Remodeling discussions and local services.

How long do pipes really last under pressure?

276 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

scott_peak7469

I once tried to “temporarily” fix a pinhole leak with duct tape and optimism - didn’t end well. Ended up with a soggy mess and a lesson in humility. Pipes really don’t care about your schedule or your wallet, do they?


Reply
thomasc12

Pipes really don’t care about your schedule or your wallet, do they?

Tell me about it. I once tried to patch a leaky joint with some leftover plumber’s putty and a prayer - lasted just long enough for me to sit down with a coffee before the whole thing started dripping again. Pipes seem to know exactly when you’re broke or busy. I swear, they wait for the worst possible moment to give up. At this point, I keep a mop and bucket on standby... just in case.


Reply

Honestly, I get the frustration, but I think pipes get a bad rap. Most of the time, they’re just quietly doing their job for decades - until we ignore them long enough that they finally throw in the towel. I swapped out my old PVC for PEX a couple years back and haven’t had a single drip since. Maybe it’s less about bad luck and more about giving them a little TLC before disaster strikes... or at least before you’re down to your last roll of paper towels.


Reply
cycling7407953

I hear you on the TLC part - maintenance really does go a long way. I’ve worked on a few remodels where the original copper pipes were still going strong after 40+ years, just because someone bothered to check for leaks and corrosion every now and then. On the flip side, I’ve seen PEX installations fail in under a decade, usually because they were exposed to UV or weren’t supported properly.

Honestly, it’s less about the material and more about how it’s installed and maintained. Even the best pipe will give out if it’s under constant stress or exposed to chemicals it wasn’t designed for. I always recommend insulating pipes and using proper fittings - especially if you’re in an older house with mixed materials. It’s not glamorous, but a little preventative work can save a ton of hassle (and water damage) down the line.

Funny thing, I once found a galvanized line from the ‘60s that looked pristine inside - guess it just got lucky with the water chemistry. Sometimes you just can’t predict it...


Reply

That’s wild about the galvanized pipe - sometimes you really do get a unicorn. I’ve noticed in some older homes, the pipes last forever in one section but are a mess just a few feet away. Maybe it’s the way the house settles or how the plumbing was routed? Curious if anyone’s seen a difference in pipe longevity between homes with basements versus slab foundations. Seems like moisture and temperature swings could play a role...


Reply
geo_oreo8985

Funny you mention that - one of my clients had pipes in the basement that looked pristine, but the same line running under the slab was a rusty disaster. I swear, it’s like pipes have their own personalities depending on where they’re hiding. Maybe basements just let things breathe more? Or maybe it’s just old house roulette...


Reply
agreen62

I’ve seen that too - pipes under the slab just seem to rot out way faster, even when the rest of the line looks fine. Makes me wonder if it’s all about moisture getting trapped down there, or maybe something in the concrete itself speeding up corrosion? Ever notice if certain types of pipe hold up better under slabs, or is it just a gamble no matter what you use? Sometimes I think it’s less about age and more about where the pipes are hiding...


Reply
cadams94

I’ve actually run into this a few times during remodels - pipes under the slab always seem to be the wild card. I remember one project where the copper lines looked pristine everywhere except under the kitchen slab, where they were just... gone. The plumber blamed it on the concrete leaching something, but I’ve also heard it’s about how moisture gets trapped with no airflow. PVC seems to last longer in those spots, but even then, shifting slabs can crack them. It really does feel like location is everything, not just the material or age.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from, but I think the “location is everything” idea gets a little overstated. In my experience with older homes - some pushing 100 years - the material and installation method matter just as much, if not more. I’ve seen original galvanized pipes under slabs that somehow outlasted newer copper in the same house, just because the copper was laid directly on the concrete with no sleeve or protection. That’s a recipe for electrolysis and pinhole leaks, especially if there’s any stray current or aggressive soil.

PVC’s not immune either, like you said, but honestly, it’s the installation shortcuts that kill these systems. No expansion joints, no bedding, pipes crammed up against rebar... it all adds up. Sure, shifting slabs can crack anything, but I’d argue a properly installed pipe - whatever the material - stands a much better chance than people give it credit for. Sometimes it’s less about where and more about how.


Reply
astronomy_maggie

That’s a solid point about installation making or breaking the system. I’ve gutted places where the copper was pristine in one section and riddled with pinholes just a few feet away - always traced back to how it was run or what it was touching. I’m still surprised how often I find pipes wedged right up against rebar or concrete, no wrap, nothing. It’s like nobody thought about expansion or chemical reactions.

I do think location can matter in some cases, though - like if you’re dealing with super acidic soil or high water tables. But yeah, most of the failures I see are from shortcuts: not enough support, weird bends, joints under stress... that kind of stuff. Ever seen PEX lines zip-tied so tight they kink? Drives me nuts.

Curious if you’ve noticed any difference with newer materials like CPVC or PEX over time? I feel like they’re more forgiving but still not immune to bad installs.


Reply

Couldn’t agree more about bad installs being the real killer. I’ve seen PEX last for years without a hitch, then fail in spots where someone cranked down a clamp or ran it across a sharp edge - same with CPVC getting brittle if it’s not supported right. I do like how PEX handles freezing better than copper, but it’s still not magic. Honestly, every material’s got its quirks... installation just makes or breaks it. Funny how some folks think new pipes are “set and forget.” Not quite.


Reply
georger21

It’s wild how many times I’ve walked into a “brand new” reno only to find leaks behind the walls because someone rushed the install. Doesn’t matter if it’s PEX, copper, or whatever - if it’s not supported or someone gets heavy-handed with a clamp, you’re asking for trouble. I’ve seen copper last 50 years in one house and spring pinhole leaks in another after five. It really does come down to the details, not just the material. People forget pipes are like anything else - they need a little respect and attention.


