Remodeling discussions and local services.

Knocking down walls: living with one big space

332 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

nickh20

I always wonder if less walls means more clutter or less.

It really depends on how disciplined you are with your stuff. Open layouts can look amazing, but they do put everything on display - there’s nowhere to hide the mess. I’ve found that using crates or open shelving actually forces people to stay organized, since clutter stands out more. But if you’re someone who likes to stash things away and deal with it later, fewer walls might make it feel messier.

One thing that helps is zoning - using rugs, furniture, or even plants to break up the space visually. That way, each “zone” feels intentional and you’re less likely to let things spill over everywhere. I’ve seen clients get creative with baskets and bins too, which keeps things tidy without closing off the space. It’s a bit of a mindset shift, but once you get used to it, open layouts can be surprisingly easy to keep neat.


Reply
kennethlopez186

Funny thing, when I knocked out the wall between my kitchen and living room, I thought I’d be tripping over shoes and mail forever. Turns out, it forced me to actually deal with my stuff instead of just tossing it in the “junk room.” But yeah, if you’re the type who likes to hide things behind closed doors (literally), open space can feel a bit… exposed. Ever tried using a big bookshelf as a divider? Works wonders and gives you somewhere to stash stuff without building another wall.


Reply

Knocking down walls: living with one big space

Ha, I totally get that feeling of suddenly having nowhere to hide the mess. When I opened up my kitchen to the living room, I realized my “strategic clutter zones” were just gone. I tried the bookshelf trick too - ended up with a jungle of plants and cookbooks as my new “wall.” It’s funny, though, how you start actually putting stuff away just because you can see it from every angle now. Still miss having a spot to shove the ugly mail pile sometimes...


Reply

It’s wild how knocking down one wall suddenly turns your entire life into an open book - literally. When I took out the divider between my dining area and living room, I thought I’d be living in some kind of magazine spread. Turns out, it’s more like a “find the hidden laundry pile” game now. Where do socks go when there’s no corner to toss them in? Still haven’t figured that one out.

I tried that whole “zone” thing with a big rug and a couple of tall plants, but my dog decided both were his new nap spots, so now it just looks like I’m running a very relaxed jungle daycare. Ever notice how much more you sweep when you can see crumbs from every angle? I swear, I never cared about dust bunnies until they were visible from the couch.

But here’s the real question: what do people do with all the random stuff that used to live behind closed doors? Like, I can’t be the only one who misses having a junk drawer that’s actually out of sight. Now my “junk drawer” is basically a decorative bowl on the coffee table, and it’s not fooling anyone.

Has anyone found a way to make open shelving look tidy for more than a day? Or is that just a myth invented by Instagram? Sometimes I wonder if I should just embrace the chaos and call it “lived-in chic.”


Reply
aaronm91

You just described my life after I demo’d the wall between my kitchen and living room. I thought the extra light would make me feel like I was living in a treehouse, but mostly it’s made me hyper-aware of every stray sock and dog toy. Open shelving is my nemesis - no matter how many baskets I buy, stuff just migrates out onto the shelves again. Have you tried those woven baskets or boxes? I keep telling myself if it’s “contained,” it counts as organized, but honestly, sometimes it just looks like a pile of baskets. Do you feel like your cleaning habits have changed since opening things up? I swear, I sweep twice as much now...


Reply
gardening292

Knocking down walls: living with one big space

I thought the extra light would make me feel like I was living in a treehouse, but mostly it’s made me hyper-aware of every stray sock and dog toy.

