Remodeling discussions and local services.

Ever regretted a fireplace facelift? Quick poll time

385 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

panderson10

I hear you on the prep - masking tape is your best friend, but somehow paint still finds a way to sneak through. I’ve seen bright white work really well, especially when the rest of the room has some warmth to balance it out. It’s all about context. Maintenance is real though... white brick plus muddy dog paws? That’s a combo I wouldn’t wish on anyone.


Reply

White brick looks amazing in photos, but in real life? It’s a dust and dirt magnet if you’ve got pets or kids running around. I did a fireplace in a creamy off-white once, and even that was a chore to keep looking fresh. If you’re set on white, maybe try a limewash or something that’s a bit more forgiving with stains. Honestly, I think a slightly warmer or grayish tone hides a lot more and still feels modern. Just my two cents - learned the hard way after scrubbing paw prints every weekend.


Reply

White brick looks amazing in photos, but in real life? It’s a dust and dirt magnet if you’ve got pets or kids running around.

Totally get where you’re coming from. I did a whitewashed brick wall in my last place - looked like something out of a magazine for about two weeks. Then the dog discovered it was the perfect spot to shake off after walks, and suddenly it was more “abstract art” than “modern farmhouse.” Limewash is definitely more forgiving, but even then, you’re still gonna see the smudges if you look close.

I’ve had better luck with a greige tone. Still feels light and airy, but it hides the mess way better. Plus, it doesn’t show every little fingerprint or paw print. If you’re set on white, maybe try a matte sealer? It helps a bit with cleaning, though nothing’s totally kid-proof... or dog-proof for that matter. Sometimes I think the only truly low-maintenance fireplace is one you never use, but where’s the fun in that?


Reply

Not sure I totally agree about white brick being a total nightmare, but I get why it feels that way, especially with pets. I’ve worked on a few projects where the client was dead set on white, and honestly, it’s not always as high-maintenance as people fear. The trick is in the finish and the texture of the brick itself. Smoother bricks with a good quality sealer are way easier to wipe down than those super porous, rustic ones that grab every bit of grime.

That said, I do think you’re right about greige tones being more forgiving. They’re basically the sweatpants of fireplace colors - comfortable, easy, and don’t show every little thing. But sometimes people want that crisp look, you know? There’s just something about a fresh white fireplace that makes a room feel bigger and brighter.

If you’re set on white, maybe try a matte sealer? It helps a bit with cleaning, though nothing’s totally kid-proof... or dog-proof for that matter.

Matte sealer is definitely a good call, but in my experience, even a satin finish can be a lifesaver for cleanability. It gives just enough sheen to make wiping off paw prints less of a chore without looking shiny or cheap.

Funny enough, I had one client who actually liked the “lived-in” look - their kids’ smudges and the dog’s nose prints kind of added character to the place. Not for everyone, obviously, but it made me rethink how “perfect” things need to stay.

Long story short: white isn’t always as scary as it seems if you pick the right materials and don’t mind a little touch-up now and then. And sometimes the mess just becomes part of the story... especially with dogs and kids running around.


Reply
hannahquantum985

I get where you’re coming from on the “lived-in” look. Had a project last year where the homeowners had two golden retrievers and insisted on a whitewashed brick surround. We used a satin sealer - definitely made life easier when it came to muddy paw prints and the occasional juice spill. Still, I always warn folks that even with the best prep, white will show life’s little messes more than greige or taupe. Sometimes you just have to embrace it... or keep a stash of touch-up paint handy.


Reply
tech_alex

White fireplaces look amazing in photos, but man, they’re like a magnet for every crumb, paw print, and coffee drip. We painted ours last fall - looked gorgeous for about two days, then my toddler used it as a canvas for his applesauce masterpiece. I’m starting to think “distressed” is just code for “I gave up on cleaning.”

Honestly, I don’t regret it (yet), but I do keep a magic eraser and a tiny paintbrush nearby. Greige probably would’ve been smarter, but hey, I guess I like living dangerously... or at least pretending my house is cleaner than it is.


Reply
melissaphotographer

I’m starting to think “distressed” is just code for “I gave up on cleaning.”

That made me laugh, because I’ve been there. We went with a whitewashed look, thinking it’d be “timeless” - didn’t factor in muddy dog tails or rogue juice boxes. Sometimes I wish I’d just left the brick alone and saved the paint money for more coffee... or maybe a toddler-proof gate.


Reply
collector73

Honestly, I hear you on the regrets. We did a “quick” DIY limewash to save money, and it looked great for about two weeks - then the kids started using it as their art wall. Now it’s just... smudged. At least you tried something new, right? I keep telling myself the lived-in look is “character.” Sometimes, leaving things as-is really is the budget-friendly win.


Reply
margaret_smith

Title: Ever regretted a fireplace facelift? Quick poll time

I tried to “restore” our 1920s brick with some trendy whitewash last year. Looked like a Pinterest dream for about five minutes, then the dog brushed up against it and now it’s just patchy chaos. Honestly, I think the original soot stains had more charm. Sometimes old bricks just want to be old bricks, you know?


Reply
scottk64

I get where you’re coming from - sometimes those “quick fixes” just don’t hold up, especially with pets in the mix. If you’re open to it, there are eco-friendly sealants that can help lock in a whitewash or limewash finish, making it more durable. But honestly, aged brick has a certain authenticity you just can’t fake. Maybe the original look was the right call after all...


Reply

Honestly, I’ve tried both approaches - painting over brick and just leaving it as-is. Every time I mess with the original, I end up wishing I hadn’t. Even with the best sealants, once you start layering on products, maintenance gets trickier, especially if you’ve got dogs or kids running around. The “lived-in” look of old brick just seems to handle wear better and ages more gracefully.

