Remodeling discussions and local services.

Ever regretted a fireplace facelift? Quick poll time

385 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

rachelanimator

Plus, those materials have their own history, which just adds to the vibe.

Not sure I’m totally on board with the “go bold or go home” approach. I get that “beige on beige just doesn’t have a story to tell,” but sometimes restraint is underrated. There’s something to be said for subtlety, especially if you’re dealing with a space that already has a lot going on architecturally.

I actually spent weeks agonizing over whether to do a dramatic tile or keep things more neutral for my own fireplace. In the end, I went with a classic herringbone brick - nothing wild, but it fits the bones of the house and doesn’t compete with the original trim (which is honestly the star). Maybe it’s not as “offbeat,” but I’m not worried about hating it in five years, either.

And about natural materials - totally agree they ground a space, but even those can look out of place if you don’t pay attention to scale and proportion. I’ve seen some reclaimed wood mantels that just overwhelm everything else. Sometimes less really is more, especially if you’re not 100% sure what your style even is yet.


Reply
ocean223

Totally get what you mean about restraint. I once tried to go “bold” with a deep green tile surround - looked amazing for about three months, then I realized it clashed with literally everything else. Ended up repainting the whole room. Neutral herringbone sounds like a safe bet. Ever notice how the “statement” stuff dates itself so fast?


Reply
andrewwalker

Ever notice how the “statement” stuff dates itself so fast?

Yeah, it’s wild how fast that happens. I did a geometric cement tile on my fireplace surround a few years ago - thought it was gonna be this timeless, modern thing. Now I cringe every time I see it in photos because it totally hijacks the whole room. Ended up covering most of it with plants and a big mirror just to tone it down. Neutral always seems boring at first, but you never regret it later.


Reply

I totally get what you mean about the “statement” stuff. Funny thing is, I did a bold navy paint on my fireplace wall thinking it’d be super chic - now it just feels like it’s shouting at me every time I walk in. But honestly, I still think some personality is worth the risk.

Neutral always seems boring at first, but you never regret it later.
I dunno, sometimes I miss having that pop, even if it does date itself. Anyone else ever swing back and forth on this?


Reply
jon_evans

I painted my old brick fireplace a deep forest green once - looked amazing for about six months, then I started feeling like it was the only thing I could see in the room. But when I went back to white, it just felt... flat? I think there’s always a bit of regret either way, honestly. Sometimes you just need that bold choice to shake things up, even if you end up repainting later.


Reply
jerrygeocacher

Title: Ever regretted a fireplace facelift? Quick poll time

I get what you mean about bold choices feeling overwhelming after a while. I once tried a “natural” limewash on my fireplace, thinking it’d give me that rustic, cozy vibe. Looked great for a bit, but then the color started to fade weirdly and I realized it just wasn’t holding up to the mess of daily life (kids, dog, you name it). Ended up scrubbing it off and going with a recycled tile surround instead. Not as dramatic, but way less maintenance and I don’t find myself second-guessing it every time I walk in the room.

Honestly, I think fireplaces are just one of those features where you’re never totally satisfied for long. You want them to stand out, but not take over. Sometimes the “safe” colors just feel boring, but the bold ones can get old fast. I guess the upside is, paint’s easy to change if you get sick of it... but yeah, I’ve definitely had my share of fireplace regrets.


Reply

I totally get where you're coming from. I did a whitewash on my old brick fireplace last year, thinking it’d be this fresh, classic update. For a while, it was perfect - until I started noticing every little smudge and fingerprint (thanks to my toddler). It's funny how something that feels like a bold move at first can just start feeling like extra work. But hey, I guess these “regrets” just mean we’re experimenting and figuring out what actually fits our lives. At least fireplaces are forgiving - there’s always another layer of paint or tile out there.


Reply
christopher_lee

At least fireplaces are forgiving - there’s always another layer of paint or tile out there.

- Totally agree, fireplaces are like the ultimate redo project.
- If you’re worried about smudges, maybe try a limewash next time? It’s more forgiving and eco-friendly than regular paint, plus it ages nicely.
- I’ve found that a matte sealer helps cut down on fingerprints - especially with little ones running around.
- Regret just means you’re learning what works for your space. Been there with a recycled tile surround... looked great, but grout maintenance was a pain. Still glad I tried it though.


Reply
jamese36

Funny how a fireplace can feel like both a blank canvas and a big commitment, right? I’ve definitely second-guessed my choices before, especially when I tried to “restore” the original brick and ended up with a patchwork of mismatched colors. But honestly, I think every layer tells a story - even the ones we want to paint over. Isn’t it wild how a little regret just means you’re figuring out what feels right for your home?


Reply
tobyrogue730

Isn’t it wild how a little regret just means you’re figuring out what feels right for your home?

Totally get this. I once spent a weekend stripping paint off our old mantel, only to realize the “original” wood was half plywood. Regret? Maybe. But now it’s got character - and a good story for guests.


