Remodeling discussions and local services.

 
Discussion options
Discussion options
[#682]

How picky are you about checking your own reno work?

Every time I finish a project (like, I just redid my bathroom floor), I get super anxious about whether I actually did it “right.” Sometimes I’ll do a mini-inspection myself, other times I just kinda wing it and hope for the best. Curious - do you folks actually follow some kind of checklist or just eyeball stuff? Ever called in a pro after the fact, or just lived with your own mistakes?


Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

115 replies

jonparker183

Title: How picky are you about checking your own reno work?

I get where you’re coming from - after I tiled my kitchen backsplash, I must’ve stared at those grout lines for hours, convinced I’d missed something. I’m definitely the checklist type, but even then, there’s always that nagging feeling I overlooked a step or didn’t get the spacing perfect. Sometimes I’ll even take photos and zoom in just to see if anything looks off (probably overkill, but it helps me sleep).

That said, I’ve learned that “good enough” is sometimes… well, good enough. Unless it’s something structural or waterproofing-related, I try not to stress too much. There was one time I had to call in a plumber after a DIY sink install went sideways - expensive lesson, but I chalked it up to experience.

Honestly, most people don’t notice the little imperfections we obsess over. If it works and looks decent, that’s a win in my book.


Reply
jessicaking557

I totally get the zooming in on photos - been there, done that, probably too many times. For me, it’s a weird mix of wanting things to look great but also knowing I’ll drive myself nuts if I chase perfection. I always tell myself, “If it’s solid and eco-friendly, I’m happy.” But then I’ll spot a slightly crooked tile and suddenly I’m rethinking my life choices... At the end of the day, if it functions and doesn’t waste resources, I call it a win.


Reply

I get hung up on the little stuff too, especially after spending hours on a project. Sometimes I’ll notice a grout line that’s just a hair off and it bugs me for days. But honestly, if it’s sturdy and does the job, I try not to sweat it. Perfection’s overrated - function and sustainability matter way more in the long run.


Reply
cloud_coder Topic starter

I once spent an entire afternoon squinting at a quarter-inch gap under a baseboard, convinced it would haunt me forever. But then I remembered my house is 120 years old and nothing’s straight anyway. At some point, “good enough” becomes a survival tactic, especially if you want to keep your sanity (and your weekends).


Reply
art_rachel

I get hung up on those little gaps too, especially when I know exactly how much caulk or wood filler it would take to fix it. But then I start thinking about the cost - both time and money - and whether anyone but me will ever notice. Sometimes I wonder if obsessing over every imperfection is worth it, or if it's just part of owning an old house. Do you ever find yourself weighing the price of “perfect” against just moving on?


Reply
fitness488

I get where you're coming from, but I actually see those little gaps as a chance to try something different. Instead of reaching for the caulk every time, I’ve started using scrap wood or even leftover paper pulp as filler. It’s cheaper, and honestly, it feels good knowing I’m not just tossing stuff in the landfill.

Sometimes I wonder if obsessing over every imperfection is worth it, or if it's just part of owning an old house.

For me, it’s less about perfection and more about making creative choices that fit the vibe of the place. Those quirks can add character - sometimes I leave a small gap if it tells a story or reminds me of what was there before. Not everyone notices, but I like knowing it’s intentional.


Reply

Title: How picky are you about checking your own reno work?

For me, it’s less about perfection and more about making creative choices that fit the vibe of the place. Those quirks can add character - sometimes I leave a small gap if it tells a story or reminds me of what was there before.

Interesting take. I get the appeal of letting some quirks show, especially in older homes where nothing is perfectly square anyway. Still, I tend to look at gaps as potential trouble spots down the line - moisture, pests, even just drafts in the wrong place can cause issues. Using scrap wood as filler is clever, but I’d be careful with paper pulp in high-moisture areas. It might not hold up over time.

I’m curious, do you ever run into problems later on with those more unconventional fillers? Sometimes I’ve seen folks get creative but then have to redo things a year or two later because the material didn’t last. Or maybe that’s part of the charm for you - fixing things as they evolve?


Reply

Honestly, I get twitchy if I spot a gap, especially in spots where water or critters might sneak in. My place is old enough that nothing’s square, but I still try to seal things up tight - learned the hard way after a squirrel found its way into my kitchen one winter. Ever tried chasing a squirrel with a broom? Not fun. I’ll fudge a little on paint lines or uneven trim, but if it’s structural or could cause bigger headaches, I’m all about overkill. Character’s great until it starts costing you sleep...


Reply
mtaylor91

I totally get where you’re coming from about sealing up every possible gap - old houses have a way of teaching you lessons you never asked for. I had a raccoon situation last year that still makes me shudder. It found a way in through what looked like a harmless little crack behind the gutter. I’d been so focused on making sure my reclaimed wood trim was lined up just right that I ignored the less glamorous stuff, like flashing and caulking. Big mistake. That raccoon was basically a demolition crew in fur.

