Remodeling discussions and local services.

locked out drama - what would you do?

1,314 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I get where you’re coming from. I had a client last year who insisted on a fancy WiFi-enabled deadbolt for their new mudroom door. Looked cool, but a few months later, I got a call - lock wouldn’t budge, batteries died, and the backup key was inside. Ended up having to pop a window screen to get in. Not exactly the “smart” solution they were hoping for.

Personally, I stick with a solid mechanical deadbolt at home. I did swap out the old brass one for a recycled steel model when I redid the door, but it’s still just a key and a bolt. Less to go wrong, and if it ever does, I can fix it with a screwdriver and a trip to the hardware store. I get the appeal of keypads, especially if you’ve got kids or roommates, but for me, the fewer things that need batteries, the better. Maybe I’m just stubborn, but I’d rather trust a chunk of metal than a circuit board when it comes to keeping my house secure.


Reply
rain_quantum1000

That story about the mudroom made me laugh - only because I’ve been there too.

“Ended up having to pop a window screen to get in. Not exactly the ‘smart’ solution they were hoping for.”
I once designed a mudroom with a keypad lock, thinking it’d be perfect for a family with teens. Two months later, the battery died during a rainstorm and everyone was stuck outside with groceries. Since then, I always recommend mechanical locks for exterior doors. Tech is great until it isn’t... sometimes old-school really is best.


Reply

Honestly, I’ve been burned by those fancy locks too - once had to crawl through a dog door in front of my neighbor. Embarrassing. Mechanical deadbolts might not be “smart,” but at least they don’t need AA batteries. Sometimes simple just works better, you know?


Reply
sandra_star2265

Had a similar run-in last winter - picture me, in pajamas, standing on my porch at 6am because the “smart” lock decided it needed a firmware update. I swear, my Victorian doesn’t care about Wi-Fi. Give me a solid old-fashioned key any day. There’s something comforting about hearing that deadbolt click… no batteries required, just a bit of elbow grease if it sticks. Sometimes progress just means more ways to get stuck outside.


Reply

I hear you on the “smart” lock drama - been there, freezing in my socks, cursing Bluetooth. Here’s my go-to: I keep a backup mechanical key hidden (not under the mat, learned that lesson). Also, regular lube on the deadbolt keeps it from sticking when you least need surprises. If you’re stuck with a smart lock, maybe stash a power bank by the door? Not elegant, but better than shivering in plaid pajamas.


Reply
georger33

I keep a backup mechanical key hidden (not under the mat, learned that lesson).

Yeah, hiding the key under the mat is basically an open invitation for Murphy’s Law to show up - ask me how I know. I once thought I was clever and stashed mine inside a fake rock in the garden. Turns out, my neighbor’s dog is part bloodhound and found it within a week... so now I get creative (and a little paranoid) about hiding spots.

I totally get the pain with smart locks. My house is old enough that if it senses anything “smart,” it probably just wants to short-circuit out of spite. I tried one of those Bluetooth ones last winter, and of course, it picked the coldest night to decide it didn’t recognize my phone. There I was, standing on the porch with two bags of groceries and a rapidly freezing lasagna, just staring at my door like it might magically open if I glared hard enough.

Honestly, nothing beats a good old-fashioned key. But your power bank idea is solid - never thought of that. The only thing is, in my house, there are about three places where you can actually plug something in without tripping a breaker. Old wiring has its own sense of humor.

One trick I picked up: keep one of those magnetic lockboxes somewhere outside but not in the obvious spots. It’s saved me more than once when my “smart” devices decided to take a nap.

And yeah, regular lube on the deadbolt is underrated advice. WD-40 is practically part of my toolkit at this point - right next to duct tape and a flashlight that only works when you don’t need it.

Anyway, if you ever figure out how to make smart locks work with 1920s doors that swell every time it rains, let me know... until then, I’ll stick with keys (and maybe an extra pair of socks by the door).


Reply
draket49

if you ever figure out how to make smart locks work with 1920s doors that swell every time it rains, let me know...

