Remodeling discussions and local services.

Swapping out old faucets and toilets - what brands actually last?

551 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I hear you on the eco models - sometimes I feel like I’m washing my hands forever just to get the soap off. I swapped out a builder-grade faucet for a Moen last year, and here’s what worked for me:

1. Shut off the water (learned that the hard way once...).
2. Loosen the old faucet with a basin wrench - those things are lifesavers in tight spots.
3. Clean up all the old gunk and mineral buildup before installing the new one.
4. Install the new faucet, making sure to use plumber’s tape on any threaded connections.

Moen’s held up pretty well so far, even with our hard water. Still, I do miss the old-school flow sometimes - those eco restrictors can be a pain when you’re in a rush.


Reply

Moen’s held up pretty well so far, even with our hard water. Still, I do miss the old-school flow sometimes - those eco restrictors can be a pain when you’re in a rush.

You nailed it with the basin wrench tip - those things are worth their weight in gold under an old farmhouse sink. I totally get missing the “real” water flow. In my 1920s place, I swapped out a leaky relic for a WaterSense model and yeah, it’s not quite the same, but I keep telling myself every little bit helps. The trick is finding that balance between saving water and not losing your mind trying to rinse off suds. You’re doing great - sometimes just getting through one of these projects without flooding the kitchen feels like a win.


Reply
zelda_shadow

Totally hear you on the WaterSense models - sometimes it feels like you need three hands just to rinse a pan. But honestly, getting through a faucet swap without a disaster is half the battle. Those old farmhouse setups can be brutal. I’ve seen Moen last a long time, but yeah, nothing quite matches the old-school flow. Still, saving water’s not a bad trade-off, even if it takes some getting used to.


Reply
climber35

Swapping out old faucets and toilets - what brands actually last?

Yeah, those WaterSense models are a bit of a double-edged sword. I get the water savings, but man, I’ve had a few where you’re basically waving a pan under a trickle, hoping for the best. I swapped out a 70s-era faucet in one flip last year - thing was built like a tank, but the finish was shot and it leaked if you looked at it wrong. Replaced it with a Delta, which was fine, but you could tell right away the flow just wasn’t the same. Still, no leaks and it’s been holding up, so I’ll take that trade.

Old farmhouse setups are their own beast. I once spent half a day just getting a rusted nut off a cast iron sink. Ended up with a busted knuckle and a few new curse words. Sometimes I wonder if the old stuff was overbuilt or if we’re just getting soft with all these “tool-free” installs.

Moen’s been solid for me, too. I’ve had a couple that outlasted two tenants and still looked decent. Kohler’s another one I trust, especially for toilets. I put in a Kohler Cimarron in my own place - flushes like a champ, even with the lower GPF. American Standard’s hit or miss, but their Cadet line isn’t bad for the price.

Honestly, I do miss the old-school flow sometimes, especially when you’re trying to fill a mop bucket or rinse out paint trays. But I guess if it means the water bill doesn’t make me wince, I can live with it. Just wish they’d find a way to save water without making you work so hard for it.

Biggest advice? Don’t cheap out on the shutoff valves and supply lines. Learned that the hard way after a “budget” valve let go in the middle of the night. Nothing like waking up to the sound of running water and realizing your kitchen’s turned into a wading pool...


Reply
raint16

Honestly, I do miss the old-school flow sometimes, especially when you’re trying to fill a mop bucket or rinse out paint trays.

I hear you on the weak flow, but honestly, I’ve had a few newer WaterSense faucets that surprised me. Some of the aerators are actually pretty clever - feels like more water than it is. Grohe’s been a sleeper hit for me, especially in rentals. Not cheap, but they seem to handle tenant abuse better than Delta or Moen in my experience. And I’ll take a “tool-free” install over wrestling with 40-year-old plumbing any day... my knuckles are still recovering from my last “vintage” project.


Reply
nancyanimator

Grohe’s solid, I’ll give you that, but I’ve had mixed luck with their cartridges over time - maybe just bad batches? Delta’s tool-free stuff is a lifesaver for tight spaces, though I’ve noticed their chrome finish scratches easier than it used to. Anyone tried Kohler’s newer lines? I keep hearing they’re upping their game durability-wise, but haven’t put one through the wringer myself. Always feels like a trade-off between ease of install and long-term reliability...


Reply

Always feels like a trade-off between ease of install and long-term reliability...

That’s the eternal struggle, isn’t it? I’ve swapped out more faucets than I care to admit - sometimes it feels like I’m running a plumbing test lab instead of managing rentals. Delta’s tool-free stuff is a real time saver when you’re wedged under a sink that’s seen better days, but yeah, the chrome finish does seem to scuff up faster now. Maybe they’re using a new process, or maybe I’m just noticing it more because tenants are getting creative with their cleaning supplies.

