I've been using activated charcoal bags for a couple years now, and honestly, they've been surprisingly effective. I was skeptical at first too—especially after dealing with those moisture tubs (ugh, the awkward guest explanations!). But the charcoal bags really do help with musty odors as well as moisture. My basement closet used to smell like an old library (not in a charming way), and after hanging a couple bags in there, the smell noticeably improved within a week or two.
As far as longevity goes, I just put mine out in the sun every month or so to "recharge" them, and they've held up pretty well. Eventually you'll need to replace them—mine lasted around two years before I felt they weren't doing the job anymore—but that's still way less hassle than emptying dehumidifier tanks or buying refills constantly.
And hey, don't feel bad about your spider plant...I once killed a succulent by overwatering it. Still haven't lived that one down.
"Eventually you'll need to replace them—mine lasted around two years before I felt they weren't doing the job anymore—but that's still way less hassle than emptying dehumidifier tanks or buying refills constantly."
Interesting, I've been debating between charcoal bags and a small electric dehumidifier for my laundry room. Do you think the charcoal bags would handle a space with frequent moisture spikes, like after running the dryer? I'm curious if they'd keep up or if I'd still end up needing something more heavy-duty...
Do you think the charcoal bags would handle a space with frequent moisture spikes, like after running the dryer?
I tried charcoal bags in my basement laundry room for a while, and honestly, they struggled after heavy laundry days. They're fine for closets or smaller spaces, but for frequent moisture spikes, I'd lean toward something electric—despite the hassle of emptying tanks occasionally.
Yeah, charcoal bags are decent for mild humidity, but they're not miracle workers. I had a client who tried them in her laundry area, and she ended up switching to a compact electric dehumidifier. It was a bit of a pain emptying the tank, but she said it made a huge difference. Sounds like you're on the right track considering something electric—your hair (and closets) will thank you later, trust me.
Have you checked if your closet doors are solid or louvered? I've noticed that closets with solid doors tend to trap moisture way more easily. Had a client who swapped hers out for louvered doors, and she said it really helped air circulate better. Also, do you have an exhaust fan or vent nearby? Sometimes just improving airflow in the room can make a noticeable difference without having to constantly empty a dehumidifier tank.
As for the frizzy hair struggle...have you tried one of those ionic hair dryers? My sister swears by hers—claims it tames the humidity-induced frizz pretty well. Might be worth looking into if you're already considering electric solutions anyway.