That’s the eternal struggle. I’ve tried shimming the strike plate and adjusting the hinges, but when the humidity hits, my door turns into a medieval barricade. Smart locks just don’t have the torque for old-school wood that expands like a sponge. One thing that helped a bit: I swapped in a graphite-based lubricant instead of WD-40 - seems to last longer and doesn’t gum up when it’s cold. Still, nothing beats having a backup key in a spot only I’d think to check (not the mailbox, learned that lesson too).


Reply

Honestly, I’ve had better luck just sanding the heck out of the door edges once a year than fiddling with lubricants. Graphite’s great, but if your door swells like mine, it’s like trying to butter toast with a spoon - sometimes you just gotta trim it down. My neighbor swears by dehumidifiers, but that feels like fighting nature with a plug.


Reply
maggies53

I get where you’re coming from - sometimes sanding’s just the only thing that works when the wood keeps swelling. I’ve tried the dehumidifier route too, but honestly, it barely made a dent during our humid summers. Have you ever tried sealing the door edges with a good exterior varnish? I’ve found it slows down the swelling a bit, though it’s not a miracle fix. Curious if anyone’s had luck with weatherstripping or maybe even swapping out the door material altogether...


Reply

Have you ever tried sealing the door edges with a good exterior varnish? I’ve found it slows down the swelling a bit, though it’s not a miracle fix.

- Tried varnish on my back door last year. Helped for a few months, but come July, the thing was sticking again. I think once the wood’s already taken on moisture over a few seasons, it just keeps coming back.
- Weatherstripping worked for me on an interior door, but on the main entry? Not so much. The swelling was too much for the strip to handle - just made closing it even harder.
- Swapping out for fiberglass or steel is probably the most “permanent” fix, but that’s a whole project. Did that at my old place after getting locked out twice in one summer (not fun). Fiberglass doesn’t move with humidity like wood does, and you can get them with a wood-look finish if that matters.
- If you’re sticking with wood, sanding and sealing is about all you can do short-term. I’d avoid sanding too much though - if you take off too much, you’ll have gaps in winter when everything shrinks back.
- One trick I picked up: run a box fan near the door on really humid days. Not a long-term solution, but it helps if you’re desperate and don’t want to sand again.

Honestly, after enough years fighting with swollen doors, I just budgeted for a new one. Sometimes it’s just not worth the hassle... especially if you’ve already been locked out once or twice.


Reply

I get the appeal of just swapping to fiberglass or steel, but I’ve actually had decent luck with a different approach - installing a storm door. It acts as a buffer, so the main wood door isn’t hit with direct humidity or rain as much. Not a total cure, but it cut down on swelling for me. Plus, you get a bit more insulation and security. Might not be for everyone, but if you like the look of your wood door and want to keep it around a bit longer, it’s worth considering before going full replacement.


Reply
timd16

That’s actually a pretty clever workaround. I’ve thought about storm doors but always wondered - do they make much of a difference in winter drafts? I’m all for saving the wood door if possible, but I worry about the extra cost and whether it’s just delaying the inevitable. Did you have to do much maintenance on the storm door itself, or is it pretty much set-and-forget? I’m definitely leaning toward anything that doesn’t involve dropping hundreds on a new door right now...


Reply

I’ve thought about storm doors but always wondered - do they make much of a difference in winter drafts?

Honestly, I was skeptical too until I put one in last year. My old wood door’s seen better days, and I figured a storm door was just putting off the inevitable. But it actually made a bigger difference than I expected - less drafty, and the entryway didn’t feel like a wind tunnel anymore. Maintenance-wise, it’s mostly wiping down glass and tightening a hinge now and then. Not totally set-and-forget, but way less hassle than replacing the whole door for now. If your main door’s not rotting or warped, it might buy you some time without breaking the bank.


Reply
nickh20

Storm doors can actually make a noticeable difference, especially if your main door isn’t in perfect shape. I’ve recommended them to clients with draft issues, and most report back that their entryway feels less chilly. They’re not a magic fix, but for the cost and effort, it’s a practical upgrade.