As for Kohler, I’ve put a few of their newer models in some mid-tier units. No horror stories yet - install was pretty straightforward, and so far, no leaks or weird handle issues. But it’s only been about a year, so the jury’s still out on long-term durability. If they hold up, I might start switching over more units. At the end of the day, I’d love something that installs itself and never breaks, but until then, I’ll just keep my toolbox handy...


Reply
richardskier

I get what you mean about the “eternal struggle” - it’s like you can have quick installs or bulletproof finishes, but rarely both. But I have to gently push back on the Delta chrome finish thing. I’ve actually had better luck with their matte black and brushed nickel lines. The chrome does seem to show every little scratch, but the matte finishes hide a lot of sins, especially in high-traffic spaces. Maybe it’s just me, but I’ve noticed tenants are less likely to go wild with abrasive cleaners if the faucet looks a bit more “designer.”

Delta’s tool-free stuff is a real time saver when you’re wedged under a sink that’s seen better days, but yeah, the chrome finish does seem to scuff up faster now.

On the Kohler front, I totally hear you about waiting to see how they hold up. I’ve had one of their Artifacts faucets in my own place for about three years now - no leaks, no weirdness, and it still looks sharp. Maybe it’s luck, or maybe it’s just that I’m more careful at home than tenants are in rentals... Hard to say. Sometimes I wonder if the “install and forget” dream is just that - a dream. But hey, at least we get to play with all the new finishes and styles along the way.


Reply

Matte black is a lifesaver for hiding fingerprints and water spots - totally agree there. I swapped out a bunch of chrome fixtures for brushed nickel in my rentals, and maintenance calls dropped off a ton. Tenants seem less tempted to attack those with steel wool or whatever mystery scrubber they use. As for “install and forget,” I think the closest I’ve come is with Toto toilets. I put a Drake in my own place about five years ago and haven’t touched it since. Faucets, though... still chasing that unicorn.


Reply
coffee141

As for “install and forget,” I think the closest I’ve come is with Toto toilets. I put a Drake in my own place about five years ago and haven’t touched it since. Faucets, though... still chasing that unicorn.

Right there with you on Toto - Drake’s been bulletproof for me too. Faucets are tricky. Even the pricier ones seem to need a cartridge swap or develop a drip after a few years. Brushed nickel holds up way better in rentals, yeah. Haven’t found a faucet brand that’s truly “install and forget” either, but Moen’s been less hassle than most in my experience. Keep at it - sounds like you’re making smart swaps.


Reply
marleywolf951

- Funny, I thought Moen was supposed to be the “set it and forget it” brand, but my kitchen one started leaking after just two years. Maybe I got a dud?
- Brushed nickel definitely hides fingerprints better than chrome - learned that the hard way with my last faucet.
- Toto Drake seems to be the gold standard for toilets. Wish faucets were that reliable...
- Anyone tried Delta? I keep seeing mixed reviews, but the warranty looks solid.
- Still hunting for that unicorn faucet myself. Maybe it’s just not out there.


Reply

Maybe it’s just not out there.

I’ve wondered the same thing about Moen - mine’s original to the house (1920s) and still works, but it’s definitely not as smooth as it used to be. Maybe they just don’t make ‘em like they used to? I’ve been eyeing Delta too, but the mixed reviews make me hesitate. Anyone else notice that older fixtures, even unbranded ones, seem to last forever compared to the new stuff? Or am I just nostalgic for things that don’t leak every couple years...


Reply
ajohnson46

- Older fixtures really do seem to last longer - probably because they used more brass and less plastic back then.
- Moen and Delta are both decent, but I’ve noticed Delta’s newer stuff can be hit or miss depending on the model.
- If you want something that’ll last, look for solid brass internals (not just “brass finish”).
- I’ve had good luck with American Standard for toilets - parts are easy to find, and they’re not as finicky as some of the newer “water-saving” models.
- Sometimes it’s worth rebuilding the old faucet if you can find the parts... those things were built like tanks.


Reply
sophie_robinson

Sometimes it’s worth rebuilding the old faucet if you can find the parts... those things were built like tanks.

I’m with you on that. I’ve got a 1940s Crane sink in my upstairs bath, and when the hot side started dripping, I figured I’d have to swap the whole thing. Ended up tracking down a replacement washer and packing nut at a local hardware store that still stocks old plumbing bits. Took maybe an hour, and now it’s smooth as butter - plus, it just feels sturdier than anything I’ve seen at the big box stores lately.

If you’re thinking about swapping out fixtures, here’s what’s worked for me:

1. Check for solid brass or at least heavy metal internals. I’ve noticed some “brass finish” stuff is just plastic underneath, which never seems to last.
2. For toilets, I agree - American Standard is hard to beat for reliability and easy-to-find parts. I’ve got one from the late ‘80s that’s still going strong.
3. Don’t overlook Kohler for toilets either. They’re a bit pricier, but I’ve had one in my downstairs powder room for 15+ years and it’s never given me trouble.
4. If you’re replacing a faucet, keep the old one around for parts. Sometimes the little bits - like screws or handles - come in handy down the line.

