Remodeling discussions and local services.

Convection vs. Conventional Ovens: Which One Actually Makes a Difference?

436 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I get the nostalgia for old-school casseroles, but I’ve actually had decent luck with convection for juicy dishes - just gotta drop the temp by 25 degrees and keep a close eye on things. My lasagna comes out with those crispy edges but still gooey in the middle, which is kind of my favorite part. Maybe it’s just my oven, but I don’t notice much drying out if I cover it tight.

Funny you mentioned energy bills - I noticed the same thing after our kitchen remodel. The oven’s not running as long, and it’s nice not having to rotate pans all the time. I do agree on bread, though. Tried a sourdough last month and it looked like a deflated tire. Guess some things just need that slower, gentler heat.


Reply

Funny you mentioned energy bills - I noticed the same thing after our kitchen remodel. The oven’s not running as long, and it’s nice not having to rotate pans all the time.

That’s been my experience too - after swapping out appliances in a couple of rentals, I was surprised how much less the tenants complained about uneven cooking. I do wonder if convection is just more forgiving for stuff like lasagna and casseroles, but I’ve had mixed results with cookies. Anyone else notice that? Sometimes they brown way faster on the edges than I expect. Maybe it’s just me, but I still miss the “set it and forget it” vibe of the old ovens for certain things...


Reply
gdiver69

Yeah, I’ve noticed cookies can be tricky in convection too. I once had a batch where the edges crisped up before the middles even set - guess the air flow is a double-edged sword. Still, for lasagna and sheet pan dinners, it’s been a game-changer. Sometimes I do miss the quirks of the old ovens, though... there was something comforting about knowing exactly how they’d mess up.


Reply

- Totally get what you mean about the “predictable mess-ups” of old ovens - kinda like that one friend who’s always late but you know exactly how late they’ll be.
- Convection has been a mixed bag for me. Sheet pan meals? Yes, please. But I tried roasting veggies once and half of them turned into veggie chips while the rest were basically steamed. Not my finest hour.
- I’ve started using parchment paper more to keep cookies from going full hockey puck on the edges, but it’s still a gamble.
- One thing I do love: my pizza crusts finally get crispy without turning the toppings into charcoal. That alone almost makes up for the cookie roulette.

Anyone ever try baking bread in a convection oven? I’m still too chicken after a sourdough disaster last year...


Reply
danielpodcaster

I totally get the hesitation after a sourdough fail - been there, and it’s rough. Honestly, convection can be tricky with bread, but it’s not impossible. If you ever get the nerve, just drop the temp by about 25 degrees and keep an eye on the crust. Mine turned out way better than I expected, even if it wasn’t bakery-level. Worst case, you get croutons for soup...


Reply

Worst case, you get croutons for soup...

Honestly, my last “artisan” loaf came out closer to a medieval weapon than anything edible. The convection fan turned my crust into armor plating. But hey, I just smashed it up and tossed it in my compost - zero waste bread fail, right? I do kind of miss the chewy centers you get with conventional ovens, though. Maybe it’s nostalgia or maybe it’s just my teeth thanking me.


Reply

I totally get what you mean about the crust turning into something out of a blacksmith’s shop. I tried baking pizza in my convection oven once, thinking it’d be all crispy and perfect, but the edges were basically petrified. I’m convinced some things just need that old-school, steady heat. Maybe convection is great for roasting veggies or getting chicken skin crispy, but bread? I’m not sold. There’s something about the way a conventional oven lets the inside stay soft that convection just can’t match, at least in my experience.


Reply
streamer209171

- Totally hear you on the pizza crust - convection can really turn it into a brick if you’re not careful.
- I’ve noticed the same thing with homemade bread. Tried convection for a sourdough loaf once and the outside was hard as a rock, but the inside was still kinda gummy. Not ideal.
- For stuff like roasted potatoes or even bacon, though, convection’s a game changer. Everything gets super crispy without having to flip things halfway through.
- One thing I did find: lowering the temp by about 25 degrees in convection mode helped a bit with cookies and softer baked goods. Still not quite the same as that slow, steady heat from a regular oven, though.
- Ever tried using a baking stone or steel in your convection oven? I’ve had mixed results, but sometimes it helps even out the heat.

Curious if anyone’s found a way to get that chewy crust without sacrificing the inside... or is it just one of those things where old-school wins every time?


