Built-in benches are one of those things that always seem like a great idea on paper, but the reality is usually a bit underwhelming. I totally agree about the storage—drawers are just more practical than lift-up lids. I tried to build a bench with a hinged top in my mudroom, thinking it would be super convenient, but it’s awkward to open if there’s anything sitting on it (which, let’s be honest, there always is). Drawers are way easier to access, especially for stuff you use all the time like shoes or bags.
The comfort issue is real. Most built-ins I’ve seen have that straight 90-degree back and a seat that’s just deep enough for a quick sit, but not enough for actual lounging. I read somewhere that the ideal seat depth for comfort is at least 18-20 inches, and a slight angle on the backrest makes a huge difference. But then you run into the problem of the bench sticking out too far or looking bulky, which people don’t always want. It’s a trade-off.
I also underestimated how much difference good cushions make. The first time I sat on my bench with just a thin pad, I felt like I was at a bus stop. Ended up getting custom foam cut to size and adding a couple of lumbar pillows, which helped a lot, but it still doesn’t compare to an actual armchair.
One thing I’d add—if you’re building a bench under a window, pay attention to the height. Standard chair height is around 18 inches, but if you go higher or lower it can feel awkward fast. And if you’re using reclaimed wood, like you mentioned, double-check for splinters or uneven surfaces. I learned that the hard way after snagging a sweater.
They do look great in photos, though. Every time someone comes over, they comment on how “custom” it looks, but nobody ever sits there for long. Maybe that’s just the nature of built-ins—they’re more about aesthetics than actual comfort. If I ever do another one, I’ll probably focus more on ergonomics and less on how it looks in listing photos.
Nailed it about the hinged lids—every time I’ve installed one, it turns into a dumping ground and then nobody wants to move all their stuff just to open it. Drawers are just less hassle. I’d add that the insulation factor gets overlooked too. If you’re using reclaimed or solid wood, it can get pretty cold in winter unless you insulate underneath, especially if it’s on an exterior wall. Ever tried sitting on one of those in January? Not fun... I wish more built-ins factored that in. Comfort and usability always seem to take a back seat to the “custom look.”
Nailed it about the hinged lids—every time I’ve installed one, it turns into a dumping ground and then nobody wants to move all their stuff just to open it. Drawers are just less hassle.
I get what you mean about the cold, but honestly, I kind of love the look and feel of solid wood, even in winter. Maybe it’s just nostalgia—my grandma’s old window seat was always freezing, but we’d pile on quilts and it felt cozy in its own way. Drawers are practical, sure, but there’s something about lifting a lid and finding old board games or photo albums that makes it feel special. Maybe I’m just a sucker for the “custom look” after all...
I totally get the nostalgia factor—there’s just something about those old-school benches with a lid, right? I’ve seen plenty of clients fall in love with the look, even if it means sacrificing a bit of convenience. Honestly, if you’re drawn to that custom vibe and it makes you happy, go for it. You can always add a thick cushion or some throw blankets to help with the cold. Sometimes, practicality isn’t everything... there’s value in a space that feels special, even if you have to move a few things around now and then.
Funny how those benches always look like the coziest spot in the house, right up until you actually sit down. I’ve put a few in properties thinking they’d be a selling point, but buyers always test them out and realize… yeah, not exactly a La-Z-Boy. Still, toss on a thick cushion and suddenly it’s “charming storage solution.” Sometimes you just have to lean into the vibe and accept a little discomfort for the sake of style.