- Totally get this. When we opened up our 1920s bungalow, I was all about the “airy loft” vibe. Didn’t realize how much visual clutter would bug me until I could see every corner from the front door.
- Woven baskets? Tried ‘em. They look great for about a week, then suddenly it’s just... basket city. I started labeling them with little tags (chalkboard paint, if you’re into DIY) so at least I know what’s supposed to go where. Helps a bit, but yeah, sometimes it’s just a pile of baskets.
- Cleaning habits? Night and day. Used to be I could ignore a mess in the dining room for days. Now, if there’s a crumb on the floor, it’s like a beacon. I sweep way more than I ever did before. Also, dust seems to travel further when there aren’t walls to block it.
- One thing that helped: I put a vintage folding screen near the entryway. It breaks up the sightlines just enough that not everything is on display, but still lets the light through. Plus, it adds some character.
- Open shelving is tricky. I started rotating what’s out - only display stuff I actually like looking at, and stash the rest in closed cabinets or drawers. If you can’t add cabinets, even a skirted table or an old trunk can hide a lot of chaos.
- Honestly, sometimes I miss having separate rooms. But then the sun hits just right in the afternoon and I remember why I did it.

If you figure out how to keep the baskets from multiplying, let me know...


Reply

Baskets are a trap - been there. I switched to a couple of big bins made from recycled materials. Less stuff out in the open, fewer containers to manage. Also, I’m ruthless about what stays visible. If it doesn’t get used daily, it’s hidden. Keeps my sanity intact.


Reply
trobinson29

Bins over baskets - yeah, I get the appeal. I went through a phase where every shelf had a cute little basket, but it just turned into a game of “where did I hide that thing?” all the time. Once we knocked down the wall between our kitchen and living room, it was like putting everything on display, whether I wanted to or not. Ended up building a big storage bench under the windows with deep drawers. Out of sight, out of mind, but still easy to grab stuff when you need it.

Funny thing is, I thought open concept would feel airy and free, but clutter multiplies fast when there aren’t any doors to close. I’m still tweaking what stays out and what gets tucked away. I do keep one or two things visible - like a cool vintage breadbox or a stack of cookbooks - just for personality. The rest? Hidden as much as possible. Makes the space feel calmer, at least for me.


Reply
mecho56

I get what you’re saying about hiding stuff away, but I actually found the opposite after we opened up our space.

“clutter multiplies fast when there aren’t any doors to close”
- I thought that’d be true, but it made me more conscious of what I actually need. We ended up paring down a ton, and now I kind of like having a few things out, even if it’s not always picture-perfect. Plus, easy access means I use stuff more often instead of it getting forgotten in a drawer. Maybe it’s just my brain needing visual reminders...


Reply

Funny, I had the same worry about open shelving but ended up liking it too. I do think seeing everything out in the open keeps me honest about what I actually use. Plus, less hiding means less forgotten stuff piling up. That said, I still stash some mess behind a plant or two...


Reply

I get the appeal of open shelving - being able to see everything does make it easier to keep track of what you actually use. But I’ve found it can also make a space feel a bit cluttered, especially in one big open area. Like,

“less hiding means less forgotten stuff piling up”
- true, but sometimes I just want to shove things out of sight and pretend my kitchen is always tidy. Ever tried mixing closed cabinets with a few open shelves? I feel like it gives you the best of both worlds.


Reply

Mixing open shelves with closed cabinets is honestly one of my favorite ways to handle a big, open kitchen. You get that airy, accessible vibe from the shelves - great for dishes you actually use every day or things you want to show off - but you’re not stuck looking at cereal boxes and mismatched mugs all the time. I’ve seen people go overboard with open shelving and it can start to feel like a display case, which isn’t always relaxing in a space you use constantly.

One trick I like is to keep open shelves limited to one wall or just around the stove area, then use closed cabinets everywhere else. It keeps things visually balanced and you still have spots to stash the less photogenic stuff. Also, playing with materials - like wood shelves against painted cabinets - can break up the monotony and make the space feel more intentional. Honestly, even just a couple of floating shelves can make a difference without tipping into clutter territory. Sometimes it’s all about editing what actually goes on those shelves...easier said than done, I know.


