Main line replacement? That’s where I’d tap out, honestly. Some stuff—tightening a fitting, swapping a faucet—that’s just elbow grease and a YouTube video. But when you’re talking about digging up pipes or dealing with the city connection, I’d rather not risk a flood or a code violation. I get wanting to save money, but sometimes it’s cheaper in the long run to let the pros handle the big stuff. That said, I totally get the urge to try—half the battle is just not being intimidated by the unknown.
But when you’re talking about digging up pipes or dealing with the city connection, I’d rather not risk a flood or a code violation.
I get that, but have you ever looked into hiring a plumber just for the trickiest part, then handling the rest yourself? I’ve saved a decent chunk doing it that way on a couple rentals. Sometimes the city stuff is less scary than it sounds—just paperwork and maybe a permit. Not saying it’s for everyone, but if you’re comfortable with research, it might not be as risky as it feels.
Sometimes the city stuff is less scary than it sounds—just paperwork and maybe a permit.
- Definitely true in some areas, but I've had cities where inspectors nitpick everything, even on minor repairs.
- I usually handle demo and basic runs, then bring in a licensed plumber for tie-ins or anything near the main.
- Permits can be a pain—sometimes quick, sometimes weeks. Worth checking before you start.
- Saved money this way, but scheduling pros for just part of a job can be tricky if they're busy.
PLUMBING CHECK-UP DILEMMA: DIY OR HIRE A PRO?
Totally get what you mean about inspectors—sometimes I feel like they’re just looking for a reason to flex their red pen. I once had a guy ding me for using the “wrong” kind of pipe insulation... on a line that wasn’t even in use. Go figure.
I’m with you on doing the grunt work myself. Demo, running lines, even sweating copper if I’m feeling brave (and have a fire extinguisher handy). But when it comes to tying into the main or anything that could flood my basement, I’d rather pay a pro than risk a swimming pool where my laundry room should be.
Permits are a wild card. Sometimes it’s just a quick online form, other times it’s like applying for a passport. Ever had a city inspector show up unannounced? That’s always a fun surprise.
Biggest headache for me is getting a plumber to just do the “hard parts.” They’re usually booked solid, and my little half-day job isn’t exactly top priority. Anyone else ever tried bribing with donuts? Didn’t work for me, but maybe I just picked the wrong flavor...
Yeah, I’ve tried the “just the tricky part” approach with plumbers too. Most of them either want the whole job or nothing. I get it, but it’s frustrating when you know you can handle 90% of it yourself. Ever had one agree to let you do the rough-in and they just come for the final tie-in? I’ve had mixed luck—sometimes they’re cool, sometimes they act like you’re asking them to babysit your dog. Curious if anyone’s found a workaround that doesn’t involve waiting weeks.
