Remodeling discussions and local services.

locked out drama - what would you do?

1,314 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

joshuapaws714

I get where you’re coming from - DIY isn’t always the most efficient, especially with locks. I’ve done the “coat hanger through the window” routine and just ended up frustrated and mildly embarrassed. As for hiding spare keys, I’m a bit conflicted. It’s convenient, but unless it’s really well-hidden (and not in one of those fake rocks everyone knows about), it feels risky. Lately I’ve leaned toward giving a spare to a neighbor I trust rather than stashing one outside. Less chance of someone stumbling across it accidentally or otherwise.


Reply

It’s convenient, but unless it’s really well-hidden (and not in one of those fake rocks everyone knows about), it feels risky. Lately I’ve leaned toward giving a spare to a neighbor I trust r...

I get the neighbor thing, but I’ve always been a bit wary of relying on someone else’s schedule. What if they’re out of town when you need the key? Here’s what I did: bought a lockbox (the kind realtors use) and bolted it to a hidden spot that’s not obvious from the street. It’s not perfect, but it feels more secure than a fake rock or leaving it with someone who might not be around. Just make sure to pick a good combo and change it every so often.


Reply

I’ve used those realtor lockboxes too, and honestly, they’re a solid option if you pick a good hiding spot.

“It’s not perfect, but it feels more secure than a fake rock or leaving it with someone who might not be around.”
I like that you mentioned changing the combo regularly - people forget about that part. Have you ever worried about someone noticing the box and trying to break into it? I’ve always wondered if a determined thief would see it as a target or just move on.


Reply

“It’s not perfect, but it feels more secure than a fake rock or leaving it with someone who might not be around.”

Honestly, I’d rather risk someone noticing the lockbox than trust a plastic rock. If a thief’s really determined, they’ll find a way in regardless. Ever tried those lockboxes with alarm features? Wondering if that’s overkill or actually helpful...


Reply
phoenixr72

I hear you on the fake rock - those things are basically an invitation for trouble. I’ve actually used a lockbox with an alarm before, and honestly, it wasn’t as dramatic as I thought. The alarm only goes off if someone really messes with it, so it’s not like it’s blaring every time you open it. Felt like a decent middle ground between convenience and security. Still, I always wonder if it just draws more attention... but at least it’s not hiding under the world’s most suspicious garden gnome.


Reply

I get what you mean about the lockbox maybe drawing attention, but honestly, I think most people just walk right past them unless they’re actively looking for one. I’ve got mine tucked behind a drainpipe, and it kind of blends in. Have you thought about one of those smart locks with keypad entry? They’re pricier, but no keys to hide at all. I used to worry about batteries dying, but mine gives plenty of warning before it’s totally out. Just another option if you want to ditch the whole “where do I hide the key” dilemma.


Reply
spirituality_adam

I get the appeal of smart locks, especially when you said:

Have you thought about one of those smart locks with keypad entry? They’re pricier, but no keys to hide at all.

That’s a solid point. No more crawling around in the bushes looking for the fake rock or trying to remember which flowerpot is hiding the backup key. I’ve installed a bunch of those keypads for clients, and honestly, most folks are surprised how reliable they’ve gotten - especially compared to the early models that would eat batteries like candy.

But I’ll play devil’s advocate for a second. The one thing that still bugs me about smart locks is they’re another thing in your house you have to “update” or troubleshoot if something goes weird. I had a client last year who got locked out because her WiFi went down during a firmware update... she was less than thrilled. Granted, most of the newer ones have backup key slots or even a 9V battery jump-start option, but it’s still another layer of tech to think about.

I’m probably old school, but there’s something reassuring about a good ol’ mechanical lockbox tucked away out of sight. You can drop it behind a gutter or paint it to match the siding - most people don’t notice unless they’re really looking (and if someone’s doing that, you probably have bigger problems). Still, if you’re someone who loses keys more often than socks in the laundry, ditching physical keys altogether does sound pretty tempting.

At the end of the day, it’s kind of a tradeoff: convenience versus one more gadget to manage. If you’re comfortable with tech and changing batteries once in a blue moon, go for it. If not, maybe stick with the tried-and-true methods... just don’t use the doormat trick. Everyone knows that one by now.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve seen those lockboxes get pried open or just straight-up stolen, especially if someone’s determined. Hiding them only works if nobody’s watching you stash the key, you know? With smart locks, yeah, there’s tech to deal with, but at least you’re not leaving a physical clue for someone to find. I guess it comes down to how much you trust your neighborhood and how much hassle you’re willing to put up with. Personally, I’d rather swap a battery than risk someone finding my backup key.