Reply
becky_rider

I’ve wrestled with this too, especially after I redid my kitchen and finally got a convection oven. Thought it’d be the holy grail for everything, but bread and pizza crusts are still tricky. I’ve tried the baking steel in convection mode - sometimes it helps, sometimes it just makes the bottom brown faster while the top stays pale. Not sure if it’s my dough or just physics refusing to cooperate.

Lowering the temp does help a bit, but I still get that weird combo of tough crust and underbaked middle if I’m not careful. The only thing that’s worked semi-consistently for me is starting with convection for like 10 minutes to get some color, then switching back to regular bake for the rest. Kind of a pain, but better than ending up with a bread brick.

Funny enough, my old-school oven in the garage (the one I keep meaning to haul off) actually does a better job on sourdough than the fancy new one. Makes me wonder if all these “upgrades” are worth it sometimes... At least roasted veggies come out perfect every time now.

If anyone’s cracked the code on chewy crusts in convection, I’m all ears. Otherwise, might just stick to conventional for bread days and save convection for bacon and potatoes - can’t argue with crispy bacon that cooks itself.


Reply

Convection’s one of those things that sounds like a magic fix, but I’ve had similar headaches. Here’s what’s worked (or not) for me, in case it helps:

- Bread and pizza: Convection seems to dry out the top before the inside is fully cooked. I get that same combo - tough crust, gummy middle. Not a fan.
- Baking steel: Tried it too, but convection just turbo-charges the bottom and leaves the rest lagging behind. Almost feels like I’m fighting my own oven sometimes.
- Temp tweaks: Dropping the temp by 25 degrees helps a bit, but then the bake takes forever and still isn’t quite right.
- Split bake method: That “start with convection, finish with conventional” thing - yep, been there. It works better than one or the other alone, but honestly, it’s a hassle when you’re juggling dinner prep and laundry.

Honestly, my old coil oven from the ‘90s does a better job on bread. Go figure. The new one is great for frozen pizzas and roasted veggies (I swear, cauliflower gets almost too crispy), but if I want a chewy sourdough crust, I drag out the “antique.”

I keep thinking there must be some pro baker trick I’m missing... or maybe all those Instagram-perfect loaves are just smoke and mirrors.

Funny aside - my spouse thought convection would save us money on energy bills. Not sure that’s panned out either. Still waiting for my utility bill to shrink.

Bottom line: For anything needing a crunchy outside and soft inside (bread, pizza), I stick with conventional. Convection wins for bacon, potatoes, sheet pan dinners - stuff where crispiness rules.

If someone invents an oven that magically does both perfectly without babysitting... sign me up (but only if it fits my budget).


Reply
data_cloud

Totally get what you mean about the “magic fix” thing. When we renovated, I was convinced convection would change my life - spoiler: it mostly just changed how fast I burn cookies.

- Bread: Same struggle. My first sourdough loaf in the new oven looked great... until I sliced it and found a doughy cave inside.
- Pizza: I keep trying convection for “crispy crust” but end up with a weirdly dry top and floppy bottom. Not the pizza night I imagined.
- Roasted veggies: Convection is a beast here. Broccoli practically turns into chips if I’m not careful.

Honestly, I’m still figuring out which setting to trust. If there’s a secret handshake for perfect bread, I haven’t learned it yet.


Reply
diy934

Convection’s one of those features that sounds fantastic on paper, but in reality, it’s a mixed bag. I’ve seen folks get really frustrated when their fancy new oven doesn’t magically make them a better baker overnight. In my experience, convection’s great for roasting - like your broccoli chips, or getting potatoes nice and crispy - but for bread and pizza? I’m not sold. That constant fan can dry out dough before it’s had a chance to rise or set properly, especially if you’re not dropping the temp by 25 degrees or so.

Truth is, most recipes are written for conventional ovens, and unless you’re willing to tweak times and temps (and maybe even mess with pan placement), you’re gonna get some weird results. Out of curiosity, have you tried baking bread or pizza with the convection off, just using standard bake? I’ve found that’s usually more forgiving, even if it takes a little longer. Or do you think it’s more about learning the quirks of your particular oven? Everyone I know seems to have a different trick...


Reply
ericstorm286

Convection’s like that gym membership you buy in January - full of promise, but if you don’t know what you’re doing, you just end up sore and confused. I’ve seen so many folks get a new oven with all the bells and whistles, then wonder why their cookies look like hockey pucks or their pizza crust is basically a cracker. That fan is no joke. It’ll dry out your dough faster than my dog finds the one mud puddle in the yard.

I’m with you on roasting - convection’s a game changer for veggies and meats. You want crispy skin on chicken? Crank up the fan. But bread? Nah. I’ve had better luck sticking to regular bake, especially for anything that needs to rise or stay moist. Tried convection once for sourdough and ended up with a loaf that could double as a doorstop.

