- I hear you on Moen—solid, but their style’s a bit “safe.”
- For toilets, I went with American Standard last time. Not glamorous, but it’s handled my kids’ “experiments” without complaint.
- Honestly, I’d love to see a faucet that lasts longer than my phone’s charging cable... but here we are.
- Cast iron relics sound cool until you try to move one up a flight of stairs.
Cast iron relics sound cool until you try to move one up a flight of stairs.
That’s exactly what I’m worried about. I found this old-school cast iron tub at a salvage place and it looked amazing, but then I started picturing the logistics... yikes. For faucets, is “safe” style really that bad if it means fewer leaks? I’m still trying to figure out if it’s worth paying extra for something like Delta or if I’ll just end up replacing it in a few years anyway. Anyone ever regret going with a cheaper brand?
Delta’s been solid for me, honestly. I’ve tried cutting corners with some off-brands in my rentals, thinking it wouldn’t matter, but I always end up fixing drips or swapping them out sooner than I’d like. “Safe” style isn’t glamorous, but if it means less maintenance calls, I’ll take it. The only time I regretted the cheaper route was when a faucet handle literally snapped off in a tenant’s hand... not a great look.
I hear you on Delta—they’re kind of the Toyota of faucets. Not flashy, but they just keep working. I’ve swapped out enough mystery-brand handles to learn my lesson too. Moen’s been pretty reliable for me as well, especially if you want something that doesn’t look like it belongs in a dentist’s office. The cheap stuff always seems like a good idea until you’re crawling under a sink at 9pm because someone’s got Niagara Falls in their bathroom...
Delta and Moen both seem to have their fan clubs, but I’ve had mixed results with each—maybe it’s just the quirks of my 1920s house. A few things I’ve noticed:
-
Delta—they’re kind of the Toyota of faucets. Not flashy, but they just keep working.
That’s fair, but I’ve had a couple Delta cartridges seize up after 8-10 years. Not terrible, but not “forever” either. At least parts are easy to find.
- Moen’s been solid for me too, especially their older single-handle stuff. The newer ones look better, but I swear the finish on my 15-year-old Moen is holding up better than the one I put in last year.
- For toilets, I’m still running an old American Standard Cadet that refuses to die. It’s not “efficient” by modern standards, but it never clogs and the parts are dirt cheap. The newer low-flow models seem hit or miss—some flush like a champ, others you’re plunging every week.
- Avoiding “mystery brands” is key. I once tried a fancy European faucet (can’t even remember the name) because it looked cool... ended up with a leaky mess and no way to get replacement parts without ordering from overseas.
- One thing I wonder: does anyone else find that some of these new “lifetime warranty” claims are more hassle than they’re worth? Had a Kohler faucet where the finish started peeling after three years—sure, they sent a replacement part, but it took weeks and a ton of back-and-forth.
- If you’re dealing with old plumbing like me, sometimes the best bet is just sticking with brands that have been around forever. At least you know you’ll be able to get parts when something inevitably goes sideways.
Curious if anyone’s had luck with newer brands like Pfister or Grohe? Or is it just safer to stick with the classics and call it good?