Reply
nature1401920

Had a client once who wanted to “restore” their brick surround, only to find out half the bricks were just a veneer slapped on in the 80s. They weren’t thrilled, but honestly, it made for a pretty unique patchwork look. Sometimes those surprises end up being the best part, even if they’re not what you pictured.


Reply
baileymountaineer

Title: Ever regretted a fireplace facelift? Quick poll time

Sometimes those surprises end up being the best part, even if they’re not what you pictured.

I get where you're coming from, but honestly, I’d be bummed if I found out my “restoration” was just a bunch of fake bricks. I like the idea of unique, but sometimes those patchwork looks just feel... unfinished? Maybe it’s just me, but I’d probably end up painting over it anyway.


Reply
jeff_wood

I’d be bummed if I found out my “restoration” was just a bunch of fake bricks. I like the idea of unique, but sometimes those patchwork looks just feel... unfinished?

I totally get that. I’m pretty practical when it comes to home projects, so if I found out the “new” look was just a veneer or something, I’d probably feel a bit ripped off too. I mean, if you’re putting in the time and money, you want it to actually feel solid, right? I’ve seen a few DIY jobs where folks tried to save cash with faux finishes and it looked okay from a distance, but up close... not so much.

Have you thought about just painting over the patchwork? I did that with ours - just went with a classic white. Covered up all the weird mismatched bits and honestly, it made the room feel a lot cleaner. It’s not super fancy, but it did the trick and didn’t break the bank. Sometimes simple is just easier to live with, especially if you’re on a budget.


Reply
boardgames316

Honestly, I think you’re spot on - patchwork can look a little half-baked if it’s not done right. But hey, if the end result feels solid and you like it, that’s what counts. Sometimes the “real” materials aren’t worth the extra hassle or cost, especially if you’re just looking for a clean finish. I’ve covered up some questionable tile work with paint too and never looked back.


Reply
puzzle_mary

Sometimes the “real” materials aren’t worth the extra hassle or cost, especially if you’re just looking for a clean finish.

I completely agree with this. I tried to demo the old brick on mine and it turned into a huge mess - ended up just skimming over it with joint compound and paint. It’s not “real” stone, but honestly, it looks sharp and no one’s noticed. If it feels solid and looks good, that’s enough for me. Sometimes shortcuts are just practical.


Reply
gamer91

Yeah, I hear you - sometimes the “real” thing just isn’t worth the headache. I’ve done the whole demo down-to-the-studs thing before and honestly, it’s a mess and way more work than it looks on YouTube. If your skim coat looks good and holds up, that’s a win in my book. Most folks just want something that looks nice and doesn’t fall apart anyway. No shame in taking the easier route when it gets the job done.


Reply
johnp38

I get what you’re saying - sometimes the “shortcut” is just smart project management. I’ve gutted a fireplace before thinking it’d be a weekend job… fast forward two weeks and I’m still scraping mortar off my shoes. If the skim coat holds, most buyers won’t know (or care) what’s underneath. Just make sure you use the right primer and sealant so you don’t end up with mystery cracks down the road. Sometimes good enough really is good enough.


Reply

I get the appeal of “good enough,” but I’ve seen a few too many fireplaces where that shortcut comes back to haunt people. You said,

“If the skim coat holds, most buyers won’t know (or care) what’s underneath.”
- but trust me, when that skim coat starts bubbling or cracking in six months, suddenly everyone cares. I always say: if you’re already knee-deep in mortar dust, might as well do it right. Otherwise, you’ll be cursing your past self every time you light a fire.


Reply
crafts271

I hear you on the “do it right or regret it” front. I’ve seen my share of quick fixes that looked fine for a hot minute, then turned into a headache - especially with fireplaces. But I’ll admit, sometimes I get tempted by the “good enough” route when I’m staring down a mountain of demo debris and my arms feel like noodles.

That said, I always end up siding with the long game. If you’re already covered in mortar dust, what’s another hour or two to make sure it’s solid? Plus, if you ever want to use eco-friendly plasters or paints down the line, they need a stable base anyway. Learned that one the hard way - my first fireplace facelift started flaking after one winter because I didn’t bother patching some old cracks underneath. Lesson learned: shortcuts are rarely as short as they seem.

It’s not just about resale either... nothing kills the cozy vibe faster than staring at a crack every time you light a fire.


Reply
finnpeak169

Lesson learned: shortcuts are rarely as short as they seem.

Couldn’t agree more. I once tried to “just patch” a few spots on a brick surround, thinking I’d save time. Ended up redoing the whole thing six months later when the paint started bubbling and the cracks came right back. Now I always do a quick checklist: scrape, patch, prime, THEN paint. It’s a pain in the moment, but way less hassle than staring at your mistakes every time you want to relax by the fire.


Reply
Scroll to Top