Remodeling discussions and local services.

Knocking down walls: living with one big space

332 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

fitness_ruby

I get the folding screen thing, but honestly, it just collects dust in my house and never feels sturdy. If you want a real divide, have you tried tall bookshelves as room dividers? They give you storage and actually block sight lines. I swapped out my old screen for one and now at least the laundry pile is hidden and I don’t trip over anything. The open concept is still there, but it feels a bit more under control.


Reply

Bookshelves as dividers are smart, especially if you need the storage. Have you found any issues with light or airflow getting blocked, though? I tried a similar setup and ended up moving things around because my plants weren’t loving the shade. Ever tried using reclaimed wood or upcycled shelves for this? Curious how folks balance function with sustainability when breaking up big spaces.


Reply
cycling779

TITLE: Knocking Down Walls: Living With One Big Space

I get the appeal of bookshelves as dividers - especially in these old houses where storage is always at a premium. But honestly, I’ve found they can make a space feel a bit boxed in, especially if you’re dealing with those beautiful tall windows and all that natural light. In my place, I tried using an old set of glass-fronted cabinets (scored them from a salvage yard - talk about character!) to separate the dining area from the living room. It looked great, but after a while, it just felt like I’d put up a wall again, only this time with more dusting.

Airflow was the sneaky issue for me. These old radiators need space to work their magic, and blocking them with shelves just meant cold toes all winter. Plus, my ferns started looking a little sad. I ended up going back to more open solutions - think vintage folding screens or even hanging plants from the ceiling to hint at a “zone” without actually blocking anything off.

I do love the sustainability angle, though. Reclaimed wood is gorgeous and has that lived-in feeling that matches creaky floors and original trim. But sometimes the bulk of a big wooden shelf just doesn’t play nice with light or heat flow in these drafty homes. If you’re set on upcycling, maybe try open shelving or staggered heights so things don’t feel so heavy? Or even mix in some metal or glass elements to keep things airy.

It’s always a balancing act - function, style, and not making your houseplants mad at you. Sometimes I wonder if less division is actually more, especially when the architecture’s got so much personality already.


Reply

It’s always a balancing act - function, style, and not making your houseplants mad at you.

This is basically my life right now. I thought knocking down a wall would make everything feel huge and breezy, but now I’m just chasing my cat out of the kitchen and wondering where to put the recycling bin so it doesn’t photobomb every Zoom call. I tried the bookshelf divider thing too - looked amazing for about a week, then I realized I’d created a dust trap and blocked half the heat from getting to my toes. Why do radiators always win these battles?

I totally get what you mean about “less division is actually more.” Sometimes I stare at all the open space and think, am I supposed to fill this or just let it be? Hanging plants are genius though - mine are thriving now that they’re not in bookshelf jail. Anyone else feel like their houseplants are secretly judging their design choices?


Reply
mollygeocacher

Radiators are the ultimate party crashers, aren’t they? I’ve seen so many beautiful divider setups that just end up blocking heat or making a weird draft. Honestly, you’re not alone with the open space dilemma. Sometimes it’s tempting to fill every corner, but leaving some “negative space” can actually make the whole room feel calmer. For the recycling bin, I’ve seen folks tuck them behind a tall plant or even use a decorative basket - kind of blends in and keeps the Zoom background looking intentional. And yeah, I swear my pothos gives me side-eye when I move it... plants have opinions.


Reply
bsmith51

For the recycling bin, I’ve seen folks tuck them behind a tall plant or even use a decorative basket - kind of blends in and keeps the Zoom background looking intentional.

I have to admit, I’m a bit of a contrarian when it comes to “negative space.” In my 1920s place, if I leave too much open area, it just feels like the ghosts of previous owners are judging my furniture choices. I get the appeal - calm and all that - but sometimes a well-placed bookshelf or even an old trunk can help break up the draftiness without blocking all the heat.

As for hiding bins behind plants, I tried that once and ended up with a recycling avalanche every time I watered the fern. Maybe it’s just me, but sometimes function wins over form...


Reply

- Gotta agree with you on the “function wins over form” bit. I’ve tried the plant trick too -

ended up with a recycling avalanche every time I watered the fern
- same here, except mine was a peace lily and it did not survive the chaos.
- In these old houses, negative space just feels... off. Maybe it’s the creaky floors or the way sound bounces around, but I always end up filling corners with something - trunks, baskets, even a random chair.
- Anyone else notice that open layouts in older homes can make drafts worse? I swear my heating bill doubled after I moved a big bookcase away from the archway. Sometimes those “cluttered” solutions are just practical.


