I learned this the hard way with my grandma's vintage stove—thought lemon oil would freshen it up nicely, but it dulled the enamel finish a bit. Definitely pays to test carefully first... wish I'd read this thread earlier.
Yikes, that's rough about the enamel finish... I've been tempted to switch to natural cleaners myself, but stories like yours make me hesitate. Has anyone tried vinegar solutions on older appliances? I've heard mixed things—some say it's gentle enough, others warn about acidity and corrosion. Wondering if there's a safe dilution ratio or something specific to watch out for with vintage finishes...
I've used vinegar solutions plenty of times, especially on older appliances during remodel jobs. Honestly, it's hit or miss depending on the finish. Had a client with a vintage fridge—tried a mild vinegar-water mix (about 1 part vinegar to 4 parts water), and it cleaned up nicely without any damage. But another time, same ratio, different appliance, and it dulled the enamel slightly. I'd suggest spot-testing in an inconspicuous area first and definitely avoid letting it sit too long... quick wipe-downs are usually safest.
"I'd suggest spot-testing in an inconspicuous area first and definitely avoid letting it sit too long... quick wipe-downs are usually safest."
Yeah, learned that lesson the hard way myself—left a vinegar mix on an old stove top once, thinking I'd come back in a minute. Got distracted (typical me), and when I finally remembered, the finish had dulled noticeably. Had to get creative with some polish to fix it. Speaking of natural cleaners, anyone had luck with baking soda paste on enamel? Curious if that's gentler or just as risky...
"Speaking of natural cleaners, anyone had luck with baking soda paste on enamel? Curious if that's gentler or just as risky..."
I've tried baking soda paste on enamel a few times, and honestly, I'd be cautious about it. It can be gentle, sure, but I've noticed that if you rub even slightly too hard or use it too often, it can leave tiny scratches or dull the finish over time. If you're set on natural cleaners and want something gentler, maybe give Castile soap diluted in warm water a shot. Here's what I usually do: mix about a teaspoon of liquid Castile soap into a spray bottle filled with warm water, spray lightly, then wipe gently with a microfiber cloth. It cleans surprisingly well without the abrasive risk. Vinegar and baking soda are great for some things, but enamel surfaces can be tricky—better safe than sorry when dealing with finishes that are expensive or tough to restore.
