Remodeling discussions and local services.

When gutters outlast the house: a rainwater mystery

476 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

donaldclimber

Funny how gutters seem to be the one thing that just won’t quit, even when everything else is falling apart. I’ve tried those foam inserts too - total mess, especially with all the maple seeds around here. Honestly, I just stick to the old ladder and hose routine twice a year. It’s not glamorous, but at least I know what I’m dealing with. Gutter guards always sound good until you’re scraping out compacted pine needles anyway... Sometimes simple really is better.


Reply
tea_jeff

Gutter guards always sound good until you’re scraping out compacted pine needles anyway... Sometimes simple really is better.

I get what you mean about the gutter guards. I tried the mesh kind last fall, thinking it’d save me time, but all it did was trap wet leaves and make the clogs harder to spot. Ended up having to pull the whole thing off just to get at the mess underneath. Maybe they work better in areas without so many trees, but with maples and pines, it’s just not worth it.

The ladder and hose method isn’t fun, but at least you can see what’s going on up there. I’ve started using a small plastic scoop too - less splashback than the hose alone, especially when stuff’s packed in tight. Not glamorous, but like you said, at least you know what you’re dealing with. Sometimes low-tech wins.


Reply

Funny, I had this vision of gutter guards as a “set it and forget it” solution, but reality was a lot messier. My last place had these fancy foam inserts - looked promising at first, but after one storm, they were basically compost. I ended up pulling out soggy clumps that smelled like a swamp. Honestly, I’d rather just schedule a clean-out and call it a day. Sometimes the old-school way is less hassle in the long run, even if it’s not glamorous.


Reply
carolgardener

Honestly, I’d rather just schedule a clean-out and call it a day. Sometimes the old-school way is less hassle in the long run, even if it’s not glamorous.

I get where you’re coming from - foam inserts are notorious for turning into sludge. But have you tried the metal mesh kind? They’re pricier up front, but I’ve found they hold up way better than the foam or plastic options. Cleaning’s still needed now and then, but at least it’s not a total swamp situation every time. Not perfect, but a decent step up from pulling out composted gunk.


Reply

“Cleaning’s still needed now and then, but at least it’s not a total swamp situation every time.”

That’s been my experience too. I swapped out foam for stainless mesh on a client’s place a couple years back - definitely less of a mess, though pine needles still find their way in. I’m curious, has anyone tried those reverse curve covers? I’ve heard mixed things, especially about heavy rain just overshooting the gutter. Worth the investment, or just another gimmick?


Reply
jsummit32

Reverse curve covers have been a bit of a mixed bag for me. I put them on the north side of my 1920s place about five years ago, mostly because the maples out front were dumping so much debris that even mesh wasn’t cutting it. They did keep out the leaves, but you’re right - during those heavy downpours, water sometimes just shot right over the edge and pooled near the foundation. Not ideal, especially with an old stone basement that’s already prone to dampness.

I ended up taking them off after two seasons. The overshoot was worse than the occasional clog, honestly. Maybe they work better on newer homes with different roof pitches or less intense rain? I’ve heard some folks swear by them, but in my case, it just wasn’t worth the hassle or expense.

What’s worked best for me is a combination of fine stainless mesh and regular maintenance. It’s not glamorous, but at least I know what to expect. Pine needles are still a nuisance - those things find their way into everything - but it’s manageable compared to the swampy mess I used to deal with.

One thing I’d add: if you’re dealing with historic gutters (mine are half-round copper), be careful with any add-ons. Some covers can trap moisture or cause corrosion if they’re not installed just right. Sometimes the old ways - just climbing up there twice a year - are still the most reliable, even if it’s not anyone’s favorite chore.

If you do try something new, I’d be curious how it holds up long-term. For now, I’m sticking with what’s tried and true... and keeping my ladder handy.


Reply
yoga_elizabeth

Sometimes the old ways - just climbing up there twice a year - are still the most reliable, even if it’s not anyone’s favorite chore.

I hear you on that. I’ve flipped a few older homes and those half-round copper gutters are beautiful but so picky about what you put on them. I tried those foam inserts once - total disaster, just turned into a soggy mess. Ever thought about rain chains or extending your downspouts further from the foundation? Sometimes redirecting the water is easier than fighting gravity at the gutter edge.


Reply
law_debbie1927

I tried those foam inserts once - total disaster, just turned into a soggy mess.

That’s exactly what happened to me with those foam inserts. They looked promising in the hardware store, but after one season, it was like pulling out a wet sponge full of maple seeds and gunk. I’ve also noticed that with historic gutters - especially the old copper half-rounds - anything that interrupts the water flow seems to cause more trouble than it solves.

Rain chains are beautiful, and I’ve seen them used to great effect on some Craftsman bungalows around here. But I wonder if they’d really handle a heavy downpour on a big Victorian roof. My place has these elaborate eaves and multiple valleys, so the volume of water can be pretty intense during a storm. Have you actually tried rain chains on a larger roofline? Or do they work better as an accent for smaller sections?

Extending downspouts is something I swear by, though. After dealing with a damp basement for years, I finally ran flexible extensions out into the garden beds. Not the prettiest solution, but it’s kept the foundation dry and even helped some of my perennials thrive.

I’m curious if anyone’s had luck with those underground drainage systems - the kind where you bury a pipe from the downspout out to daylight or a dry well. It seems like it could be less obtrusive than long plastic tubes snaking across the yard, but I worry about clogging or roots getting in there over time.

Sometimes I think we’re all just negotiating with gravity and history at once... The old ways do have their charm (and their headaches). Has anyone found a modern fix that actually respects the look of these older homes?


