Remodeling discussions and local services.
how much did your bathroom remodel run you (roughly)?
Funny thing, we also found knob-and-tube wiring tucked behind our old plaster... one surprise after another with these houses.
That’s wild - old wiring always seems to pop up at the worst time. We ran into galvanized pipes during our remodel, which added a chunk to the budget. Curious, did you end up rewiring the whole bathroom or just patching that section? Our total was around $18k, but a lot of that was unexpected fixes like plumbing and electrical. Did you have to redo your subfloor too, or was it in decent shape?
Curious, did you end up rewiring the whole bathroom or just patching that section? Our total was around $18k, but a lot of that was unexpected fixes like plumbing and electrical. Did you have to redo your subfloor too, or was it in decent shape?
Knob-and-tube is always a wild card - never know what you’ll find until you open things up. I’ve seen jobs where folks try to just patch the wiring, but honestly, it’s usually safer (and less hassle long-term) to rewire the whole space if you’re already in there. Costs more upfront but saves headaches down the line.
Galvanized pipes are another classic. They always seem fine until you touch them, then suddenly you’re replacing half your plumbing. $18k sounds about right for an older house with those kinds of surprises. Subfloors can go either way - sometimes they’re solid, sometimes they’re basically compost. If yours held up, that’s a win.
Don’t get discouraged by the curveballs. Old houses have character, but they definitely keep you on your toes...
Costs more upfront but saves headaches down the line.
Couldn’t agree more with rewiring - patching just seems like asking for trouble, especially with old knob-and-tube. We did a full gut and found the subfloor was half rotted under the tub, so that had to go too. If you’re already opening up walls, I’d say check insulation and maybe upgrade to something eco-friendly while you’re at it. It’s wild how one fix leads to another... but at least you know it’s solid for years.
Funny how every time you open up a wall, it’s like Pandora’s box - except instead of hope, you find old wiring and mystery pipes. Ever run into those weird “fixes” from previous owners? I once found a light switch wired to nothing but a nail… Anyone else end up redoing plumbing while they’re at it, or is that just me?
I hear you on the “Pandora’s box” thing - every time I think I’ve budgeted enough, I find something else lurking behind the drywall. Those mystery fixes from previous owners are wild... I once found a pipe capped with duct tape and a prayer. I always wonder, do people just not care or were they just trying to save a buck? Honestly, redoing plumbing seems almost inevitable if you want peace of mind. Did you end up having to move any walls, or was it mostly just chasing down weird wiring and pipes?
Yeah, I totally get what you mean about the “prayer and duct tape” approach - seems like every house has at least one of those surprises. In my last bathroom reno, I didn’t have to move any walls, but tracing down all the weird, spliced wiring and random pipe reroutes took way more time than I expected. Sometimes I wonder if people just got overwhelmed or if they really thought it was a good fix at the time. Either way, redoing the plumbing was worth it for the peace of mind. You’re not alone in finding those head-scratchers behind the walls.
I swear, every time I open up a wall, I brace myself for some “creative” solution from a previous owner. My last bathroom redo was supposed to be a simple facelift - paint, new vanity, maybe swap out the toilet. Ended up spending way more time (and money) on fixing the “temporary” plumbing fixes that had clearly been there for decades. I get wanting to save a buck, but some of those shortcuts just end up costing more in the long run.
All in, I kept it under $4k by doing most of the work myself and shopping around for fixtures. Honestly, if you’re willing to put in the sweat equity and don’t mind learning as you go, it’s doable on a budget. But yeah, tracing down mystery wires and pipes is like playing a weird game of house detective... except you’re the one who pays when you lose.
Title: How Much Did Your Bathroom Remodel Run You (Roughly)?
Man, I hear you on the “creative” fixes. Every house I’ve worked on has had at least one “what were they thinking?” moment behind the drywall. But I’ll be honest - sometimes those old shortcuts are the only reason the place is still standing. I once found a whole section of copper pipe patched with what looked like a garden hose and duct tape. Not code, obviously, but it held up for who knows how many years.
