Remodeling discussions and local services.

how much did your bathroom remodel run you (roughly)?

1,195 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

charlesking45

That’s honestly encouraging to hear, because I’m just wrapping my head around my first bathroom reno and the cost estimates from contractors are wild. I’m thinking of doing demo and tiling myself, but the plumbing part still freaks me out a bit - did you run into anything unexpected with PEX, or was it pretty straightforward once you got started? I keep hearing mixed things about it...


Reply
danielw88

I’m thinking of doing demo and tiling myself, but the plumbing part still freaks me out a bit - did you run into anything unexpected with PEX, or was it pretty straightforward once you got started? I keep hearing mixed things about it...

I totally get the hesitation with plumbing - honestly, that was my biggest worry too. I ended up doing most of my bathroom reno myself to save cash, and PEX was a new thing for me. I’d say it was a lot less intimidating than I expected, but there were a couple of “wait, am I doing this right?” moments. The crimping tool felt awkward at first, and I had to redo a couple of connections because I didn’t seat the pipe all the way in. Nothing catastrophic, just a little annoying.

One thing I wish I’d known: double-check the local code about PEX connections inside walls. Some places want you to use specific fittings or have access panels. I almost closed up a wall before realizing I needed a different type of fitting for code compliance. That would’ve been a pain to fix later.

If you’re comfortable with measuring twice and cutting once, PEX is pretty forgiving. The flexibility is a huge plus compared to copper, especially in tight spots. Just make sure you get the right size rings and fittings - there are a couple different systems (crimp vs. clamp), and mixing them up can cause leaks.

Demo and tiling are definitely doable if you’re patient. Tiling took me longer than I thought, mostly because I kept second-guessing my layout. But honestly, the satisfaction of seeing it come together was worth the extra time.

How wild were your contractor quotes? Mine ranged from $9k to $17k for a small bathroom, which is what pushed me to DIY in the first place. Ended up spending about $4k all-in, mostly on fixtures and tile. If you’re handy and willing to learn as you go, it’s totally possible to keep costs down. Just budget extra time for those “learning curve” moments... they happen.

Curious if you’re planning on moving any plumbing or just swapping out fixtures? That made a big difference in how complicated things got for me.


Reply

PEX is one of those things that looks scarier than it is - kind of like parallel parking a big truck. Once you get the hang of the crimp tool, it’s pretty forgiving. Biggest tip: don’t cheap out on the tool itself. I’ve seen folks try to use knockoff crimpers and end up with leaks that make you wish you’d just stuck with buckets. Also, if you’re moving plumbing, map everything out first. Nothing like realizing your new vanity sits right where the old drain stub was... ask me how I know. Swapping fixtures is way less hassle, but if you’re rerouting lines, double-check every measurement before you cut.


Reply

Did my main bath last year and tried to keep it as cheap as possible. Used PEX for the first time - agree, the tool matters. I borrowed a good one from a neighbor after my $20 Amazon crimper left me with a slow drip behind the wall (didn’t catch it until I saw the paint bubbling... fun times). All in, I spent about $2,800, but I reused the tub and did all the demo and plumbing myself. If you’re moving pipes, measure three times. I had to redo a section because I eyeballed it and ended up short by an inch. Not worth the hassle.


Reply
fishing_bear

Mine ran a bit higher, but I blame the quirks of my 1920s house. Ended up around $4,200, mostly because I had to replace some ancient lath and plaster behind the shower. I hear you on the PEX tools - my first attempt with a cheap clamp left me chasing leaks for days. Measuring three times is solid advice. I learned the hard way that “close enough” doesn’t cut it when you’re dealing with 100-year-old walls that aren’t square.


Reply
jerryinferno637

I get what you’re saying about measuring three times, but honestly, sometimes I think you just have to accept a little bit of “close enough” with these old houses. My place is from 1915 and nothing is square, plumb, or level. I spent hours trying to get the new tub to line up perfectly with the walls, but after a while I realized it was just never going to look like a new build. There’s a certain charm to the quirks, right? I mean, if I wanted everything perfect, I probably wouldn’t have bought a house with original wavy glass windows.

On the PEX tools - yeah, the cheap ones are a gamble. I actually borrowed a higher-end crimper from a neighbor after my first attempt ended in a slow drip behind the wall. Not fun. But I will say, I’ve had better luck with the push-to-connect fittings in tight spots. They’re pricier, but for a couple connections behind the shower where I really didn’t want to risk another leak, it was worth it.

Your $4,200 sounds about right for dealing with lath and plaster. I tried to save some of mine, but it’s like opening a can of worms every time. Sometimes I think the “just patch it” approach is underrated - unless you’re dealing with a full-on crumble. Anyway, I guess my point is, sometimes you have to let go of perfection and just work with what you’ve got. These old houses keep us humble.


