I’ve definitely had mixed results with leftover house paint on planters. Once, I skipped sanding because I was in a rush (and honestly, who wants to sand a dozen pots?), and the paint flaked off in sheets after the first rain. Another time, I did zero prep on some old terracotta, and it’s still holding up two summers later. I swear, the universe just likes to mess with us sometimes.
The “worn” look can be pretty charming, though—I actually lean into it for porch stuff. A little chipping here and there makes things feel lived-in, not like a showroom. If you’re after a cleaner look, I’ve found a quick wipe with rubbing alcohol helps paint stick, especially on plastic. But if you’re into that rustic vibe, honestly, just let the paint do its thing and embrace the chaos. Sometimes the best porch refreshes are the ones that don’t look too perfect.
That’s funny, because I’ve had the exact opposite luck with terracotta—mine always seems to peel unless I prime it first. Maybe it’s just the brand of paint or the humidity here, who knows. I do like what you said about the “worn” look, though.
Totally agree, especially since my porch is more “yard sale chic” than anything fancy.A little chipping here and there makes things feel lived-in, not like a showroom.
I’m curious, have you tried swapping out throw pillows or adding thrifted rugs for a quick change? I’m always on the hunt for cheap ways to mix things up without buying new planters every time the paint starts to flake.
I hear you on the terracotta—mine’s hit or miss too. Sometimes the paint sticks, sometimes it flakes off in sheets, and I’ve just learned to live with the “distressed” vibe. Like you said,
That’s exactly the look my old porch pulls off, whether I want it or not.“A little chipping here and there makes things feel lived-in, not like a showroom.”
I’m a big fan of swapping out pillows and rugs. Thrift stores are goldmines for that kind of thing, especially if you don’t mind a little wear. I’ve found some pretty wild patterns over the years that somehow work together when everything else is a bit mismatched. One year I even used an old wool blanket as a rug—wasn’t perfect, but it did the job for fall.
Honestly, I’d rather spend five bucks on a funky pillow than repaint planters every season. Less hassle, more character. Plus, if something gets ruined by rain or sun, it’s no big loss.
- Totally get where you're coming from on the planters—I've tried every primer under the sun and still end up with that “chipped chic” look half the time.
- Swapping out soft goods is a game changer. I’ve picked up some crazy patterned throws at estate sales that somehow just work, even if they clash a bit.
- One thing I’ll add: I like moving around small furniture pieces too. Even just dragging an old bench from the backyard to the porch makes it feel fresh without spending much.
- Not gonna lie, sometimes I miss that crisp, just-painted vibe... but honestly, people seem to love the lived-in look when they’re checking out a place. Makes it feel like home, not a catalog.
I hear you on the chipped planters—sometimes I wonder if it’s just the weather or if I’m missing some secret prep step. Has anyone tried using natural sealants or eco-friendly paints for outdoor stuff? Curious if they hold up better or just end up with the same “distressed” look after a season.