One thing I’m curious about: has anyone tried the newer “ceramic disc” cartridges? I keep hearing they’re supposed to last longer than the old rubber washers, but I’ve only ever used them in newer Moen models. Not sure if they’re really all that much better or just marketing hype.

And about the water-saving toilets - some of them are so finicky. I had one that needed two flushes half the time, which kind of defeats the purpose. Anyone found a model that actually works well without being a pain?

Curious what folks have found when it comes to mixing old and new - like, is it worth hunting for vintage parts, or do you just bite the bullet and go modern if something major fails?


Reply
web279

I’ve swapped out a couple old faucets for ones with ceramic disc cartridges - mostly Delta and Grohe. They do seem smoother and I haven’t had to mess with drips yet, but I wonder how they’ll hold up after 10-15 years. The old-school stuff just keeps going if you can find the bits. On toilets, I tried a Toto Drake after getting fed up with double-flushing a “high efficiency” model... night and day difference. Anyone ever retrofit an old tank with modern guts, or is that just asking for trouble?


Reply

Retrofitting an old tank isn’t always a bad idea, honestly. I swapped out the guts in a 70s American Standard with a Fluidmaster kit and it’s been working fine for years. Just double-check the fit - sometimes the old tanks are a weird size or shape, so you might need to get creative. It’s way cheaper than a new toilet, and if you’re handy, not too much hassle.


Reply

That’s a solid approach - sometimes those old tanks have more life in them than folks realize. I’ve done similar retrofits in a few rental units, and it’s surprising how reliable they can be with updated internals. You’re right about the fit, though... had one where I had to trim the fill valve just to get the lid back on. It’s a good reminder that a little creativity can save a lot of money, especially if you’re managing multiple properties.


Reply

It’s a good reminder that a little creativity can save a lot of money, especially if you’re managing multiple properties.

- Couldn’t agree more - my motto is “if it ain’t leaking, it’s still got potential.”
- For faucets, I’ve had Moen outlast just about everything else. They’re not the cheapest, but I swear they survive tenants who think “gentle” is a setting on the washing machine.
- Toilets... honestly, old American Standards are like cockroaches. I’ve got one from the 80s that’s seen more action than my first car and still flushes like a champ.
- That said, I tried swapping in some off-brand stuff once to save a buck - regretted it. Spent more time fixing leaks than I did installing them. Lesson learned: cheap up front usually means expensive later.
- And yeah, trimming fill valves or wrestling with weird tank shapes is basically a rite of passage. If you haven’t had to MacGyver a part with a hacksaw and some creative language, are you even in this business?

If you find something that actually lasts longer than my patience with plumbing repairs, let me know...


Reply
jsniper94

If you haven’t had to MacGyver a part with a hacksaw and some creative language, are you even in this business?

That line made me laugh - been there way too many times. I’ll second you on Moen for faucets; they just seem to take a beating and keep working. I’ve had mixed luck with Kohler, though - sometimes solid, sometimes the finish flakes off faster than I’d expect. Old American Standards really are tanks, but finding parts for those relics can be a pain. Honestly, I think half the job is just figuring out which brands won’t make you regret your life choices six months down the road.


Reply

Honestly, I think half the job is just figuring out which brands won’t make you regret your life choices six months down the road.

Isn’t that the truth? I swear, if I had a nickel for every time I’ve stared at a leaking faucet and thought, “Well, this is karma for buying the ‘good deal’ brand,” I’d have enough to actually buy a Grohe.

I’m with you on Moen - those things are practically indestructible, and the cartridges are easy to swap. Plus, they tend to be more forgiving if you’re trying to keep things eco-friendly. Their newer models actually have some solid low-flow options that don’t feel like you’re washing your hands in a drizzle.

Kohler’s a weird one for me too. Some of their stuff looks great out of the box, but I’ve seen finishes pit or flake off way sooner than they should. Not always, but enough that I’d hesitate to put them in a rental or anywhere that sees heavy use.

American Standard is basically the cockroach of fixtures - just refuses to die. But yeah, hunting down a replacement part for a 30-year-old toilet can turn into a full-on archaeological dig. I’ve had luck with some of the newer Toto toilets as well. They’re not always the cheapest, but the internals seem to hold up, and they’re usually pretty water-efficient. Not to mention, parts are surprisingly easy to find (at least where I am).

One thing I will say - sometimes it’s worth looking at how easy a fixture is to repair before buying. Some brands make you replace the whole assembly for a $2 seal that’s buried in some proprietary housing. Others are actually designed so you can fix them without needing a degree in engineering or a third arm.

Anyway, if I never have to hacksaw another corroded nut off an old faucet again, it’ll be too soon... but who am I kidding? That’s basically a rite of passage at this point.


Reply
Scroll to Top