Reply
nshadow20

I hear you on the foam inserts - mine turned into a science experiment by midsummer. I’ve seen rain chains look stunning, but I’m skeptical they’d keep up with the kind of runoff you get from a big Victorian roof. I tried underground drainage a few years back, and while it’s definitely less of an eyesore, I had to snake the pipes every spring because of roots and silt. Has anyone managed to keep those clear long-term without constant maintenance? I’m starting to think the old-school open trenches weren’t so dumb after all...


Reply
rocky_robinson9681

I totally get where you're coming from about the underground drainage.

I had to snake the pipes every spring because of roots and silt.
Been there, done that - roots seem to find those pipes no matter what. I’ve heard some folks swear by those perforated pipe sleeves, but honestly, I haven’t seen them make a huge difference long-term. Sometimes the “ugly” open trenches just work, you know? Maybe there’s a way to blend them in with landscaping if you go that route again. Anyone else ever tried hiding a trench with river rock or plants?


Reply
susandrummer

I tried the river rock trick once - looked great for about a month, then weeds started poking through like they owned the place.

Sometimes the “ugly” open trenches just work, you know?
Honestly, I think you’re right. Sometimes function wins over pretty. Maybe some creeping thyme or low ground cover could help disguise the worst of it?


Reply

- I get the appeal of hiding trenches, but honestly, sometimes those “ugly” channels are the only thing that keeps water moving where it should.
- Tried ground covers before - looked lush for a bit, but roots clogged things up fast.
- If you’re set on pretty, maybe flagstone stepping stones with gaps for drainage? Less maintenance than thyme, and still looks intentional.
- Sometimes you just gotta embrace the utilitarian look... at least until you find something that actually works long-term.


Reply

Sometimes you just gotta embrace the utilitarian look... at least until you find something that actually works long-term.

That’s been my story for years. Our house is nearly a century old, and every time I try to “pretty up” the drainage, I end up with water sneaking into the basement or pooling under the porch. Once tried those creeping ground covers - looked great for a season, then roots found their way into every crack and made things worse. Has anyone managed to make those stone channels blend in without them turning into a mossy slip’n’slide? Or is it just wishful thinking with these old houses?


Reply

Stone channels are a double-edged sword, honestly. I’ve tried to make them look less like a construction site and more like part of the landscaping, but it’s tough. Even with careful grading, the moss and algae just take over after a couple of wet seasons, and then you’re basically ice skating every time it rains. I once tried mixing in some river rock with smaller gravel and planting sedges along the edge - looked decent for a while, but the roots started creeping in and clogged up the flow.

With these old houses, sometimes function just has to win out. I’ve settled for keeping the channels clear and just tossing a few big potted plants nearby to distract from the utilitarian look. Not perfect, but at least the basement stays dry. If there’s a magic solution, I haven’t found it yet...


Reply

Even with careful grading, the moss and algae just take over after a couple of wet seasons, and then you’re basically ice skating every time it rains.

That’s so real. I’ve nearly wiped out more than once on those slick stones - makes you wonder if the “natural look” is worth the bruises. I tried a flagstone path once, thinking it’d blend in, but the green slime was relentless. Ever looked into those resin-bound aggregates? Supposedly less slippery, but I’ve never seen them up close. Curious if they actually hold up in a soggy yard.


Reply

I get the appeal of those resin-bound paths, but honestly, I’m not convinced they’re the magic fix for slippery yards. My neighbor put one in last year - looked great at first, but after a few months of heavy rain, it started to get patchy and weirdly tacky underfoot. Plus, if you’ve got a lot of tree cover, the organic gunk still builds up and gets slick. I’d rather stick with gravel or even mulch, messy as it is. At least you can rake it out and start fresh when it gets gross.


Reply
charliee36

I hear you on the resin-bound stuff - my cousin had similar issues with theirs, especially under trees. Gravel does get messy, but at least it’s easy to maintain. Have you ever tried those permeable pavers? I’ve wondered if they’re any better for drainage and slipperiness long-term.


Reply

Permeable pavers are definitely worth a look if you’re tired of the resin-bound headaches. I put some in a side path a few years back and, honestly, they’ve held up better than I expected. Drainage is solid - even after a downpour, there’s barely any pooling. As for slipperiness, they’re not perfect, but way less slick than resin or even some concrete when wet. The only thing is, you’ll need to keep an eye on weeds popping up between the gaps, especially if you’ve got trees nearby. Nothing’s totally maintenance-free, but at least with pavers, you can pull up a section if roots start messing with things - beats having to redo the whole surface. If you’re already dealing with gutter overflow, the extra drainage from pavers could help a bit, too. Just make sure you prep the base right, or you’ll be chasing sunken spots down the line.


Reply
fmaverick18

Couldn’t agree more about the drainage - permeable pavers are a game changer if you’re sick of water pooling everywhere. I will say, though, the weed thing can get old fast if you’re not on top of it. I’ve tried the polymeric sand trick between the joints, and it helps a bit, but nothing’s perfect. Still, compared to resin-bound or asphalt, it’s way less hassle in the long run. Plus, if you’re thinking about rainwater harvesting, that extra infiltration means less runoff to deal with. Just wish more folks realized how much difference a good base makes... half the issues I see are from people skipping that step.


Reply
literature492

Funny you mention the base - my neighbor redid their patio last year and just laid the pavers right on dirt. Looked great for about a month, then every rain turned it into a wobbly mess. Can’t stress enough how much prep work saves headaches down the line. I’m with you on weeds though... they find a way no matter what you do. Polymeric sand helped in my courtyard, but I still get the odd stubborn sprout here and there.


Reply
Scroll to Top