Remodeling discussions and local services.

Natural cleaners vs store-bought stuff for appliances

697 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I dunno, vinegar and dish soap can be hit or miss too. Last weekend I tackled this ancient oven door covered in baked-on gunk and grease - seriously, it looked fossilized. Tried vinegar and dish soap first, but honestly, after scrubbing forever, it barely made a dent. Ended up grabbing a store-bought degreaser, and boom... wiped right off. Felt kinda guilty about the chemicals, but hey, sometimes natural just won't cut it. Anyone else find some messes just laugh at the homemade stuff?


Reply
pat_thinker

Yeah, vinegar and dish soap are decent for everyday grime, but when you're dealing with years of baked-on grease... forget it. I've had similar battles with old stovetops - natural methods barely scratch the surface. Curious though, has anyone tried baking soda paste or steam cleaning on tough appliance messes? Wondering if those hold up better or if they're just more wishful thinking...


Reply
elizabethnelson183

"Curious though, has anyone tried baking soda paste or steam cleaning on tough appliance messes?"

Steam cleaning can actually be pretty effective, especially if you let the steam sit for a bit to loosen things up. Baking soda paste works okay too, but honestly, patience and elbow grease are key...no magic bullet, unfortunately.


Reply

Steam cleaning worked pretty well for me, especially on the oven...though I did have to go over it twice. Baking soda paste was a bit meh - maybe I didn't mix it right? Either way, nothing beats good old-fashioned scrubbing, sadly.


Reply

Steam cleaning's decent, agreed, but honestly I've had better luck with baking soda paste. Trick is to let it sit longer - overnight if you can - and add a touch of dish soap to help it stick.

"Either way, nothing beats good old-fashioned scrubbing, sadly."

Ha, true enough. Elbow grease always ends up being the magic ingredient somehow...


Reply
cloudphoto5258

I've tried baking soda paste myself and yeah, leaving it overnight does help. Still, it's a bit messy for me, especially around stove burners. Honestly, nothing beats scrubbing, even though my arms hate me afterward. At least it's cheap and reliable - can't complain about that. Glad I'm not the only one still relying on elbow grease in the age of fancy cleaning gadgets...


Reply
timphotographer

Totally feel you on the baking soda messiness - I've had my share of gritty paste stuck in burner crevices too. Still, it's hard to beat how cheap and effective it is. One thing I've found helpful is adding a bit of vinegar spray afterward; it fizzles up and loosens the leftover residue, making scrubbing a little less brutal on my arms. Fancy gadgets are tempting, but honestly, simple stuff usually does the trick just fine...and my wallet appreciates it.


Reply

I hear you about the vinegar trick - it really does help cut through that gritty baking soda residue. I used to swear by store-bought cleaners until one day I ran out halfway through cleaning my oven door (talk about timing...). Ended up mixing lemon juice with salt out of desperation, and surprisingly, it tackled the grime better than my usual cleaner ever did. Never looked back since. Natural stuff might take a bit more elbow grease sometimes, but it's nice knowing exactly what's touching surfaces where I prep food. Plus, can't argue with saving a few bucks here and there.


Reply

- Totally agree, lemon juice and salt combo is underrated - works wonders on stubborn stains, especially rust spots.
- Another good one is baking soda paste with hydrogen peroxide... great for whitening appliance surfaces without scratching.
- Store-bought stuff can be convenient, sure, but half the time you're paying extra for fancy packaging and fragrances you don't really need.
- Plus, natural cleaners are safer around kids/pets, which is a big bonus if your household's anything like mine.


Reply

I've tried the lemon and salt trick before, worked pretty well on rust spots around my sink. But does anyone find baking soda leaves a gritty residue sometimes? Maybe I'm mixing it wrong...


Reply
ashleyillustrator

Yeah, baking soda can definitely leave that gritty feel sometimes, especially if it's not fully dissolved or rinsed off. Maybe try mixing it into a paste with a bit more water and giving it an extra rinse afterward? I've found that helps. But honestly, lemon and salt is my go-to as well - works wonders without the hassle of residue. Glad it worked for your rust spots though... satisfying when simple tricks do the job.