I get wanting to do things yourself and keep costs down - I’m all about sweat equity too - but after running into a few of those Frankenstein jobs, I started budgeting extra for pros on plumbing and electrical. There’s just stuff I’d rather not gamble on, especially if it means tearing out tile again in six months because something leaks.
My last bathroom reno ran closer to $7k, but that included hiring out the rough-in plumbing and moving a wall. Could I have done it cheaper? Probably. But after dealing with a previous owner’s “temporary” fixes, I figured it was worth paying up front for peace of mind.
Not saying DIY isn’t doable - totally is if you’ve got the time and patience - but sometimes those hidden surprises make me wish I’d just written a bigger check from the start. Then again, where’s the fun in that? Half the stories come from what you find behind the walls... even if they do cost you a few extra gray hairs.
Man, you nailed it with the “Frankenstein jobs.” I’ve had my share of “why is this even here?” moments too. Paying for pros on plumbing and electrical is just smart - some stuff’s not worth the risk or the headache. Seven grand sounds pretty reasonable, honestly, especially if you moved a wall. Peace of mind’s hard to put a price on.
- “Frankenstein jobs” is the perfect way to describe what I found behind my shower wall - looked like four different people tried their hand at plumbing, none of them sober.
- I tried to DIY a bit (big mistake), but after a minor flood and an electrical scare, I caved and called the pros.
- My total? Around $5,800. No wall moving, but did splurge on tile and a fancy rain showerhead that my kids now use as an indoor waterpark.
- Honestly, you’re right - peace of mind is worth every penny. I can sleep without worrying the toilet’s gonna fall through the floor.
- Seven grand for moving a wall and pro work sounds pretty darn good to me. Some quotes I got were pushing $12k for basic stuff... wild.
- Lesson learned: If it involves pipes or wires, just budget for the real deal. Your future self (and your insurance) will thank you.
I totally get the “Frankenstein job” thing - when I opened up my bathroom wall, I found a weird mix of copper, PEX, and even some old galvanized pipe. Looked like a plumbing time capsule. My budget was around $6k, but I tried to save by painting myself and reusing the vanity. Still, the hidden stuff always costs more than you think. Did anyone else run into surprise expenses once they started demo?
That’s the thing with old houses - demo always uncovers some wild stuff. I once found a random patch of wallpaper behind my shower, like someone just tiled right over it. My last bathroom reno was supposed to be $8k, but after finding water damage under the tub, it ballooned closer to $11k. Did you end up replacing all the plumbing, or just patching what you could? Sometimes I wonder if it’s better to gut everything and start fresh, or just fix what’s broken and hope for the best...
Sometimes I wonder if it’s better to gut everything and start fresh, or just fix what’s broken and hope for the best...
I’ve wrestled with that too. When I did my guest bath, I only replaced the worst of the old copper lines - figured no point in ripping out stuff that still looked solid. But then again, part of me wishes I’d just started from scratch, since now I’m paranoid about what’s lurking behind the walls. Did you run into any electrical surprises while you were at it? Sometimes those are even scarier than plumbing.
I hear you on the “what’s behind the walls” anxiety. When we tackled our 1920s bath, I thought I’d just patch up what was obvious, but one loose tile turned into a whole wall of crumbly plaster. Didn’t hit any electrical nightmares, but I did find some old knob-and-tube wiring tucked way back. It’s a gamble either way, but sometimes leaving well enough alone is the only way to stay sane - and on budget.
Title: How Much Did Your Bathroom Remodel Run You (Roughly)?
That “just patch it up” optimism gets me every time. I totally get the urge to leave things alone, but with these old houses, sometimes you’re just kicking the can down the road. When we redid our 1918 bathroom, I swore I’d keep it simple - then found a whole mess of ancient pipes and, yeah, some knob-and-tube too. Ended up redoing more than planned, but honestly, knowing what’s behind those walls helps me sleep better.