That said, I get the appeal of a cleaner or lighter look. Limewash can look good for a while, but in high-traffic homes, it tends to chip or fade unevenly. If you really want to protect a finish, those eco-friendly sealants help, but they can darken the color or add a sheen that looks a bit off under certain lights. Sometimes it’s just easier to embrace the imperfections - saves time and hassle down the line.


Reply

I get wanting to keep the original brick, but honestly, I’ve never understood the fear of painting or limewashing. I painted over a dingy, soot-stained fireplace in my 1920s place last year - used mineral paint, not latex - and it’s been a game changer. No regrets. The room feels brighter, and the brick still has texture. Maintenance hasn’t been any worse than before, and I’ve got two kids and a dog who treat the hearth like a jungle gym. Sometimes the “imperfections” just look like neglect, not charm. Guess it depends on the brick and the vibe you’re after.


Reply
aparker76

I painted over a dingy, soot-stained fireplace in my 1920s place last year - used mineral paint, not latex - and it’s been a game changer. No regrets.

Never regretted it here either. I get the “original brick” crowd, but sometimes that old brick just drags the whole room down. I once flipped a 1950s ranch where the fireplace looked like it had survived a barbecue explosion - so much grime and weird stains. Painted it a soft white, and suddenly the whole living room felt twice as big. No one missed the “character” of those stains, trust me. Maintenance was honestly easier too, just a quick wipe now and then. Sometimes you gotta let go of nostalgia for the sake of sanity.


Reply

- Totally get the “original brick” nostalgia, but honestly? Some bricks are just... sad.
- Painted mine last month - looked like a chimney sweep’s nightmare before. Now it’s clean, bright, and doesn’t make me want to vacuum every time I look at it.
- Maintenance is a breeze. No more scrubbing at mystery stains from the 1970s.
- If you love it, that’s what matters. Not every “character” is worth preserving - sometimes it’s just dirt in disguise.


Reply
kayaker17

Painted brick can be a game changer, honestly. I’ve seen some fireplaces where the “character” was just decades of grime and not much else. Did a job last year - client was on the fence, but after we painted, it looked like a whole new room. Sometimes you just gotta let go of the old brick guilt.


Reply
kathygardener

Never regretted it, honestly. I used to feel weird about covering up “original” brick, like I was erasing history or something. But after staring at our dingy, brownish fireplace for years, I finally gave in and painted it a soft white. Whole vibe of the room changed overnight - suddenly everything felt brighter and cleaner. The old brick just looked... tired, not charming.

I get the hesitation, especially with all those “don’t paint brick!” articles floating around. But at the end of the day, it’s your space. If you’re living with something that bugs you every time you walk in the room, why not fix it? Paint is cheap compared to a full reno, and if you hate it (which I doubt), there are ways to undo it or at least tone it down.

There’s nothing wrong with updating things that just don’t work anymore. Sometimes “character” is just code for outdated and dirty, haha.


Reply

Never understood the “don’t paint brick” crowd, honestly. If it’s dragging down the whole room, why keep it just for the sake of “history”? I’ve painted over plenty of old brick fireplaces - never once had a client regret it. The space always feels fresher. Worst case, you can always try a limewash or something if you want some texture back. At the end of the day, you’re the one living with it, not some future historian.


Reply
jose_joker

Never regretted painting a brick fireplace here, either. I get the argument about preserving original materials, especially in older homes, but honestly, not every brick is worth saving for posterity. Some of the stuff from the 60s and 70s is just plain ugly, and if it’s sucking the life out of your living room, why not change it?

I’ve done both - painted and limewashed. If you use a breathable paint or a mineral-based limewash, you’re not really damaging the brick structurally. That’s usually my main concern with historic materials: making sure whatever I put on can be reversed or won’t trap moisture. But at the end of the day, you’re right - it’s your space. If a coat of paint makes it feel more like home, I say go for it. Worst case, future owners can always strip it back if they’re that passionate about “authenticity.” Most people just want a cozy room that looks good now.


Reply

Never looked back after painting ours, either. The original brick was this weird orangey-brown that just clashed with everything - felt like I was living in a 1970s rec room. I get the whole “preserve the past” thing, but honestly, not every design choice from back then is worth keeping around.

We went with a whitewash because it was cheaper than a full-on refacing and still let some of the texture show through. Plus, if I ever get tired of it (or if someone down the line is a brick purist), it’s not impossible to undo. I did worry about moisture at first, but as long as you use the right stuff, like you said, it’s not really an issue.

Honestly, for what we spent - just paint and a weekend’s work - it made the whole room feel brighter and more “us.” No regrets here. If anything, I wish we’d done it sooner instead of living with that eyesore for years.


Reply
literature488

We went with a whitewash because it was cheaper than a full-on refacing and still let some of the texture show through.

- Did a similar thing for a client last year - original brick was that deep red, almost maroon, and it just sucked all the light out of the space.
- We tested a few finishes: full paint, limewash, and whitewash. Whitewash won out for the same reasons you mentioned - texture stays visible, and it’s not a total commitment if tastes change later.
- Moisture is always the big concern. Used a mineral-based paint (Romabio Classico Limewash) that lets the brick breathe. Haven’t had any issues with peeling or efflorescence.
- One thing I’d add: prep is everything. Clean the brick thoroughly, patch any cracks, and tape off like your life depends on it. Skipping those steps is where regrets usually start.
- Honestly, I get the “preserve the past” argument, but sometimes you just need to make a space feel like home. Haven’t had a single client regret it yet - if anything, they’re surprised how much it changes the vibe.
- Only minor downside: once you brighten up the fireplace, suddenly you notice how dated everything else looks... but that’s another project.


Reply
Scroll to Top