Remodeling discussions and local services.

Lighting up the backyard fence: solar, wired, or something else?

789 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I get the appeal of mixing things up, but I’ll admit I’m a bit more old-school about it. Our place is from the 1920s and I’ve found that too much variety in lighting can sometimes clash with the vibe of an older home. Maybe it’s just me, but when I tried string lights and solar lanterns together last summer, it ended up looking a little haphazard - like a yard sale after dark. The warm white bulbs helped, but the different shapes and brightness levels kind of fought each other.

I do agree that wired lights are worth the hassle if you want something that lasts (especially in weird weather), but I actually like sticking to one or two styles max. It feels calmer, especially with all the quirks these old houses already have going on. That said, I totally get wanting a lived-in look - just think there’s a sweet spot between “eclectic” and “random.” Maybe it depends on the house? Some places can pull off that patchwork charm better than others.


Reply
comics653

just think there’s a sweet spot between “eclectic” and “random.” Maybe it depends on the house? Some places can pull off that patchwork charm better than others.

Totally get what you mean about the “yard sale after dark” vibe - been there myself. I once tried mixing vintage lanterns with some modern LED strips on a 1940s bungalow flip, thinking it’d look quirky and fun. Instead, it felt like the lighting equivalent of wearing plaid with polka dots. Ended up dialing it back to just globe string lights, and suddenly the whole space felt intentional, not chaotic.

Curious - have you ever tried using dimmers or smart bulbs to help unify different fixtures? Sometimes tweaking brightness makes a bigger difference than I expected, especially when the styles don’t quite match.


Reply
writing_katie2588

Honestly, I think sometimes a little “mismatch” can actually work, especially outdoors. Not every backyard needs to look like a catalog spread. I’ve seen folks mix solar lanterns with hardwired sconces and it just feels lived-in, not messy. Dimmers and smart bulbs help, sure, but sometimes the trick is just repeating one element - like using the same color temp across different fixtures. That alone can tie things together even if the styles are all over the place.


Reply
patr10

I get the appeal of a “lived-in” look, but I’ve seen mismatched lighting go sideways fast - especially when the color temps are just a little off. Even if you nail the same Kelvin, sometimes the quality of light from solar vs. wired fixtures is just... different. Solar can be dimmer or have that bluish cast, and it ends up feeling accidental instead of intentional. I’m all for mixing things up, but I think there’s a fine line between eclectic and chaotic. Maybe it’s just my eye, but I’d rather commit to one type and play with placement or fixture shape instead.


Reply

“Solar can be dimmer or have that bluish cast, and it ends up feeling accidental instead of intentional.”

I totally get what you mean about the accidental vibe. I tried mixing solar and plug-in string lights along my fence last summer, thinking it’d look “layered.” Instead, it was like a weird patchwork - some spots glowed warm and cozy, others looked almost hospital-ish. My partner kept asking if we’d left a flashlight out. I’m still tempted by solar for the easy install, but I’m starting to think you’re right about sticking to one type and just moving them around for effect.


Reply
cocobaker

- I actually think mixing solar and plug-in can still work, but it’s all about picking the right bulbs and being picky about color temp.
- Some of those solar lights are super blue, but I’ve found a few brands that do a warmer white - closer to the plug-in vibe.
- One trick I’ve used: pop out a test bulb before buying a whole set. If it’s too cold or dim, back it goes.
- Layering can look intentional if you’re careful about placement - like using solar on the far corners or spots you don’t want to run cords, then plug-ins where you want more punch.
- Totally get the “hospital” look though. Had a client’s patio end up looking like an ER waiting room until we swapped out the bluer lights for warm LEDs.
- If you’re still tempted by solar, maybe try a couple of the new “Edison-style” ones - they’re not as harsh and blend better with plug-in strands.
- It’s a bit of trial and error, but sometimes mixing pays off if you’re patient (and picky).


Reply
adventure626

- I actually think mixing solar and plug-in can still work, but it’s all about picking the right bulbs and being picky about color temp. - Some of those solar lights are super blue, but I’ve fo...

Mixing solar and plug-in can definitely work if you’re picky about the details. I’ve run into that “ER waiting room” look too - funny how just swapping out a few bulbs can totally change the vibe. The Edison-style solar lights are a solid call; they’re not perfect, but they blend better than most. I’d just watch out for cheap solar brands that fade after a season. Have you noticed any issues with solar brightness dropping off after a few months? That’s been my main gripe, but maybe the newer models are holding up better.


Reply
gamer91

Yeah, I’ve had the same issue with solar lights losing their punch after a while. Last summer, half of mine were barely a glowworm by August. I switched to a pricier set this year - so far, so good, but I’m not holding my breath. Mixing in a few plug-ins near the seating area helped a ton for actual light where I need it. The rest is just for looks anyway.


Reply

I’ve had similar luck with solar - after a couple seasons, they just don’t hold up. In my case, I ended up running low-voltage wired lights along the fence. It took some work, but honestly, the consistency is worth it. Solar’s fine for accent, but I need to see where I’m going, not just trip over the dog.


Reply

I hear you on the solar lights - mine looked great for about a year, then started flickering like a haunted house. Wired lighting does take more effort, but it’s hard to beat that reliability. If you want a softer vibe, I’ve mixed in some string lights too... just for a bit of whimsy. Sometimes it’s less about seeing every step and more about setting a mood, right?


