Remodeling discussions and local services.

Swapping out old faucets and toilets - what brands actually last?

551 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I hear you on the big brand hype. Had a similar experience - my last place had a no-name faucet (I think it was from one of those “builder basic” lines at the hardware store) and it worked just fine for the six years I lived there. Never leaked, didn’t get all crusty, and honestly, I barely thought about it until I moved out and realized it was still going strong.

I do get why people swear by the pricier stuff, though. My parents splurged on a WaterSense-certified Kohler toilet for their remodel, and it’s been a champ - super efficient, barely ever needs plunging. But then again, my neighbor’s off-brand toilet has also survived two kids and a dog who thinks it’s a water bowl, so who knows.

I’m curious if anyone’s noticed a difference in water usage or durability with the eco-friendly models versus the standard ones? Sometimes I wonder if the green labels are more about marketing than real-world savings...


Reply

I’m curious if anyone’s noticed a difference in water usage or durability with the eco-friendly models versus the standard ones? Sometimes I wonder if the green labels are more about marketing than real-world savings...

I’ve swapped out two original 1940s toilets for modern WaterSense models (one Kohler, one American Standard) in my old place. The water bills dropped a bit, but honestly, the biggest thing I noticed was that the Kohler’s flush isn’t as powerful - sometimes needs a second go. The older tank guzzled more but never got clogged. Anyone else run into “eco” models that actually underperform, or is it just certain brands?


Reply
sperez78

Honestly, I’ve had the same issue with some “eco” toilets - less water, but sometimes that means double flushing, which kind of defeats the point. I do think some brands cut corners just to slap on a green label. That said, my Toto Drake has been solid so far - no clogs, decent flush, and still uses way less water than the old beast it replaced. Maybe it’s more about the specific model than just the eco label?


Reply
robotics710

I totally get what you mean about the “eco” label not always living up to the hype. I’ve seen clients swap out old fixtures for something “green,” only to end up frustrated with performance. The Toto Drake’s a solid choice - honestly, I’ve recommended it more than once and haven’t heard complaints yet. Sometimes it really does come down to the specific model, not just the marketing. It’s wild how much difference a well-designed flush can make... I guess not all low-flow toilets are created equal.


Reply

I’ve had similar experiences with “eco” fixtures that didn’t stand the test of time - especially with faucets. For my 1920s place, I ended up sticking with Moen for faucets and the Toto Drake for toilets. The Drake’s flush is surprisingly reliable, even compared to some older high-flow models I’ve used. It’s tempting to go by labels, but honestly, build quality and design seem to matter more in the long run.


Reply
carolr71

Swapping out old faucets and toilets - what brands actually last?

Totally get what you mean about “eco” fixtures that end up being more eco-annoying than eco-friendly. I’ve seen some so-called water-saving faucets that basically just dribble and make you want to scream. Moen’s been a solid pick for me too - those cartridges are like the cockroaches of plumbing, they just keep going. Ever tried Kohler for sinks? I’ve had a few clients swear by them, but I’m always a little suspicious of anything that looks too pretty... Is it just me, or do the fancy ones break faster?


Reply

- Had a Kohler faucet in the kitchen for about eight years - still works, but the finish started flaking after five. Functionally solid, but yeah, the “designer” lines seem more fragile.
- Delta’s been weirdly reliable for me. Not flashy, but zero leaks or issues so far.
- Agree on Moen cartridges - they just don’t quit.
- Those ultra-sleek faucets look great until you need to find a replacement part... then it’s a nightmare.


Reply
dallen31

- Seen a lot of Delta and Moen outlast trends and fads - totally agree, they’re not flashy but they just work.
- I’ve noticed some of the newer “matte black” finishes scratch or chip way faster than chrome or stainless. Anyone else seeing that?
- I’m curious - has anyone tried those touchless faucets long-term? I keep getting asked about them, but I’m not sure how they hold up after a few years.


Reply
ctail27

Swapping out old faucets and toilets - what brands actually last?