Reply

Yeah, I hear you on the “close enough” philosophy - old houses really do have a mind of their own. My 1920s bungalow is the same way. I spent a whole afternoon trying to get a reclaimed door to fit a bathroom opening that was somehow both too wide and too narrow at the same time. At some point, you just embrace the weird angles and hope your guests find it “charming” instead of “drafty.”

I’ve also had my share of PEX drama. Tried to save money with a bargain crimper and ended up with a tiny leak that took weeks to track down. After that, I switched to those push-to-connect fittings for the trickier spots - totally worth the extra cost for peace of mind, especially when you’re working behind old plaster.

Lath and plaster is its own beast. I tried to reuse what I could, but half the time it crumbled if I even looked at it wrong. I ended up patching more than replacing, just to keep some of that original character. There’s something satisfying about making it work instead of gutting everything. Perfection’s overrated anyway - quirks tell the story.


Reply

Old houses really are a different animal. I’ve run into the same thing - nothing’s ever square, and you end up spending more time figuring out how to make things “good enough” than actually installing anything. Honestly, I think you’re spot on about quirks adding character. I’ve learned the hard way that chasing perfection in these places is a losing battle and just eats up your budget. Curious, did you end up saving much by patching the lath and plaster instead of gutting? Sometimes I wonder if the extra labor is worth it, but I get wanting to keep the original vibe.


Reply

It’s wild how much time goes into just making things “look right” in these old spaces, isn’t it? I totally get wanting to keep the original lath and plaster - it does have a certain vibe you just can’t replicate with drywall. But I’ve seen projects where patching ends up costing nearly as much as replacing, once you add up the labor. Did you run into any surprises behind the walls? Sometimes I wonder if it’s more about preserving history than actually saving money... but I get why you’d go that route.


Reply
toby_explorer

Yeah, I hear you on the lath and plaster. I tried to keep mine too, but honestly, the patching was a pain and not cheap. Ended up finding some old knob-and-tube wiring back there, which was a whole extra headache. In the end, I spent about $14k on my bathroom, mostly because of those “surprises” behind the walls. Sometimes I think it’s more about the character than the cost savings, for sure.


Reply

Sometimes I think it’s more about the character than the cost savings, for sure.

Totally get that. I tried to save the original tile in mine, but once I opened things up, it was a domino effect - cracked joists, ancient plumbing, you name it. Ended up around $11k, mostly labor and fixing old mistakes. Sometimes “character” just means more work.


Reply
climber695820

Sometimes “character” just means more work.

That’s the truth. I thought I’d just be swapping out fixtures, but the second I pulled up the floor, I found old knob-and-tube wiring and a weird patch job from the ‘60s. Ended up redoing way more than planned. Did you run into any surprises with the plumbing? I swear, every time I touch something in this house, it’s like opening a can of worms.


Reply

Did you run into any surprises with the plumbing? I swear, every time I touch something in this house, it’s like opening a can of worms.

That’s such a classic old-house move. I’ve lost count of how many times a “simple” swap turned into a full-blown project. Plumbing is usually the wild card for me, too. Once I opened up a wall expecting to just reroute a shower line, only to find a Frankenstein mess of galvanized, copper, and even some random PVC thrown in. Ended up replacing almost everything just for peace of mind.

If you’re still in the thick of it, here’s how I usually tackle those can-of-worms moments:

1. **Assess what’s salvageable.** Sometimes, old pipes or wiring look scary but are actually fine. Other times, you find a patch job that’s just too sketchy to leave alone. I always try to weigh the cost (and mess) of replacing versus the risk of leaving it.

2. **Budget for the unknowns.** I know it’s not what anyone wants to hear, but I always set aside at least 15-20% of my budget for “surprises.” It’s not fun, but it saves so much stress when you inevitably hit something weird.

3. **Prioritize safety and code.** If you find knob-and-tube or old lead pipes, it’s almost always worth updating, even if it blows the budget. I’ve seen too many people try to work around it, then regret it later when they have to rip everything out again.

4. **Document as you go.** Take photos before you close up walls or floors. You’ll thank yourself if you ever have to troubleshoot or sell the house down the line.

I know it can feel like the house is fighting you at every turn, but sometimes those surprises are a blessing in disguise. At least you know things are done right. And honestly, sometimes the weird quirks end up being the parts you love most - once you’re on the other side of the chaos, anyway.

Curious - did you end up keeping any of the vintage fixtures or details, or did everything have to go? I’ve had clients who insisted on keeping the original sink or tile, even if it meant a little extra work. Sometimes it’s worth it for the character (even if it means more work, like you said).


Reply
tobyjohnson719

Plumbing is usually the wild card for me, too. Once I opened up a wall expecting to just reroute a shower line, only to find a Frankenstein mess of galvanized, copper, and even some random PVC thrown in. Ended up replacing almost everything just for peace of mind.