Reply
bearallen526

Totally get what you mean about the solar lights - mine started acting up after the first winter, too. It’s kind of a bummer when you put in the effort and then they go all spooky on you. Mixing in string lights is such a good idea though, especially for that cozy vibe. I’ve actually started layering a few different types, like some low-voltage wired spots for the main areas and then string lights for the mood. It’s a bit of work upfront, but I found it’s worth it when you’re out there in the evening and everything just feels right. Don’t stress if it takes a few tries to get the look you want... I’m still tweaking mine every season.


Reply
nseeker70

I can relate to the frustration with solar lights not holding up. I tried a set last year, thinking they’d be low-maintenance, but after a few months of cold and rain, half of them were flickering or just dead. I do appreciate the simplicity, but reliability was a letdown.

I noticed you mentioned layering different types -

“I’ve actually started layering a few different types, like some low-voltage wired spots for the main areas and then string lights for the mood.”
- which is pretty much where I landed after some trial and error. I ended up running low-voltage wires along the fence for consistent lighting, then added plug-in string lights for atmosphere. The upfront work was more than I expected (digging a shallow trench for the wiring wasn’t my favorite weekend), but it’s been solid since.

One thing I’d add: if you’re mixing systems, keep an eye on how you’re powering everything. I underestimated how many outlets I’d need and had to rethink placement. Not sure if there’s a perfect solution, but having a mix does seem to balance reliability and that cozy look. Still tweaking mine too... it’s kind of an ongoing experiment.


Reply
rbarkley94

Yeah, I totally get what you mean about the solar lights. I was so optimistic when I first put them in - like, “Hey, free energy, what could go wrong?” Turns out, a lot. Mine barely made it through one winter before they started acting up. I guess the weather just beats them up over time.

Mixing wired and plug-in lights sounds like a smart move, though. I’ve been debating if it’s worth the hassle to run wires, but hearing that it’s been reliable for you makes me think maybe I should just bite the bullet. The trench-digging part is definitely not appealing... but neither is replacing dead solar lights every few months.

The outlet thing is such a pain, too. I didn’t realize how quickly you run out of places to plug stuff in until I started adding more lights. Extension cords everywhere isn’t exactly the look I’m going for. Still, your setup sounds like a good balance between practical and cozy. Makes me feel better knowing it’s kind of an ongoing experiment for everyone, not just me figuring it out as I go.


Reply
guitarist40

I hear you on the trench-digging - when we rewired the old carriage lights along our fence, I swore I’d never voluntarily dig another foot of dirt. But honestly, once it was done, I stopped worrying about whether the lights would work after every storm. The only thing that caught me off guard was how much brighter wired lights are compared to solar. Sometimes it almost feels too modern for the house, but I guess that’s the tradeoff. Have you thought about low-voltage systems? They’re a bit less invasive than full wiring, and I’ve seen neighbors have good luck with them. Just curious if anyone’s tried those with older fences - wondering if they hold up better than solar in the long run.


Reply
williamw76

Low-voltage systems are interesting, but honestly, I’ve found they’re not always the silver bullet people make them out to be. I tried them on an older property - looked great at first, but over time, the connections started to corrode and the light output dropped. Wired is more work up front, sure, but it’s way more reliable long-term, especially if you’re thinking about value down the line. Solar’s just too hit-or-miss in my experience, unless you’re somewhere with perfect sun exposure year-round. If you’re investing in curb appeal or resale, I’d lean wired every time, even if it feels a bit too “new.”


Reply
susany59

Wired’s definitely the way I’d go if you want something that just works and lasts. I tried solar on my last place - looked good for a few months, then half the lights were dead by winter. Upfront cost hurts, but you don’t have to mess with it later.


Reply
collector68

Had a client swear by solar for their fence, but come January, half the lights were just sad little glimmers.

“looked good for a few months, then half the lights were dead by winter.”
I get the appeal - no trenching, no wires - but I’ve seen more headaches than not. Wired’s a pain upfront, sure, but you’re not swapping dead batteries every few weeks when it gets cold. Still, part of me wonders if newer solar tech is any better now...


Reply

“looked good for a few months, then half the lights were dead by winter.”

That’s exactly what I’ve seen too - solar looks dreamy in the catalog, but in real life? Not so much once the days get short and gloomy. I get the no-wires appeal, but I’d rather deal with a little trenching than have my fence look like it’s half celebrating Christmas and half mourning it. Maybe the newer solar stuff is better, but unless you’re in Arizona, I’m still skeptical. Wired just feels more reliable, even if it’s a pain at first.


Reply

Wired’s definitely more work up front, but I’ve never had to worry about them conking out mid-winter. I tried solar along my last property’s back fence - looked decent through the summer, but by November, half were flickering or just dead. Maybe it’s our cloudy weather, but it felt like I was always fiddling with batteries or repositioning panels.

I get the appeal of skipping the trenching, though. Digging in rocky soil is a pain, and I’ve had to rent a trencher more than once. Still, once it’s done, you don’t have to think about it for years. The only thing that’s made me pause is low-voltage landscape lighting. It’s not totally wireless, but it’s way easier to install than full 120V and seems to hold up better than solar. Has anyone had those fail in winter? I’m tempted to try them on my next flip, just not sure if they’re really that much better.


Reply

I’ve only messed with low-voltage lights once, but honestly, they handled our gross, wet winter better than I expected. The connectors were a bit finicky at install, but nothing died or got super dim. Didn’t have to dig nearly as much either, which was a relief. If you’re flipping and want something that won’t need babysitting, it’s probably a decent bet. Solar’s just too unpredictable here - clouds ruin everything.


Reply
Scroll to Top