I see your point about the hinged cover, but honestly, I tried something similar at first and found it more annoying than helpful. Every time I had groceries or bags in hand, flipping that cover open was a hassle. I ended up just going with a weather-resistant keypad instead—no cover at all—and it's held up surprisingly well through storms and snow. Might not be as sleek-looking, but usability-wise, it's been way better for me...
Interesting perspective, but have you noticed any issues with durability over time? I'm asking because my place is a historic home—lots of character, but also lots of quirks—and I've been hesitant to go fully uncovered with the keypad. I went with a hinged cover thinking it'd protect from the elements, but yeah... juggling groceries and fighting that little flap is a pain. Maybe I'm overthinking it, though—sounds like your keypad's holding up fine even without protection?
I've had mine uncovered for about three years now, and honestly, it's held up surprisingly well. Granted, my house isn't historic, but it does get hit with some pretty harsh weather—rain, snow, direct sun, you name it. I initially worried about moisture seeping in, but so far, no issues at all. The keypad's a bit faded from the sun, but functionality-wise, it's still solid. I'd say ditching the flap might be worth the convenience... especially if you're regularly juggling groceries or kids like me.
I went flapless on mine about five years ago, and honestly, I haven't looked back. The keypad's definitely faded—it's practically vintage-looking now—but still works like a charm. Funny enough, I worried more about ice buildup in winter than rain, but turns out a quick brush-off does the trick. Convenience-wise, it's a lifesaver when you're hauling paint cans or lumber (or pizza boxes...). I'd say the minor cosmetic wear is worth the trade-off for ease of use.
Interesting take, I've debated going flapless myself but haven't quite pulled the trigger yet. My main concern's always been security—though I guess if someone's determined enough, a keypad probably won't stop them anyway. Good point about winter ice buildup; hadn't even thought of that. Might finally give it a shot next time I renovate... convenience wins out eventually, right?