Reply

I've had mixed results with lemon and salt myself - works great on rust, but sometimes leaves stainless steel looking a bit dull afterward. Maybe I'm just not rinsing thoroughly enough though.

A couple things I've noticed:
- Vinegar diluted with water is pretty reliable for general appliance cleaning. Cheap too.
- Store-bought cleaners do seem quicker sometimes, but the fumes and cost aren't worth it for me.
- Baking soda paste is good, but yeah, gritty residue can be annoying if you're in a hurry.

Curious if anyone's tried vinegar with essential oils or something similar to cut down on the smell? Vinegar works well, but that sharp scent lingers longer than I'd like...


Reply
jonr44

Totally with you on the vinegar smell lingering...I've started adding a bit of lavender or eucalyptus oil to mine - helps a ton. Also noticed microfiber cloths make stainless steel shine better without streaks than regular towels, no idea why though.


Reply
maggie_fire

"Also noticed microfiber cloths make stainless steel shine better without streaks than regular towels, no idea why though."

Microfiber cloths have tiny fibers that trap dirt and moisture better, so they leave fewer streaks behind. Adding essential oils is a smart move - definitely helps tone down vinegar's intensity...nice tip!


Reply
rmeow26

Microfiber cloths are legit. Switched over a while back and haven't looked at regular towels since. Vinegar's good, but honestly, sometimes I just grab whatever's handy...even dish soap diluted in water works fine for quick touch-ups. Essential oils sound fancy though, might give that a shot next time the vinegar smell starts reminding me of salad dressing.


Reply
katie_dust

Microfiber cloths really are a game changer. Been using them for a couple years now, and they're still holding up great. If the vinegar smell bugs you, try adding just a few drops of lemon or lavender essential oil - doesn't take much, and it cuts that salad dressing vibe right out. Dish soap diluted in water is my go-to as well, especially for quick wipe-downs. Cheap, easy, and gets the job done without fuss.


Reply

I've tried the vinegar and essential oil trick too - definitely helps tone down that pickle jar scent, lol. But honestly, in my old house with vintage appliances, sometimes I wonder if natural cleaners are tough enough to handle decades-old grime. Had a stubborn grease spot on my 1950s stove that laughed at vinegar and lemon oil. Ended up reluctantly grabbing a store-bought degreaser, and it worked like magic. Anyone else dealing with older appliances find natural cleaners strong enough, or is it just me?


Reply

Totally get what you're saying. Natural cleaners have their place, but vintage grease is a whole different beast - it's like decades of stubbornness baked right in, lol. I've flipped a few older homes with appliances straight outta the 60s and 70s, and honestly, vinegar and baking soda just didn't cut it for the hardcore grime. I usually try to stick with natural stuff first too, but sometimes you need something stronger to break through those layers.

One thing that does help though - heat. If you warm up the grime first (like turning on the stove for a minute or two), even natural cleaners can work a bit better. Still, I've had moments where nothing short of industrial-strength degreaser could rescue the situation. Don't feel bad about occasionally reaching for the store-bought stuff; sometimes practicality wins out over purity.


Reply
mmiller86

Heat's a great tip - I hadn't thought of warming things up first. I've been tackling my first renovation (a 1950s kitchen, yikes), and I started out determined to keep things natural. But after scrubbing the oven door for what felt like forever with lemon juice and baking soda, I finally caved and grabbed something stronger from the store. It felt like cheating at first, but honestly, it saved me hours of frustration.

One thing that did help a bit was letting the baking soda paste sit overnight under plastic wrap. It softened the grime enough to scrape off easier the next day. Still wasn't perfect, but it made a noticeable difference.

Curious if anyone's tried steam cleaning for vintage appliances? I've heard mixed things - some swear by it, others say it's just a waste of time. Wondering if it's worth renting one or if that's just another rabbit hole...


Reply

I feel your pain on the baking soda paste - I once spent an entire weekend trying to resurrect a vintage fridge with vinegar and baking soda. It smelled like salad dressing for days, and honestly, the results were pretty meh. Steam cleaning, though... I rented one last year for an old stove, and it was surprisingly effective. Didn't magically erase decades of grime, but definitely loosened things up enough to make scrubbing less soul-crushing. Worth a shot if you're already knee-deep in renovation chaos anyway.


Reply
Scroll to Top