Honestly, half the battle is just figuring out your own oven’s quirks. Some run hot, some have cold spots... I swear, every oven has its own personality. My last one had a “hot left corner” where everything would burn if you weren’t paying attention. Now I just rotate pans like I’m spinning plates at a circus.

Tweaking temps and times is fine if you’re into experimenting, but most days I just want dinner to not be a science project. Conventional bake might take longer, but at least it’s predictable. Unless you’re baking for the Great British Bake Off, I say keep it simple and save the convection for Sunday roast potatoes.


Reply
gandalfjones331

- Totally agree - convection is killer for crisping up veggies, but I’ve dried out more than one batch of muffins thinking I’d “speed things up.”
- One thing I do like: convection seems to use a bit less energy since it cooks faster. Anyone else notice a difference in their power bill after switching?
- Still, for anything delicate or finicky, I stick with conventional. Less drama, fewer surprises.
- Curious - has anyone found a reliable way to keep bread from turning into a brick in convection mode?


Reply
melissatail10

I’ve definitely noticed the energy savings too, but I’m with you - delicate stuff just seems to go sideways in convection. For bread, I’ve tried lowering the temp by 25 degrees and adding a pan of water for steam, but honestly, it’s hit or miss. Sometimes the crust is great, other times it’s like biting into drywall. Has anyone played around with covering the loaf for part of the bake? Wondering if that helps keep things softer. Also, does anyone else find convection dries out roasted chicken faster, or is that just me?


Reply

Sometimes the crust is great, other times it’s like biting into drywall.

Yeah, convection can be a gamble with bread. I’ve covered loaves with foil for the first half - helps keep things softer, but you lose some crust crunch. And you’re not imagining it, chicken dries out way faster in convection. I usually drop the temp even more or just stick to conventional for that.


Reply
singer34

You nailed it about chicken drying out in convection. I learned that the hard way with a batch of thighs - thought I was being clever, but they came out like jerky. Now I only use convection for stuff that actually needs the air movement, like roasting veggies or getting fries crispy. Bread’s a weird one, though. Sometimes convection gives me this gorgeous, even color, but then the inside’s not quite right. I’ve tried the foil trick too, but then the crust’s kinda meh.

Honestly, for most baking, I just stick with conventional. It’s more predictable, especially for cakes and breads. If I’m doing pizza or something where I want that extra crunch, I’ll switch to convection for the last few minutes. That way you get the best of both worlds - soft inside, crispy outside.

One thing I’ve noticed: every oven seems to have its own personality. My old oven ran hot, so convection was a disaster. My current one’s more forgiving, but I still have to keep an eye on it. Thermometers help, but even then it’s a bit of a guessing game.

I don’t think there’s a “right” answer here - it’s just trial and error till you figure out what works in your kitchen. If you’re getting drywall crust, maybe try a pan of water on the bottom rack for steam? That helped me a bit. Or just embrace the rustic vibe and call it artisan...


Reply
anomad81

- Had the same issue with convection and chicken - skin got leathery, meat was dry. Not worth it.
- For bread, I’ve tried the pan of water trick too. Sometimes it helps, but honestly, my crust still ends up tougher than I want.
- My oven’s “convection” setting is more like a turbo jet. Even with temp adjustments, stuff cooks unevenly unless I rotate trays halfway.
- Conventional just feels safer for baking. Less guesswork, fewer surprises.
- Only time convection wins for me is with roasted potatoes or anything you want super crispy. Otherwise, I’m sticking to old-school.


Reply
shadow_nomad

My oven’s “convection” setting is more like a turbo jet. Even with temp adjustments, stuff cooks unevenly unless I rotate trays halfway.

That’s been my experience too - convection just blasts everything, and I end up babysitting the oven more than I’d like. I’m curious, has anyone tried using convection for things like casseroles or lasagna? Wondering if the airflow actually helps with even browning on those, or just dries out the top layer.


Reply
mochad39

Wondering if the airflow actually helps with even browning on those, or just dries out the top layer.

I’ve had mixed luck with casseroles in convection mode. The top gets that nice golden color faster, but sometimes it’s almost too crisp before the inside is bubbling. Maybe my old house oven is extra “enthusiastic,” but I usually end up tenting foil over the dish halfway through. Anyone else notice it seems to dry out cheese more than brown it? Or is that just my 1950s wiring talking...


Reply
Scroll to Top