Have you experimented much with different mud types? I've noticed that switching to a setting-type compound (like Easy Sand) for deeper fills or wider joints really cuts down on shrinkage. Takes a bit more prep, but the results have been pretty solid for me...might be worth a shot.
I've had decent luck with Easy Sand too, but honestly, the extra prep and cleanup can be a bit of a hassle. Lately, I've been leaning toward lightweight all-purpose compounds—less fuss, easier sanding, and still pretty minimal shrinkage if you layer it right. Plus, from an eco standpoint, less waste and cleanup materials involved. Might not be perfect for every deep fill, but it's worked surprisingly well for me...
Totally feel you on the Easy Sand cleanup hassle—been there, done that, still finding dried bits stuck to my tools months later...
- Lightweight all-purpose is definitely underrated. I switched over a while back and haven't looked back since. Sure, it might take an extra coat or two for deeper fills, but honestly, I'd rather slap on another thin layer than spend half my weekend chiseling hardened compound off my buckets.
- Plus, sanding Easy Sand always feels like punishment for past DIY sins. Lightweight compound sands like butter in comparison—my shoulders thank me every time.
- Eco-wise you're spot-on too. Less waste overall and fewer disposable items cluttering up the trash bin. I mean, who doesn't love feeling slightly less guilty about their DIY footprint?
- One thing I've noticed though: if you're dealing with really deep joints or big gaps (like when your drywall cuts look like they were done blindfolded...not that I'd know anything about that), sometimes it's worth biting the bullet and using setting compound first just to get a solid base. Then finish off with lightweight stuff for smoothness.
- But hey, if you've got your layering technique down pat and it's working well enough without cracking or shrinking too much—more power to ya. Drywall finishing is one of those things where if it ain't broke, don't fix it...or sand it again.
Either way, sounds like you've found a method that's keeping you sane—and that's half the battle right there.
Yeah, lightweight compound is definitely easier on cleanup. But honestly, for bigger gaps I've found setting compound saves me time overall—just gotta clean tools quick or regret it later... learned that the hard way.
Totally agree on the setting compound for bigger gaps—it's a lifesaver. Ever tried mixing in a bit of dish soap when cleaning your tools afterward? I found it helps break down the compound quicker, especially if you're not lightning-fast with cleanup. Also curious, do you usually tape your joints first or just fill directly when dealing with wider gaps? I've experimented both ways, and taping first seems to give me fewer headaches later...