That’s exactly what happened to us with our last bathroom reno. We thought we’d be clever and just swap out the tub - no big deal, right? Two days later, we were staring at a mess of corroded pipes and at least three different kinds of fittings (none of which matched). I was tempted to patch it up and hope for the best, but honestly, that never pays off in the long run. Ended up shelling out for all new PEX lines. The initial quote was $8k for the whole job, but after “surprises” and code upgrades, it crept closer to $11k.

I get wanting to keep original fixtures for character, but sometimes it’s just not practical if you’re on a budget. We kept the old cast iron tub (that thing’s not going anywhere), but everything else had to go. I’d rather spend money where it counts than risk another plumbing disaster in five years.


Reply
daisyjournalist

We ran into the same thing - thought we’d just update the vanity and toilet, but once we opened the floor, it was a maze of ancient lead and cast iron. Ended up gutting everything down to the studs. Honestly, I wish we’d budgeted more for “unknowns.” Did you run into any electrical surprises too, or was it just plumbing chaos?


Reply

Title: How Much Did Your Bathroom Remodel Run You (Roughly)?

We thought we’d just swap out the tub and slap on some new tile, but the second we took up the old linoleum, it was like opening a time capsule - wires everywhere, half of them cloth-wrapped and brittle. Ended up having to rewire most of the lighting and outlets because nothing was grounded right. The plumbing was a mess too, but honestly, the electrical was what really blew our budget.

I totally get what you mean about “unknowns.” We had a little buffer set aside, but it vanished fast once the electrician started poking around. Looking back, I wish we’d just assumed everything behind the walls needed replacing. It’s wild how these old houses hide so much weirdness. At least now I know what’s behind every wall in there... but my wallet still hasn’t forgiven me.


Reply
jsniper39

That sounds almost exactly like what happened with ours, except we found a couple of live wires just tucked behind the old vanity - no junction box, nothing. The “just swap the tub” idea turned into a total gut job once we realized the vent stack was leaking too. Did you end up having to move any plumbing, or was it just updating what was there? Our costs basically doubled once we had to bring everything up to code. I wish I’d budgeted for a full rewire from the start, but hindsight’s 20/20...


Reply
blazeking34

We had a similar “just replace the fixtures” plan, but yeah, once we opened up the walls it was like a time capsule of questionable 70s wiring and plumbing. Ended up moving the toilet a few feet (which meant jackhammering the slab - fun times), and had to re-route some supply lines because apparently copper pipes don’t last forever. Didn’t touch the vent stack, but I probably should’ve, considering how much else was wrong.

I totally get what you mean about costs ballooning. Our budget basically evaporated once the electrician started poking around. I thought I was being smart by setting aside a “surprise” fund, but it was gone in a week. If I ever do this again, I’m just assuming everything behind the walls is a disaster waiting to happen. At least now I can sleep at night knowing nothing’s going to catch fire... probably.


Reply
business_max

Yeah, the “just swap out the fixtures” plan never seems to go as simply as it sounds. When we opened up our bathroom walls, we found a mess of old galvanized pipes and even some cloth-wrapped wiring. Ended up costing almost double what we’d budgeted, mostly because of hidden stuff like that. I guess the lesson for me was to expect the unexpected and pad the contingency fund even more than I thought was necessary. Funny how a simple project can turn into a full-blown overhaul once you see what’s lurking behind the drywall.


Reply
pumpkin_rodriguez

Title: How Much Did Your Bathroom Remodel Run You (Roughly)?

That’s exactly what happened to us, except in our case, it was a tangle of ancient copper pipes and some weird, half-rotted wood blocking where a vent should’ve been. I went in thinking we’d just replace the vanity and maybe retile, but by the time we were done opening things up, it turned into replacing half the plumbing and rewiring for code compliance. The “simple swap” idea is a myth, at least in any house older than the 80s.

I’m pretty detail-oriented with my budgets, but even then, our costs ballooned by about 40% over what I’d mapped out. I’d set aside a 15% contingency, but that evaporated fast once the hidden stuff started showing up. Honestly, I think a lot of those HGTV-type shows do people a disservice by glossing over how much time and money gets eaten up by these surprises. It’s not just about picking tile and faucets - there’s a lot of infrastructure hiding behind the walls that nobody wants to think about until it’s too late.

Curious if you tackled any of the work yourself or just handed it all off to a contractor? I tried to DIY as much as possible, but there’s a point where you hit code issues or stuff that’s just beyond a weekend warrior’s skill set. I’ve heard some folks say you can save a bundle doing demo and painting yourself, but honestly, the real costs seem to come from the stuff you can’t see - like plumbing and electrical.

Did you end up replacing everything back there, or just patching what looked sketchy? I went back and forth on whether to rip out all the old wiring or just fix the worst bits, but in the end, it seemed smarter (and probably cheaper in the long run) to just bite the bullet and update it all while the walls were open. Kind of painful at the time, but at least I’m not lying awake wondering if I’ve got a fire hazard lurking back there...

Anyway, just curious how you approached those decisions, since it sounds like you ran into some of the same headaches.


Reply
Scroll to Top