parts are easy to find, which is huge when something breaks at 10pm.
- For toilets, Toto’s been solid. Not the cheapest, but flushes like a champ and no weird leaks yet.
- Honestly, I’d skip most of the boutique brands unless you’re okay with replacing stuff sooner than you’d expect... learned that from my cousin’s experience.


Reply

I keep hearing good things about Toto toilets, but I’m curious - has anyone had issues with their parts availability?

“Parts are easy to find, which is huge when something breaks at 10pm.”
That’s been my main concern, especially since I’ve run into weird proprietary stuff before. Also, for Moen and Delta faucets, do you notice any difference in how they handle mineral buildup over time? Our water’s pretty hard and I’m worried about finish getting wrecked or valves seizing up.


Reply
activist497882

I get your concern about proprietary parts - some brands really do make it a headache. In my experience, Toto’s been pretty reliable for parts, even for older models. As for Moen vs. Delta, I’ve noticed Delta’s finishes hold up a bit better with hard water, but both can get crusty if you don’t stay on top of cleaning. A quick wipe-down every so often makes a big difference.


Reply
hannah_rain

As for Moen vs. Delta, I’ve noticed Delta’s finishes hold up a bit better with hard water, but both can get crusty if you don’t stay on top of cleaning.

I’d say that matches what I’ve seen, though honestly, Moen’s cartridge system is just easier to swap out when something goes wrong. That’s saved me a headache or two over the years. For toilets, I’ve had a Kohler that’s still going strong after 15 years - parts are easy to find and it just keeps working. Hard water’s brutal, though... even the “spot resistant” finishes only go so far if you’ve got well water like I do.


Reply
astronomy308

You’re not alone dealing with hard water headaches. I’ve got well water too, and even the “spot free” finishes eventually show their age. I totally get what you mean about Moen cartridges - they’re a breeze to swap compared to some of the older Delta models I’ve run into. That’s saved me from a lot of cursing under the sink.

Kohler toilets are tanks, honestly. I’ve had one in my guest bath for over a decade, and it’s still going strong with just the occasional flapper replacement. If you’re keeping up with basic cleaning and maybe running a vinegar soak through the faucet aerators every few months, you’re already ahead of the game. Hard water’s tough, but it sounds like you’ve got a solid routine down. Sometimes it’s just about finding what works and sticking with it - even if it means a little extra elbow grease now and then.


Reply
breezej67

Kohler toilets are tanks, honestly. I’ve had one in my guest bath for over a decade, and it’s still going strong with just the occasional flapper replacement.

Couldn’t agree more on Kohler. I swear, those things could survive a small meteor strike. I’ve flipped a few houses where the only thing left working was the Kohler toilet - everything else was toast.

On the faucet side, Moen’s cartridge system is basically idiot-proof. I’m not saying I’ve ever put one in backwards at 2AM while half-asleep, but... let’s just say if you do, you’ll know pretty quick. Delta’s older stuff can be a pain, but their newer models aren’t bad once you get past the “how many Allen wrenches does one faucet need?” phase.

Hard water is the real villain here though. Even “spot free” finishes are like that one friend who promises to help you move and then bails halfway through - you think they’ll stick around, but nope. I started running a vinegar rinse through everything every couple months and it helps, but let’s be honest: if your water eats through metal, there’s only so much you can do.

If anyone’s curious about American Standard toilets - they’re decent, but I’ve seen more finicky flush valves on those than I care to remember. For pure longevity and less fiddling? Still team Kohler.

At this point, my cleaning routine is basically: scrub, soak in vinegar, replace what breaks, repeat. It’s not glamorous but hey - it works (most of the time).


Reply
shadows74

- Kohler toilets really are the MVPs - mine’s outlasted two bathroom remodels and a couple of clumsy plumbers.
- Moen’s cartridges have saved my sanity more than once, but I’ll admit, I’ve had a Delta faucet where the handle got wobbly after a year. Maybe just bad luck?
- Hard water is relentless. I tried those “miracle” spot-free sprays - no dice. Vinegar soaks are my go-to too, but sometimes I just give up and let the finish look “vintage.”
- For toilets, I’d add Toto to the list. Pricey, but the flush is next-level and they’re surprisingly low maintenance.
- If you’re swapping out faucets, don’t skip on braided supply lines - they’re cheap insurance against leaks down the road.
- My cleaning routine is basically yours: scrub, soak, replace...and occasionally curse at calcium buildup. It’s a process.


Reply

If you’re swapping out faucets, don’t skip on braided supply lines - they’re cheap insurance against leaks down the road.

Couldn’t agree more on the braided lines. I’ve seen too many disasters from folks reusing old plastic ones. On brands, Kohler and Toto are both solid for toilets - rarely get callbacks on those. For faucets, Moen’s internals hold up, but I’ve had better luck with Grohe for long-term durability. Hard water’s a pain, but a whole-house filter can help if you’re tired of scrubbing. Sometimes the “vintage” look just wins, though...


Reply
jlopez96

I’ve had mixed results with Moen - sometimes the cartridges get sticky after a few years, especially with hard water. Grohe’s definitely solid, though I find their replacement parts a bit pricier. Anyone tried Delta lately? I keep hearing their newer models are easier to repair, but I haven’t swapped one in for a while. Curious if they’re holding up as well as the old ones did...


Reply
hiking_tim

- Totally get the Moen struggle - mine started squeaking like a haunted house after a few years.
- Grohe’s great, but yeah, my wallet cries every time I need a part.
- Delta’s newer stuff? Had to swap a kitchen faucet last year. The quick-connect hoses are actually pretty slick, and the cartridge was way easier to pop out than the old ones.
- Durability seems decent so far, but I’m not sure they’re as bombproof as the 90s models.
- Side note: if you’re dealing with hard water, those cheap inline filters can save a lot of headaches... and maybe your sanity.