I’ve had similar thoughts about those matte black finishes. They look sharp at first, but I’ve seen a couple in friends’ houses where the finish started to wear off around the handles after just a year or two. I’m not sure if it’s the cleaning products or just normal use, but chrome definitely seems to hold up better in my experience. Stainless is a close second, though it can show water spots if you don’t wipe it down.

On the touchless faucet thing - has anyone run into issues with the sensors getting finicky over time? I installed one in my kitchen about three years ago (Kohler, I think), and it’s mostly been great, but every now and then it’ll just stop responding until I reset it. Not a huge deal, but I wonder if that’s just par for the course with the tech, or if some brands are more reliable than others. Also, battery changes are a bit of a pain if you forget about them.

I’m curious if anyone’s tried the newer “smart” toilets or bidet seats. Are they actually worth the extra cost, or is it just another thing to break down the line? I’ve stuck with basic Toto and American Standard models for years because they’re easy to fix and parts are everywhere, but I keep seeing those fancy models popping up in remodels. Do they really last, or is it just more stuff to maintain?

And speaking of longevity, has anyone noticed a difference in how long the internal parts last between brands? Like, do the fill valves or flush mechanisms on Kohler or Delta toilets actually outlast the cheaper ones, or is it all pretty much the same once you get past the marketing? Sometimes I wonder if it’s just luck of the draw...


Reply
andrew_evans

I’ve stuck with basic Toto and American Standard models for years because they’re easy to fix and parts are everywhere, but I keep seeing those fancy models popping up in remodels. Do they really last, or is it just more stuff to maintain?

You’re not wrong about sticking with the basics - Toto and American Standard have a solid track record for a reason. I’ve installed a few of the “smart” toilets and bidet seats, and honestly, while the features are cool, there’s definitely more that can go wrong. When something does break, replacement parts aren’t always as easy to source as with the standard models. As for internal parts like fill valves, I’ve noticed Kohler tends to use proprietary designs that can be pricier to replace, but Delta’s internals seem a bit more universal. Still, sometimes it really does feel like luck of the draw - one unit lasts forever, another needs tinkering after a year or two.


Reply
rayvolunteer

I hear you on the “more features, more problems” thing. I’ve swapped out a couple of those high-tech toilets for friends, and honestly, the troubleshooting is a pain compared to the old-school stuff. If you’re like me and want to keep things simple (and cheap), here’s my usual approach: stick with Toto or American Standard for toilets, and Delta for faucets. Parts are everywhere, and you don’t need a PhD to fix a leak. The fancy stuff looks cool, but I’d rather not have to Google error codes just to flush.


Reply
fisher615431

Honestly, I’m with you on keeping it simple. I once installed one of those “smart” toilets for my cousin - thing had a remote, heated seat, the works. Two months later, he calls me because it’s flashing some cryptic code and won’t flush. Turns out a sensor got wet. We ended up bypassing half the electronics just to get it working again. Never again.

Toto’s been rock solid for me too, though I’ll admit I’ve had decent luck with Kohler as well - parts are easy to find at the local hardware store, which is a lifesaver when something inevitably goes wrong at 10pm. For faucets, Delta’s cartridges are super easy to swap out, but I’ve also used Moen and found their quick-connect hoses pretty handy.

I get the appeal of all the bells and whistles, but honestly? Give me something that just works and doesn’t require a manual thicker than my old phone book. Less time fixing means more time actually enjoying the bathroom... or at least not dreading it.


Reply

I hear you on the smart stuff being more trouble than it’s worth. I replaced my old leaky faucet with a basic Delta last year - nothing fancy, just solid brass and easy to fix. Saved a ton compared to the touchless models, and if it ever drips, I know I can get a cartridge at any hardware store. For toilets, I’ve had a builder-grade American Standard for almost 15 years now and it just keeps going... not glamorous, but I’d rather spend that money elsewhere.


Reply
golfplayer41

I get where you’re coming from - simple definitely has its perks. But I’ve actually had pretty good luck with some of the newer touchless faucets in my rentals. Less fingerprints, and tenants seem to like the “fancy” factor. They’re a pain when they break, sure, but honestly, hasn’t happened much for me yet. Maybe I’ve just been lucky...