I’m all for character, but I draw the line at anything that could compromise the envelope of the house. Air leaks, moisture, critters - those are the things that’ll undo all your hard work and green upgrades in no time. I’ll admit, I’m probably more obsessive about insulation and air sealing than most people. If it’s visible, I can live with a little imperfection (honestly, sometimes those quirks are what make an old place feel alive), but if it’s hidden and could turn into mold or pest damage, I go overboard.

Funny thing is, once you start thinking about energy loss and sustainability, it’s hard to unsee all the places where your house is bleeding heat or letting in drafts. I’ve spent hours with a smoke pencil and thermal camera just chasing down cold spots. Sometimes it feels like overkill, but then winter hits and my heating bill isn’t through the roof... totally worth it.

Paint lines? Meh. But gaps? That’s where I get twitchy too. Guess some things are just non-negotiable if you want to sleep at night - literally and figuratively.


Reply
gardener36

Totally relate to that “demolition crew in fur” vibe - mine was a squirrel, but same chaos. I used to care way more about keeping the original plaster perfect, but after that winter with drafts sneaking in everywhere, I’m all about sealing up the hidden stuff. Character’s great, but not when it comes with a side of wildlife.


Reply
jackwhiskers337

Yeah, I hear you on the “character” thing - sometimes old houses just have a little too much personality, especially when it comes with teeth or claws. I used to be a stickler for keeping every bit of original trim and plaster, but after patching up squirrel-sized holes and chasing drafts all winter, priorities definitely shift. Curious - do you ever find yourself second-guessing if you’ve sealed everything up, or do you just trust your work and move on? I swear, sometimes I’ll be lying in bed at night wondering if I missed a gap somewhere behind the walls...


Reply
btaylor91

Yeah, I hear you on the “character” thing - sometimes old houses just have a little too much personality, especially when it comes with teeth or claws.

I get what you mean about lying in bed, replaying every possible spot you might’ve missed. But honestly, I think there’s a point where you just have to trust your process and accept that perfection isn’t realistic - especially on a budget. I used to obsess over every draft, but after a while, I realized chasing every tiny gap can get expensive and exhausting. Sometimes “good enough” really is good enough, at least until the next big project rolls around.


Reply
pault69

Sometimes “good enough” really is good enough, at least until the next big project rolls around.

Totally get this. I used to stress over every uneven line or paint drip, but after a few renos, I realized most people never notice. If it’s functional and looks decent, I move on. Perfection’s overrated.


Reply
paulw41

I get what you mean, but I’m still stuck on the “check it three times” phase. Maybe it’s just my personality, but if I see a crooked outlet cover or a patchy paint spot, it bugs me every time I walk by. Drives my partner nuts because I’ll redo stuff that’s “fine” to everyone else.

That said, I’m starting to realize you’re right -

most people never notice
. I spent like an hour fixing one tiny tile in the bathroom and literally no one has commented (or probably even looked at it). Guess I’m learning to let go... slowly. Still, there’s something satisfying about getting those little details right, even if it’s just for my own peace of mind. Maybe one day I’ll be able to walk past a slightly uneven shelf without thinking about it. For now, though, the level stays out.


Reply
rperez62

Honestly, I think those little details matter more than people admit. Sure, most folks won’t notice a single tile, but the overall vibe just feels more polished when everything lines up. I say embrace the level - perfectionism can be its own kind of creativity.


Reply

Title: How picky are you about checking your own reno work?

I get what you mean about the details, but sometimes I think we can get a little too hung up on perfection. I’ve spent way too many hours agonizing over grout lines that literally no one else will ever notice. At some point, I just have to remind myself - this is a home, not a museum. If the vibe feels good and nothing’s falling off the wall, I call it a win. Besides, a little “character” never hurt anyone... right?


Reply
briangamerpro

I get caught up in the details too, but honestly, I’ve learned the hard way that chasing perfection can drive you nuts. Last year I redid my kitchen backsplash and spent hours trying to get every tile lined up just right. My wife walked in, glanced around, and said, “Looks great!” Meanwhile, I was convinced the whole wall was crooked. Now, if it’s solid and looks good from across the room, I try not to sweat it too much. A little imperfection just gives it some soul, in my opinion.


Reply
cloud_coder Topic starter

I hear you on the perfectionism front. Living in a 1920s house, if I tried to make every corner square and every floorboard level, I’d be living in a padded cell by now. I once spent an entire afternoon trying to get a door to hang straight, only to realize the whole frame was off by nearly an inch. Now, if it opens and closes without trapping anyone inside, I call it a win. Sometimes, you just have to embrace the “historic charm” and move on.


Reply
dennisf47

Title: How picky are you about checking your own reno work?

Totally get it. My place is from the 1910s and nothing is straight - walls, floors, you name it. I used to stress over every little imperfection, but now I just remind myself that a little wonkiness is part of the story. If it works and looks decent, that’s good enough for me.


Reply
Scroll to Top