Remodeling discussions and local services.

locked out drama - what would you do?

1,314 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

andreww28

Keypads seem more reliable, but I do wonder about battery life and what happens if you forget to change them. Has anyone factored in the long-term costs of replacing batteries or repairing keypads compared to just maintaining a regular lock?

Been there with the frozen keyholes - nothing like standing outside in January, hands numb, trying to coax a lock open. I switched to a keypad a couple years back, mostly out of frustration. Honestly, I had the same worry about batteries dying at the worst possible time. The one I got has a little backup key slot (hidden under a cap), but of course, that means still keeping track of a key... kind of defeats the purpose.

Long-term costs are interesting. I’ve replaced the batteries maybe twice in three years (uses AA’s), so not too bad, but I did have to call support once when the buttons started sticking after a wet spring. That repair cost more than a new deadbolt would’ve. Still, not having to deal with frozen locks or lost keys has been worth it for me.

If you’re handy, regular locks are cheaper and easier to fix yourself. But for convenience, especially with kids running in and out, the keypad wins. Hidden expenses on both sides, like you said - just depends which hassle you’d rather deal with.


Reply
animation937

You’re not alone in weighing all those trade-offs. I’ve found regular locks easier to tinker with if something goes wrong, but honestly, the convenience of a keypad - especially when your hands are full or it’s freezing out - can’t be overstated. Battery changes are rare if you use good ones, and most models warn you before they die. That said, I do keep a backup key hidden just in case... old habits die hard. Either way, you’re making a smart call thinking ahead about costs and hassle.


Reply

I totally get the backup key thing - my parents always had one stashed in a fake rock by the porch, and I used to roll my eyes at it. Now, after locking myself out twice during this reno (once with paint all over my hands, once in the rain), I’m starting to appreciate their paranoia. I’ve been eyeing those keypad locks for the new door, but I keep wondering: what happens if the electronics glitch out? Like, not just dead batteries, but a legit malfunction. I’m not super techy, so the idea of troubleshooting a lock with a manual in one hand and YouTube in the other isn’t exactly appealing.

On the other hand, I’ve had regular locks freeze up in winter, and that’s its own headache. I guess there’s no perfect solution - just different flavors of hassle. Curious if anyone’s actually had a keypad lock totally fail on them, not just run out of juice? Did you end up calling a locksmith, or was there some workaround?

It’s wild how something as basic as getting into your house can turn into a whole saga. Makes me think twice about hiding a key, even if it feels a bit old-school.


Reply

- Totally relate to the fake rock key - my folks did the same, and I used to think it was overkill.
- I’ve actually had a keypad lock freeze up once (not battery, just glitched out after a power surge). Ended up crawling through a window, which was... not my finest hour.
- Most keypad models have a physical key backup, but honestly, finding the key when you need it is its own adventure.
- Regular locks freezing in winter is brutal too. I’ve seen people use de-icer sprays, but that’s not always handy when you’re standing outside in socks.
- At this point, I’m leaning toward a keypad with a key override and maybe a super well-hidden spare, just in case.
- It’s wild how much thought goes into something as simple as getting in your own door.


Reply
carolcollector9073

- The fake rock key is such a classic - my parents had one too, except theirs was this weird plastic turtle that stuck out like a sore thumb. Never fooled anyone, but hey, it made for a good story.

- Keypad locks are great until they decide to have a meltdown. I once had to use a credit card to jimmy open my own back door (not as easy as the movies make it look, by the way). Ended up scratching the paint, which bugged me more than the lock drama.

- Totally agree about the physical backup key. I swear, those things migrate to the most random places. I’ve found mine in a drawer with old takeout menus and, once, in a planter. Not my proudest moment.

- Winter locks are the worst. I’ve tried the de-icer trick, but usually just end up breathing on the lock like some desperate dragon. Not super effective, but at least it keeps your hands warm for a second.

- At this point, I’m convinced there’s no perfect solution. Maybe a keypad with a backup key, plus a hidden spare, plus a neighbor who owes you a favor... just in case.


Reply

That plastic turtle story made me laugh - my dad went with the “hide it under the doormat” classic, which is basically an invitation for anyone to let themselves in. I tried a keypad lock when I moved in, but it glitched the first cold snap and started beeping like a microwave. Ended up climbing through a basement window (which, by the way, is not as easy as it looks when you’re holding a bag of groceries and regretting every life choice). Now I just hand a spare to my neighbor and hope for the best.


Reply
aspenfoodie

Man, I’ve been there with the “creative” entry attempts - once tried to jimmy a window open with a credit card and ended up snapping the card and nearly my wrist. The cold-weather keypad fail is classic tech irony... you pay extra for convenience and end up crawling through a window anyway.

Honestly, giving a spare to your neighbor is underrated. People get nervous about it, but most neighbors are more trustworthy than we give them credit for. Plus, it’s way less embarrassing than explaining to a locksmith why you’re standing outside in pajamas at 7am. I’ve also seen folks use those little lockboxes with codes (like realtors use), but even those can freeze up or get jammed if you’re in a colder area.

At the end of the day, whatever keeps you from doing acrobatics with groceries is probably the right call. There’s no perfect system, but at least you’ve got a backup plan now.


Reply
margaretrunner854

Lockboxes always make me nervous - maybe it’s just from seeing too many break-in stories, but I can’t help thinking someone could crack the code if they really wanted. I’ve actually designed a few mudrooms with little hidden cubbies for spare keys, but then you have to remember where you put them, which is its own challenge. Have you ever tried one of those fingerprint locks? I’m curious if they’re any more reliable in the cold or if it’s just another tech headache waiting to happen.