Reply

I hear you about the lockboxes - had one go missing from a rental property once, and it was a headache. Still, I’ve had smart locks glitch out too, especially in bad weather. Ever had a tenant call you at midnight because the app wouldn’t connect? Curious if anyone’s found a backup method that actually feels secure and isn’t a total pain.


Reply

Ever had a tenant call you at midnight because the app wouldn’t connect?

Man, that’s the worst - had it happen with a WiFi drop during a storm, and there I was trying to troubleshoot over the phone half asleep. I started leaving an old-school key in a coded outdoor hide-a-key as backup. Not perfect, but at least it’s something when tech fails. I get the worry about security, but honestly, it’s way less hassle than getting a locksmith out at 1am.


Reply

Had a similar situation last winter - tenant got locked out because the smart lock battery died, and of course, it was snowing. I’ve started putting in those little lock boxes too, but I always tell folks to keep an eye on battery levels. Honestly, sometimes low-tech just saves the day. I get the security concerns, but in my experience, most break-ins aren’t from someone finding a lockbox - they’re just looking for an unlocked window or something easier.


Reply
phoenixgolfplayer

Had something similar happen but with my own front door - smart lock battery died right when I got home with a trunk full of groceries. Ended up sitting on the porch for an hour. Honestly, I’m starting to think old-school keys aren’t so bad... less fancy, but way less hassle sometimes.


Reply
cathye21

I hear you - technology giveth and technology locketh you out. I had a similar run-in with my “smart” thermostat last winter. Power went out, and suddenly my eco-friendly house was just... cold. Sometimes I wonder if all these gadgets are just making life more complicated.

But hey, at least you got some fresh air with your groceries? Silver lining, maybe. I still keep a spare key hidden in the garden, old-school style. Not exactly high-tech, but it’s never run out of batteries on me.

Curious - has anyone tried those solar-powered locks? I keep seeing ads for them, but I’m skeptical. Feels like one cloudy week and you’re back to sitting on the porch with melting ice cream. Or am I just being paranoid about “smart” everything?


Reply

Locked Out Drama - What Would You Do?

I hear you on the “smart” everything craze. My house was built in 1912, and I swear it looks at me funny every time I try to install anything with a microchip. Last year, my neighbor got one of those solar locks - looked fancy until a week of rain left him camped out on his porch with a pizza and no way in. Meanwhile, my rusty old skeleton key just keeps chugging along. Sometimes low-tech is the real luxury.


Reply

Honestly, I’m with you - sometimes the old stuff just works. My “security system” is a stubborn deadbolt and a dog that barks at squirrels. Tried a smart lock once, but it ate batteries like candy. Low-tech wins for my wallet and my sanity.


Reply
donaldgreen701

I get it - those battery-hungry smart locks are a pain. I stick with a regular deadbolt too, plus I keep a spare key with a neighbor I trust. Not fancy, but it’s saved me more than once. Sometimes simple is just easier on the nerves.


Reply

I tried one of those “smart” locks once and, no joke, the battery died in the middle of a rainstorm. Picture me, soaked, trying to remember if I left a window unlocked (spoiler: I didn’t). Since then, it’s regular deadbolt for me too - plus a rock that looks suspiciously like it’s hiding something in the garden. Anyone ever try one of those combo lockboxes? Are they any less hassle than smart locks or just another thing to stress about?


Reply
tech_zeus

- Had a combo lockbox for years - never failed me, but I do worry about someone spotting it and figuring out the code.
- Way less hassle than smart locks, though. No batteries, no apps, just remember the numbers.
- Ever thought about hiding a spare with a neighbor instead? That’s saved me more than once.


Reply
gadgeteer456374

“Had a combo lockbox for years - never failed me, but I do worry about someone spotting it and figuring out the code.”

Totally get that. I’ve used those lockboxes on flips - never had an issue, but I always tuck them somewhere less obvious. Neighbor with a spare is smart, though. Less risk if you trust them.


Reply
fitness_debbie

Totally get that.

I hear you on the “tuck them somewhere less obvious” trick. I once hid a lockbox behind a fake rock in the garden - felt like a spy movie, honestly. Still, I lean toward the neighbor-with-a-key route these days. Less hardware to fuss with, and it’s saved me a late-night locksmith call more than once.


Reply
Scroll to Top