Reply

Knocking Down Walls: Living With One Big Space

Sometimes those “cluttered” solutions are just practical.

Couldn’t agree more - sometimes a strategically placed “clutter” pile is the only thing standing between you and a drafty disaster. I’ve seen folks try to go full minimalist in these old houses, but then you’re left with echoes and chilly toes. Honestly, a big old trunk or even a stack of books can do wonders for both the vibe and the heating bill. And as for plants... let’s just say my monstera is now safely out of splash zone range after one too many soggy magazine incidents.


Reply
astrology_cloud

I hear you on the “clutter” thing - sometimes it’s less about style and more about survival. I’ve worked in plenty of open-plan renos where people rip out walls, then realize they’ve basically created a wind tunnel. Rugs, bookshelves, even a heavy curtain can break up the space and keep things cozy. Minimalism looks great in photos, but real life gets drafty fast, especially in these old houses with questionable insulation. And yeah, plants are great until you’re mopping up after them... learned that one the hard way too.


Reply
astronomy747

Yeah, the wind tunnel effect is real - I've been there. It's wild how taking down a wall can totally change how air moves (and where all the dog hair ends up). You're spot on about rugs and bookshelves being more than just decor; they're kind of survival tools. Ever tried using a big plant as a divider, then regretted it when you realize you’ve basically just created a high-maintenance mess? I tried putting a monstera in the middle of our living/dining space to break it up, and two weeks later I was chasing root rot and water stains. Not my brightest idea.

Have you ever experimented with those sliding panels or screens? I found they’re a decent compromise when you want to zone off a bit without committing to building something permanent. Plus, you can move them around when you get bored... or when you realize you’ve just created a weird echo chamber. Speaking of echoes, did you notice any sound issues after opening things up? I swear, sometimes it feels like voices just bounce around forever now, especially with hardwood floors.

Insulation is a whole other can of worms, especially in these old houses. Sometimes I wonder if we’re just fighting a losing battle unless we go all in with new windows and draft stoppers. Ever tried hanging tapestries or heavier wall art to help with drafts? I thought it was an old wives’ tale, but it actually made a difference in one of our draftiest corners.

Anyway, I get the appeal of minimalism, but yeah, real life gets messy and cold fast. Curious if you’ve found any tricks for keeping things cozy without piling up too much “stuff”? Or is it just about finding the right balance and accepting a little controlled chaos?


Reply

Knocking down walls: living with one big space

I’ve definitely fallen for the “big plant as divider” trap too - mine was a fiddle leaf fig that instantly regretted being in the middle of the draft zone. Now it’s just a sad stick in a pot. Sliding panels are cool, but why are the decent ones always so pricey? I tried hanging a couple of thick curtains instead and, honestly, they help with both echoes and drafts. Not exactly Instagram-worthy but my heating bill thanks me. As for minimalism... I keep trying, but somehow the “necessary” stuff multiplies overnight. Maybe cozy just means learning to live with a little clutter?


Reply
business_max8722

Maybe cozy just means learning to live with a little clutter?

Couldn’t agree more. Every time I try to go “minimal,” the stuff just creeps back in - tools, books, random chargers... it’s like clutter is magnetic. Curtains are underrated, honestly. I rigged up some heavy canvas drop cloths on a pipe for a room divider and they do the job without costing a fortune. Not pretty, but functional. Plants as dividers never worked for me either - drafts and low light just kill them. Sometimes you’ve gotta pick comfort over aesthetics, especially when winter hits.


Reply

Totally get what you mean about clutter sneaking back in. I’ve tried the whole “everything in its place” thing, but life just doesn’t work that way for me. I actually like having a few baskets or bins around - easy to toss stuff in and hide the mess when people come over. Curtains as dividers are a lifesaver on a budget, even if they’re not winning any style awards. Tried using bookshelves once, but they just collected more junk. At some point, you just have to accept a bit of chaos if you want the space to feel lived-in and warm.


Reply
fitness_debbie

I hear you on the baskets - those things are my secret weapon for surprise guests. I’ve got one by the door that’s basically a catch-all for mail, keys, and whatever else I can’t deal with in the moment. It’s not pretty, but it keeps the chaos contained. Curtains as dividers are underrated, honestly. I used an old sheet once when I was broke and needed to split my living room from my “bedroom” corner. Not exactly Pinterest-worthy, but it did the trick.