Reply

I hear you on the touchless faucets - my brother swears by them in his units, too. I’m still a bit old-school, but I get the appeal, especially for rentals where you want that “wow” factor. Just gotta say, when they go, tracking down the right sensor or part can be a pain. For longevity, I’ve had the best luck with Moen and Delta (manual ones, at least). They seem to take a beating and still work. Kohler toilets haven’t let me down yet, either.


Reply
finn_tail

Just gotta say, when they go, tracking down the right sensor or part can be a pain.

You nailed it there. Those touchless ones look slick, but when the sensor acts up, it’s a whole project just to figure out what’s wrong. I’ve swapped out way more Moen and Delta manual faucets than I can count, and they’re usually still kicking after years of tenant abuse. Kohler toilets - same deal, barely ever get a call about those. If it ain’t broke, right?


Reply
gadgeteer544588

Swapping out old faucets and toilets - what brands actually last?

Those touchless ones look slick, but when the sensor acts up, it’s a whole project just to figure out what’s wrong.

Right? I tried those motion-activated faucets in a couple of my rentals thinking they’d cut down on water waste and maintenance calls. Joke’s on me - ended up getting texts at 10pm because the thing wouldn’t shut off or, worse, wouldn’t turn on at all. Tenants get frustrated, I get frustrated, and then I’m on YouTube trying to figure out if it’s the solenoid or the battery or who knows what. Give me a good old-fashioned handle any day.

I’ve noticed the same as you with Moen and Delta. They’re not fancy, but they survive just about anything. I swear, one of my units still has a Delta from the late ‘90s and it’s outlasted three tenants who thought it was a towel rack. I will say, though, I’ve had a couple of Kohler toilets where the flapper started leaking after a few years. Not a huge deal, but it’s always the little things that sneak up on you.

Ever tried American Standard for toilets? I’ve had decent luck with them, but I’ve heard mixed reviews. Some folks swear by them, others say they’re more trouble than they’re worth. I guess it depends on the model. Honestly, I’m starting to think the secret is just sticking with the classics and avoiding anything that needs batteries or a manual thicker than a phone book.

Anyone else ever get burned by those “lifetime warranty” claims? I tried cashing in on one once and it felt like more paperwork than it was worth. At this point, I’d rather just buy a new part and be done with it.

Curious if anyone’s found a sensor faucet that actually holds up, though. I keep hoping someone’s cracked the code, but so far, I haven’t seen it.


Reply

I hear you on the sensor faucets - every time I’ve tried one, it’s been more hassle than it’s worth. Even the “commercial grade” ones at my buddy’s restaurant needed constant fiddling. As for American Standard toilets, I’ve had mixed luck too. One model worked great, another had a weird flush valve issue that drove me nuts. Anyone else notice that even with “lifetime warranties,” you end up jumping through hoops just to get a $10 part? Sometimes I wonder if it’s just easier to stick with what’s proven, even if it’s not the fanciest option.


Reply

Had a similar experience with sensor faucets - honestly, the water savings just weren’t worth the constant resets and battery swaps. For toilets, I’ve had better luck with Toto. Not the cheapest, but their eco models have been surprisingly reliable over the years.


Reply

Toto’s a solid pick - can’t really argue with their track record. I’ve put in a bunch of their eco models for clients, and honestly, they just keep working. Not the cheapest up front, but you save yourself headaches down the line. Sensor faucets, though... yeah, I hear you. They sound great on paper, but between the batteries and random malfunctions, it’s more hassle than it should be. Sometimes the old-school manual stuff just wins out for reliability.

If you’re looking at faucets, I’ve had decent luck with Moen and Delta - parts are easy to find if anything goes wrong. Not perfect, but less finicky than most of the “smart” options out there. It’s always a balance between features and long-term maintenance. You’re not alone in getting frustrated with all the tech that’s supposed to make life easier but ends up being another thing to fix.


Reply
Scroll to Top