Cost-wise? We thought we’d keep it under $10k, but it crept closer to $18k once the hidden surprises started popping up. Not cheap, but at least I’m not worried about a pipe bursting in the middle of the night. Sometimes you’ve just gotta rip off the band-aid... or in this case, half the wall. If you can swing it, fixing things right is worth it in the long run - even if your wallet cries a little.
It’s wild how those “quick fixes” always turn into full-blown adventures, especially in older homes. I’ve seen so many clients start with a simple tile swap, only to discover a spiderweb of ancient plumbing or, my personal favorite, mystery wiring that looks like it belongs in a museum. The peace of mind after sorting it all out is real, though - I totally get that.
Your $18k sounds about right for a gut job, especially with surprises behind every wall. I’ve noticed folks sometimes try to save by skipping waterproofing or reusing old fixtures, but honestly, that can backfire fast. Curious - did you splurge on anything fun, like heated floors or a statement tub, or was it mostly “invisible” upgrades? I always find it’s the little luxuries that make the pain of the bill sting a bit less...
We definitely fell into the “just replace the vanity” trap and ended up gutting half the room once we saw what was lurking behind the walls. I totally agree about waterproofing - my partner wanted to skip it to save a few bucks, but I put my foot down. We did treat ourselves to a rain shower head, though, and honestly, it makes getting up for work way less painful. Did you find any weird surprises behind your walls, or was it mostly what you expected?
We definitely fell into the “just replace the vanity” trap and ended up gutting half the room once we saw what was lurking behind the walls.
- Ran into a similar situation - planned for a simple tile swap, but found ancient galvanized pipes and some sketchy wiring. Ended up redoing all the plumbing and electrical.
- Waterproofing is non-negotiable for me, too. Skipping it’s just asking for trouble down the line.
- Rain shower head = game changer. Worth every penny.
Curious - did you guys upgrade your exhaust fan too? I’ve found old fans are usually way underpowered, especially after opening up the walls.
Exhaust fans are one of those things you don’t really think about until you’re knee-deep in demo and suddenly realize, “Wait, this thing barely moves air.” I’ve seen so many bathrooms with ancient fans that sound like jet engines but barely clear any steam. Upgrading ours made a huge difference - went with a quiet Panasonic model, and it actually keeps the mirrors fog-free now.
Funny thing, we also thought we’d just swap out the vanity and maybe replace a few tiles. Ended up with the whole room stripped to studs because of hidden water damage behind the shower. The waterproofing step was non-negotiable after that... learned my lesson the hard way. Honestly, I’m always a bit surprised when folks skip it - feels like tempting fate.
Rain shower heads are fantastic, though I will say cleaning those little nozzles gets old fast if you’ve got hard water. Still worth it for that spa vibe, though.
- 100% agree on the exhaust fan. Most people don’t realize how much energy (and money) gets wasted running an old, noisy fan that barely does anything. Swapping to an efficient, quiet model is one of those upgrades you actually notice every single day.
- Waterproofing is non-negotiable for me too. I’ve seen way too many “budget” remodels where folks skip it or use cheap materials, then end up with mold and rot a couple years later. Not worth it - spend the extra on proper membranes and sealants.
- Rain shower heads are nice, but yeah, hard water is a pain. I went with a model that has silicone nozzles you can just rub clean with your thumb. Still, if you’re in a hard water area, a filter might be worth it.
- For cost: my last eco-friendly bathroom reno (full gut, mid-range fixtures, high-efficiency everything) ran about $14k. Could’ve saved a bit going cheaper on tile or skipping the low-flow toilet, but honestly, the water savings add up over time.
- One thing I’d add - if you’re already demoing to the studs, insulate those walls. Makes a big difference in comfort and energy use, especially in older homes.