Reply
rwhiskers11

Delta’s newer stuff? Had to swap a kitchen faucet last year. The quick-connect hoses are actually pretty slick, and the cartridge was way easier to pop out than the old ones.

I’m with you on the Delta quick-connects - makes life so much easier under the sink. For anyone looking to stretch the lifespan, I’ve found that regular vinegar soaks on aerators and cartridges can really help, especially with hard water. Has anyone tried those eco-friendly faucets with built-in flow restrictors? Curious if they hold up or just end up being another thing to fix down the road...


Reply
poetry147

Has anyone tried those eco-friendly faucets with built-in flow restrictors? Curious if they hold up or just end up being another thing to fix down the road...

I swapped in a Moen low-flow model last year - honestly, it’s held up better than I expected. The restrictor hasn’t clogged yet, even with our mineral-heavy water. Only thing is, sometimes the pressure feels a bit weak for rinsing big pots. Anyone else notice that tradeoff?


Reply
cnelson63

Only thing is, sometimes the pressure feels a bit weak for rinsing big pots. Anyone else notice that tradeoff?

Oh man, you nailed it with the pot rinsing struggle. I put in a Delta low-flow in my own kitchen last winter - figured I’d practice what I preach before telling clients to go green. It’s been solid, no leaks or weird noises, but yeah, when I’m trying to blast out dried oatmeal from a saucepan, it’s like using a gentle mountain stream instead of a firehose.

Funny enough, my wife actually likes it because it doesn’t splash everywhere when she’s washing veggies. But for me, sometimes I just want to power-wash the spaghetti sauce off a plate, you know? Haven’t had any clogging issues yet, even with our hard water, but I do pop the aerator off every few months just in case.

Honestly, I’d say they’re worth it if you’re not expecting Niagara Falls every time you turn on the tap. Just gotta adjust your expectations (and maybe soak those pots a little longer).


Reply
emilymusician3205

when I’m trying to blast out dried oatmeal from a saucepan, it’s like using a gentle mountain stream instead of a firehose.

That’s exactly it. I swapped in a Moen low-flow last year and while it’s been reliable, I do miss the “firehose” effect for stuff like caked-on chili. It’s kind of a weird tradeoff - great for not flooding the counter when you’re rinsing berries, but not so great when you need some muscle. I’ve actually started keeping an old spray bottle under the sink for those stubborn bits (probably overkill, but hey, it works).

On the brand front, I’ve had better luck with Kohler for toilets - ours is pushing 12 years and still flushes like day one. Faucets seem more hit or miss. My parents’ old Price Pfister is still kicking, but the finish looks rough.

Guess it comes down to what bugs you more: weak pressure or surprise puddles on the floor. For me, I’ll take a little extra soaking time if it means less mopping.


Reply
summitgamerdev

Yeah, I get that tradeoff. Low-flow is great for saving water, but sometimes you just want that extra oomph. I’ve had similar luck with Kohler toilets - ours survived three kids and a dog who thinks it’s his water bowl. Faucets are always a gamble, honestly. Your spray bottle trick isn’t overkill at all... whatever works, right?


Reply

Honestly, I’ve had better luck with American Standard than Kohler for toilets. The last Kohler I installed started leaking after a year, while my old American Standard is still going strong. As for faucets, I actually think Delta holds up better than most - less fiddling with repairs.

Faucets are always a gamble, honestly.

I get where you’re coming from, but if you stick to the basics - no fancy sensors or weird finishes - they’re not as much of a crapshoot. Sometimes simple really does last longer.


Reply

I totally get what you mean about sticking with the basics. My house is pushing 100 years, and honestly, the simplest fixtures have outlasted anything “modern” I tried swapping in. I replaced a fancy touchless faucet once - looked great, but it was a headache. The old-school Delta I put in after? Still works like a charm, no fuss. Sometimes the tried-and-true stuff really does win out over bells and whistles.


Reply
snorkeler20

Sometimes the tried-and-true stuff really does win out over bells and whistles.

I get where you're coming from, but I’ve actually had the opposite luck with some newer stuff. My Moen touchless has been running strong for 5 years - no leaks, no weirdness. Maybe it’s just a roll of the dice sometimes? The old-school stuff is solid, but I wouldn’t totally write off modern features either. Sometimes they just need a bit more TLC or a better install.


Reply

I hear you on the newer features sometimes being worth it. I was pretty skeptical about touchless faucets at first - just seemed like one more thing to break. But after installing one in our kitchen, I’ve been surprised by how reliable it’s been. I think you nailed it with the install part; a lot of issues seem to come down to whether things are put in right from the start.

That said, I still get nervous about anything with electronics or sensors. Maybe that’s just me being cautious, but I’ve seen a few horror stories about replacement parts being a pain to find. Still, five years without a hiccup is impressive. Makes me feel a bit better about mixing in some newer tech as I swap stuff out.

Guess there’s no perfect answer - sometimes you get a solid run with new gadgets, sometimes the classics just keep chugging along. Either way, it’s good to hear when something modern actually holds up over time.


Reply
genealogist56

Couldn’t agree more about the install making all the difference - seen plenty of “bad” products that were just badly put in. On the touchless faucet front, I was wary too. Honestly, I still keep a backup manual one in the garage just in case, but the Moen we put in has been solid for a few years now. Replacement parts are a headache, though - definitely wish more brands made that part easier. Still, when they work, they’re a game-changer for messy kitchen jobs. For toilets, Toto’s still my go-to - basic models, nothing fancy, but they just don’t quit. Sometimes boring is better, you know?


Reply
Scroll to Top