Funny about bookshelves... I tried using one to create a little “office nook,” but it just became a dumping ground for random stuff. I think there’s something to be said for letting a space look lived-in instead of obsessing over perfection. A little mess makes it feel like home, at least for me. And honestly, open spaces just seem to attract clutter no matter what you do. Maybe that’s just part of the charm?


Reply
debbie_taylor

I totally get the thing about open spaces just collecting clutter. When I knocked down the wall between my kitchen and living area, I thought it would feel airy and organized, but honestly, it just made it easier for stuff to migrate everywhere. I tried using a tall shelving unit as a divider too - ended up with a mix of cookbooks, mail, and random tools all in one place. The baskets help, but I’m still figuring out a system that’s not just moving piles from one spot to another. Maybe the lived-in look is just inevitable with open layouts...


Reply

- Totally get where you’re coming from - open layouts look great in photos, but in real life, stuff just drifts.
- I’ve seen some folks use low credenzas or benches instead of shelving units to break up the space without creating a “catch-all” zone.
- One trick: assign each zone a purpose and stick to it, even if it means being a little ruthless with what stays out.
- It’s not always perfect, but I’ve found that regular mini-purges (like 10 minutes every few days) keep things from piling up.
- Honestly, a bit of lived-in mess just means people actually live there... nothing wrong with that.


Reply

Knocking down walls: living with one big space

I swear, open layouts are like magnets for random stuff. I tried the “zone” thing - my dining table still ends up as a mail station, homework desk, and snack bar all at once. I did grab a cheap rolling cart from IKEA to corral the chaos, but it’s basically a mobile junk drawer now. At this point, I just call it “multifunctional living.” Cheaper than therapy, right?


Reply
business770

Funny you mention the rolling cart - mine started as a “craft station” and now it’s just where all the half-finished projects and random chargers go to die. I grew up in a house with tiny, closed-off rooms, so when we opened up our main floor, I thought it’d be easier to keep tidy. Nope. The clutter just spreads out more visibly now. I’ve tried baskets, trays, you name it. Honestly, sometimes I miss having doors to just hide the mess behind.


Reply
zeusastronomer

I totally get what you mean about missing doors to hide the chaos. Our house is from the 1920s, so it’s all little rooms and nooks. I used to think knocking down a few walls would make everything feel lighter and more organized, but honestly, I’ve grown to love having spots where I can just close a door and pretend the mess doesn’t exist for a while. There’s something comforting about knowing the clutter is contained - even if it’s just out of sight.

That said, I do envy how open spaces let in so much light and make gatherings feel less cramped. But yeah, the “stuff” just migrates everywhere with no boundaries. Have you found any tricks that actually work for keeping things under control in an open layout? Or is it just a constant battle between baskets and the never-ending tide of random objects? Sometimes I wonder if people with those perfectly tidy open-plan homes are hiding all their junk in the garage...


Reply
james_martin

Knocking Down Walls: Living With One Big Space

I’m right there with you on the “where does all this stuff even come from?” question. We opened up our kitchen and living room last year, and I swear, the clutter just learned how to travel faster. Before, at least the mess was quarantined behind a door or two. Now it’s like - bam - everyone’s shoes, mail, and random kid art are on display for anyone who walks in.

I tried the whole “everything has a basket” approach, but honestly, baskets just became new places for junk to pile up. I think the only real trick that’s worked (sort of) is being super intentional about what actually gets to live in the open space. If it doesn’t have a purpose or isn’t used daily, it gets banished to a closet or - yeah - the garage. I’m convinced those Instagram-perfect open-plan homes either have a secret storage bunker or they just don’t own anything besides three throw pillows and a plant.

One thing that helped a bit was creating “zones” with rugs and furniture. It doesn’t stop the mess from spreading, but at least it gives me an excuse to say, “That’s not my pile of laundry - it’s part of the living room zone decor.” Also, I’ve started using trays for corralling stuff on counters and tables. It tricks my brain into thinking things are organized when really it’s just organized chaos.

Honestly though, sometimes I miss being able to just shut a door and pretend everything is fine behind it. Open layouts are great for light and parties, but not so much for hiding evidence of daily life. Maybe someday I’ll figure out the magic formula... until then, baskets and denial seem to be my go-to strategy.


Reply
Scroll to Top