Reply
tiggerwolf94

- When we opened up the kitchen in our 1920s place, I ran into the same dilemma.
- Ended up doing open shelves just on the chimney wall - kept the original brick exposed, which looks great with wood.
- Closed cabinets everywhere else, especially under the counters.
- One thing I’d add: deep drawers for pots and pans are a lifesaver.
- Agree about editing what’s on display...I thought I’d love showing off all my vintage Pyrex, but it got dusty fast.
- If you’ve got high ceilings, staggered shelf heights help break up the space too.
- Only regret: wish I’d planned for more hidden storage. Open layouts are great, but clutter creeps in if you’re not careful.


Reply
dobby_blizzard

Funny you mention the vintage Pyrex - mine looked amazing for about a week, then it was like a dust magnet. I do love the idea of

“open shelves just on the chimney wall - kept the original brick exposed, which looks great with wood.”
That mix of materials really does give the space some soul. I went a little wild with open shelving at first and, honestly, it stressed me out. Now I keep only the stuff I use daily out, and the rest is hidden away. Deep drawers for pots are a total game changer, though. Never going back to rummaging in dark cabinets again.


Reply
snorkeler72

Deep drawers are the unsung heroes of kitchen sanity, honestly. I used to think open shelving was the dream - until I realized my “curated” display was just a rotating dust-and-clutter exhibit. Now it’s mugs, bowls, and that’s about it. The rest? Out of sight, out of mind... and way less stressful. Exposed brick with wood, though - can’t beat that combo for instant character.


Reply
carolnaturalist6405

Deep drawers are the unsung heroes of kitchen sanity, honestly.

I get the love for deep drawers, but honestly, I’ve flipped a few places where open shelving actually worked - if you’re strict about what goes up there. The trick is to treat it like a rotating gallery, not storage. Less is more. And about exposed brick with wood, yeah, it’s got character, but it can make a big space feel colder if you’re not careful. Sometimes drywall and paint do wonders for warmth, especially in those big open layouts.


Reply
film_hunter

- Deep drawers are a lifesaver for pots and pans, but I swear, open shelves turn into a dust magnet at my house.
- Exposed brick looks cool until winter hits and suddenly you’re living in a trendy meat locker.
- Painted drywall isn’t glamorous, but it’s way easier to touch up after a wild spaghetti night... just saying.
- Big open spaces are great for parties, but echoey when you’re yelling at your dog to get off the couch.


Reply

I get the echo thing, but honestly, I’ll take a little reverb over feeling boxed in. We knocked out a wall between our kitchen and living room last year and yeah, it’s louder, but now I can keep an eye on the kids (and the dog stealing snacks) while I cook. Plus, with a couple rugs and some curtains, the sound isn’t half as bad as I expected. Painted drywall is definitely easier to fix after “creative” cooking mishaps, though... learned that one the hard way.


Reply

Funny you mention the “creative” cooking mishaps - my wall still has a faint outline of spaghetti sauce from last year’s lasagna disaster. I totally get what you mean about the sound, though. Did you notice any weird drafts after opening up the space? I swear our living room got colder, but maybe that’s just me being paranoid. Rugs definitely help with both noise and chilly toes.


Reply

Drafts are real - at least in my place. After we opened up the parlor and dining room, it felt like the old house started breathing differently. I swear you can feel a breeze sneak through the floorboards some days, especially in winter. Rugs help, but I also ended up hanging some heavy curtains between spaces for a while. Not exactly open-concept chic, but it kept the chill down.

Funny thing about noise, too. The echoes are wild when the house is empty. I started collecting old tapestries and quilts to hang on the walls, partly for the look, partly for the sound. Adds a bit of character and muffles the chaos when everyone’s home.

And yeah, cooking disasters leave their mark. I’ve got a faint curry stain on the ceiling from an “experimental” dinner last fall. It’s almost like a badge of honor at this point - proof that life happens here.

If you’re feeling colder, you’re probably not imagining it. These old houses weren’t built for open plans, so once you knock down a wall, all bets are off with drafts and heat flow. But honestly, I kind of love how the space feels now - messy, lived-in, and full of stories (and stains).


Reply
Scroll to Top