Reply
cars695

Honestly, I think you nailed it - install matters way more than just the type of pipe. I’ve seen PEX that was supposed to be “maintenance-free” start leaking at the joints because someone didn’t seat the fittings right. Here’s what I usually do when I’m working on a reno or even just checking my own place:

1. Always check for proper support. Pipes shouldn’t be hanging loose or jammed tight against studs.
2. Use the right clamps and don’t overtighten - especially with PEX, it’s easy to crush it if you’re not careful.
3. For copper, make sure the cuts are clean and deburred. Any rough edge can become a weak spot over time.
4. Pressure test before closing up walls. It’s tempting to skip this step, but it saves so much hassle down the line.

I’ve had copper last decades in one house and fail in five years in another, too. Sometimes it’s water chemistry, sometimes it’s just a bad batch of pipe... but most of the time, it’s how it was put in. A little patience goes a long way.


Reply

That’s interesting about copper failing early in some places - makes me wonder if I should be more worried about what’s in my water than the pipe itself. I’ve got PEX going into a bathroom reno right now, and honestly, the pressure test thing is stressing me out more than anything else. Do you ever use those push-to-connect fittings, or do you stick with crimp rings? I keep hearing mixed things, especially for spots that’ll be buried in a wall...


Reply

“Do you ever use those push-to-connect fittings, or do you stick with crimp rings? I keep hearing mixed things, especially for spots that’ll be buried in a wall...”

I’m in the middle of my first reno too, and I went back and forth on this exact thing. Ended up using crimp rings for anything that’s going behind drywall. The push-to-connect fittings seemed super convenient, but I read a few stories about them leaking over time if there’s any movement or if the pipe isn’t cut perfectly square. Maybe I’m overthinking it, but the idea of tearing open a wall later just stresses me out more than taking a little extra time with the crimp tool. For exposed spots or temporary fixes, though, those push fittings are hard to beat.


Reply
joseph_jackson

Honestly, I’m with you on not wanting to rip open drywall down the road.

“the idea of tearing open a wall later just stresses me out more than taking a little extra time with the crimp tool.”
Couldn’t agree more.

- Crimp rings = peace of mind for anything hidden.
- Push-to-connect? Great for quick fixes or spots you can watch.
- Seen a push fitting pop off once when someone didn’t deburr the pipe… not a fun day.

If it’s buried, I’ll take the extra 10 minutes and stick with crimp every time.


Reply
hiking_amanda

I get the stress about hidden leaks - had a buddy who had to rip out a finished basement wall because a push fitting let go after a year. Total nightmare. But I do wonder, has anyone actually seen a crimp fail if it was done right? I’ve only ever seen issues when someone rushed or skipped checking the gauge. Sometimes I think we overthink it, but then again, water finds every mistake eventually... How long do you all trust PEX behind drywall before you start worrying?


Reply
jerry_moore

Honestly, I get the paranoia - hidden leaks are every property owner’s worst nightmare. I’ve had my fair share of “surprise” water issues over the years, and it’s never fun. That said, I’ve seen a lot of PEX installs and, like you mentioned, it’s almost always user error when something fails. If the crimp rings are done right and you’re not skipping steps, those connections are pretty bulletproof.

I’ve got rentals with PEX behind drywall that have been going strong for 10+ years now. I don’t lose sleep over them. The only time I start to worry is if there’s been a sketchy reno or I know someone cut corners. Otherwise, I’d say PEX is about as reliable as it gets for modern plumbing - at least compared to the old copper-with-pinholes or brittle PVC days. Water will find a way eventually, but if you trust your install, you’re probably fine for a long while.

That said, I still get a little nervous every time I close up a wall... just can’t help it.


Reply
gamer24

- Can’t argue with the nerves when you’re buttoning up a wall - once it’s covered, any mistake is gonna be a pain to find later.
- I’ve lived through the copper pinhole saga in my old place. Never-ending hunt for those tiny leaks, and repairs always seemed to pop up right after you fix something else.
- Swapped to PEX in one wing of the house about 8 years ago. Honestly, haven’t looked back. No corrosion, no green stains, and the flexibility made it way easier to snake through the weird framing in these old walls.
- Still, I’m a bit old-school - always double-check the crimps, and I use the metal rings instead of the plastic ones. Maybe overkill, but it helps me sleep better.
- One thing I’ve noticed: water pressure matters. If your system’s running high, nothing lasts as long as it should, no matter what pipe you use. I run a pressure regulator down to about 60 psi - seems to keep stress off all the lines.
- Agree that sketchy renos are where trouble starts. Had a previous owner “fix” a leak under the kitchen with duct tape and paint... took me forever to track down that slow drip.
- Noticed PEX stands up to freezing better than copper, too. Up here in the north, that’s a big deal. Pipes used to burst every other winter before I switched.
- Still, I keep an eye on things - old habits die hard. Even if PEX is reliable, nothing’s truly permanent in a house that’s been standing for 100+ years.

Just my two cents. No perfect solution, but PEX has made my life a lot less stressful compared to the old stuff.


Reply

Pressure’s the silent killer, for sure. I’ve seen copper last 60 years and I’ve seen it pinhole in under 10, all depending on what’s running through it and how hard. PEX is a game-changer for those weird old walls - totally agree on the metal rings, too. I still test every crimp twice, just in case. And yeah, 60 psi is my sweet spot as well... anything higher and you’re just asking for trouble down the line. Funny how the “quick fixes” from past owners always end up being the longest jobs to sort out.


Reply
Scroll to Top