Reply

Title: Locked Out Drama - What Would You Do?

Have you ever tried one of those fingerprint locks? I’m curious if they’re any more reliable in the cold or if it’s just another tech headache waiting to happen.

Totally get the lockbox paranoia - I've seen enough Dateline episodes to be suspicious of anything with a code. As for fingerprint locks, I've installed a couple for clients who wanted to go "full spy movie," but honestly, they're not foolproof. Cold weather can mess with the sensors, and if your hands are dry or you just put on lotion... good luck. My step-by-step: 1) Hide a key somewhere only you would look (think inside a fake rock, not under the mat), 2) Keep a backup with a neighbor you trust, and 3) If you go high-tech, always have a Plan B. Tech is great until it isn't - then you're standing outside waving at your own door like an idiot.


Reply
shadow_nomad

I hear you on the fingerprint locks - I've tested a couple and they're cool in theory, but winter is a pain. My hands get cracked and the sensor just blinks at me. I still keep a regular key hidden, just in case tech decides to take a day off. Honestly, nothing beats a good old-fashioned spare.


Reply

Yeah, those sensors just don’t get along with winter hands. I’ve got an old house and honestly, half the time I’m just hoping the original lock doesn’t jam on me. Ever tried one of those combo keypads? Wondering if they’re any better when it’s freezing out...


Reply
cmitchell70

Ever tried one of those combo keypads? Wondering if they’re any better when it’s freezing out...

Honestly, I swapped out the old deadbolt for a keypad last winter after getting locked out with numb fingers one too many times. It’s not perfect - buttons can get stiff if there’s ice buildup, but at least you’re not fumbling for keys with gloves on. One thing, though: if your door isn’t perfectly aligned (old house problems), even the fanciest keypad won’t save you from a sticky latch. I’d say it’s an upgrade, but not a miracle cure.


Reply
marketing_aaron

even the fanciest keypad won’t save you from a sticky latch

That’s spot on. I’ve installed a handful of these in rentals, and honestly, the keypad’s only as good as the hardware behind it. If the deadbolt or strike plate is even a little off, you’ll still be wrestling with the door. For older doors, I usually do a quick alignment and hit the latch with some graphite lubricant before winter. Makes a big difference, especially when temps drop and things swell up.


Reply

Honestly, I get the point about hardware, but I’d push back a bit on always reaching for graphite or quick fixes. Sometimes those lubricants just mask a bigger issue - like a warped jamb or moisture problems. I’ve had better luck swapping out old weatherstripping and using reclaimed hardwood for repairs. It’s a bit more work upfront, but it keeps things moving smoothly year-round and cuts down on waste. Plus, less chemical residue indoors. Just my two cents...


Reply

I get where you’re coming from - quick fixes like graphite are just band-aids if the door’s actually out of whack. I’ve seen folks dump half a can of spray lube into a sticky lock, only to have the door swell shut again after the next rainstorm. Swapping out weatherstripping and fixing up the jamb is definitely more work, but it’s the kind of thing that actually solves the problem instead of kicking it down the road.

That said, sometimes people just want their door to open right now, especially if they’re standing outside in the cold with groceries. I’m curious - when you’re dealing with an old door that’s already seen better days, do you always go for reclaimed hardwood? Or do you ever just bite the bullet and replace the whole unit? I’ve had clients who swear by patching things up, but sometimes it feels like you’re fighting a losing battle with old wood and shifting frames...


Reply
music811

Honestly, I’ve patched up more old doors than I care to admit, and sometimes it really does feel like you’re just delaying the inevitable. But hey, there’s something satisfying about squeezing a few more years out of a stubborn old door. I usually try reclaimed wood if the frame’s still got some life - otherwise, yeah, sometimes you just have to call it and get a new one. No shame in admitting defeat to a 70-year-old jamb that’s seen one too many winters.


Reply
dennis_runner

No shame in admitting defeat to a 70-year-old jamb that’s seen one too many winters.

Honestly, I needed to hear that. I keep thinking I should be able to fix everything with enough patience and wood filler, but sometimes you just hit that point where it’s more stress than it’s worth. I tried patching up my back door last fall - ended up fighting with warped boards for hours. In the end, replacing was way less hassle. There’s definitely something to be said for knowing when to move on.


Reply
running650

Yeah, I hear you. There’s only so many times you can sand, fill, and repaint before the whole thing just feels like a lost cause. I used to get stubborn about “saving” old stuff too, but after wrestling with a doorframe that crumbled every time I touched it, I just started budgeting for replacements instead. Sometimes you just gotta let the old wood retire gracefully... and save yourself a few headaches in the process.


Reply
geo912

Yeah, I get that. There’s a point where patching up old wood turns into a never-ending project. I tried to “save” a window sill once - epoxy, filler, the works - but every time I thought I’d fixed it, another chunk would flake off. Sometimes you just have to accept defeat and swap it out. New materials can be a lifesaver, especially when you’re dealing with locks and security. No shame in letting the relics go if they’re giving you grief.


Reply

Totally get it - sometimes you just hit a wall with old wood. I tried patching a door frame last year, but after the third round of repairs, I gave up and replaced it. Old charm is great, but not when you’re locked out in the rain. New hardware’s worth it for peace of mind.


Reply
Scroll to Top