One thing to keep in mind - if you ever get locked out, a storm door can be both a blessing and a curse. If it’s got its own lock and you accidentally pull the main door shut behind you, you might find yourself stuck outside twice over. I’ve seen it happen more than once during remodels when folks are juggling groceries or tools. If you go this route, maybe skip locking the storm door unless you’re extra cautious or have a spare key hidden somewhere safe.

Maintenance is pretty minimal. Wipe down the glass, check the seals every season, and tighten up hardware if it starts to rattle. I wouldn’t say it replaces a solid main door if yours is truly shot, but if you’re just dealing with drafts and the occasional cold snap, it’s a solid stopgap.

Funny enough, I once had a client who installed a storm door mainly for curb appeal, but ended up loving how much warmer her foyer felt in January. She called it “the best accidental insulation” she’d ever bought. Sometimes the small fixes make the biggest difference... as long as you don’t lock yourself out in your slippers.


Reply

Locked Out Drama - What Would You Do?

Been there, done that - locked myself out with both doors once, and it was a pain. Here’s what I do now: I keep a spare key in one of those fake rock things (not the most secure, but better than freezing). I also put a little sticky note on the inside of the storm door that just says “KEY?” as a reminder. Not the prettiest, but it works. I agree, storm doors help with drafts, but if you’re forgetful like me, double-check those locks before heading out in your socks...


Reply
photography_eric9794

I keep a spare key in one of those fake rock things (not the most secure, but better than freezing).

That’s actually a clever workaround - sometimes practicality wins over perfection, right? I’ve seen folks invest in smart locks with keypad entry, but I always wonder: do those really solve the problem, or just add another thing to forget the code for? Your sticky note idea is simple but effective. Ever thought about a neighbor you trust holding a spare? It’s not foolproof, but sometimes community beats gadgets.


Reply
chessplayer345484

I’ve seen folks invest in smart locks with keypad entry, but I always wonder: do those really solve the problem, or just add another thing to forget the code for?

Honestly, I’ve installed a few keypad locks for clients. They’re convenient, but yeah - codes get forgotten, batteries die, and then you’re back at square one. Personally, I lean toward a combo: trusted neighbor with a spare and a mechanical lockbox (the kind realtors use). Less tech to fail, more peace of mind.


Reply
georgetrader

I hear you on the tech fails - nothing like standing outside with dead batteries and groceries. I’ve seen folks stash a spare key in a recycled pill bottle tucked in the garden, too. Low-tech, but it works. Your combo approach sounds pretty solid, honestly.


Reply
mecho56

I’ve seen folks stash a spare key in a recycled pill bottle tucked in the garden, too. Low-tech, but it works.

That’s actually what my neighbor did - except squirrels kept digging up her “hidden” key. She switched to a combo lockbox bolted behind her compost bin, which seems to work better. I like the idea of blending tech with old-school backups, but I’m always a little wary about hiding keys outside. Too easy to forget where you put them, or worse, someone else finds them first. Still, anything’s better than standing in the rain with melting ice cream and no way in...


Reply

Too easy to forget where you put them, or worse, someone else finds them first.

That’s exactly my worry with outdoor hiding spots. I once tried the “fake rock” trick, but it just looked so out of place in my tiny front yard - like, who are we kidding? If you’re going for subtlety, the combo lockbox is a step up. Here’s how I’d approach it:

1. If you’re set on a physical backup, pick a lockbox that blends in with your exterior (matte black or green works well near plants).
2. Mount it somewhere that’s not in direct line of sight but still accessible - behind a planter or under the deck stairs.
3. For tech, smart locks with keypad entry are great as long as you remember to change the code regularly and keep batteries fresh.
4. Always have a backup plan inside the house too - like giving a spare to someone you trust nearby.

I’m still not convinced there’s a perfect solution, but at least standing in the rain juggling groceries is less likely if you’ve got layers of backup.


Reply
Scroll to Top