Remodeling discussions and local services.

Smart lights vs smart switches for yard setup?

660 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Less crawling around in crawlspaces, more time picking out throw pillows... priorities, right?

Honestly, I’m with you on the “haunted maze” wiring - sometimes it’s just not worth the headache. But I do think there are a few things to weigh up, especially if you’re thinking about long-term flexibility or resale.

- Curb appeal: You nailed it. A plastic smart bulb sticking out of a classic lantern is a vibe killer. If you’ve got vintage fixtures, smart switches let you keep the look and still get automation. No one knows you’ve gone high-tech except you (and maybe your electrician).
- Color options: Smart bulbs win here, hands down. If you love changing up the mood for parties or holidays, switches can’t compete. I’ve seen some wild Halloween setups with just a few color bulbs.
- Weather: You mentioned enclosed fixtures, which is key. I’ve had clients try open sconces with smart bulbs and... let’s just say, rain and electronics don’t mix. If your fixtures aren’t fully sealed, switches might be safer in the long run.
- Control: With switches, you can still use regular bulbs (including vintage-style LEDs), and everyone in the house can use the wall switch like normal. No “why won’t the porch light turn on?” moments when someone flips the switch off at the wall and kills power to the smart bulb.
- Installation: If you’re not into wiring, bulbs are the obvious choice. But if you ever do a reno or have an electrician in for something else, adding a smart switch isn’t a huge deal. Sometimes it’s just a little more upfront work for a lot less hassle later.

I’ve seen both work well, but it really comes down to how much you want to mess with the fixtures and what kind of control you want. For me, I lean switches for the front (curb appeal, classic look), and bulbs for the backyard where I can get a little more playful with color. But hey, if you’re spending more time picking out throw pillows than rewiring, you’re probably doing something right.


Reply

Had a place last year where the previous owner went all-in on smart bulbs - looked cool at first, but every time someone hit the wall switch, half the porch went dark and the app freaked out. Ended up swapping to smart switches for the front just to keep things simple (and avoid explaining “don’t touch that switch” to guests). Backyard’s a different story though... colored bulbs make BBQ nights way more fun. Guess it’s all about picking your battles.


Reply

I totally get what you mean about the “don’t touch the switch” dance - been there, and it drove my family nuts. I ended up going with smart switches in the main areas too, just because it was cheaper in the long run (those bulbs add up fast if you’ve got a bunch of fixtures). For the backyard, though, I’m kinda torn. I like the idea of colored bulbs for parties, but I’m always worried about how long they’ll last outside, especially with all the rain we get.

Have you noticed any issues with the colored bulbs holding up outdoors? I keep debating if I should just stick with regular bulbs and use some outdoor string lights for color instead... seems like a more budget-friendly way to get that vibe without worrying about replacing expensive bulbs every year.


Reply

I keep debating if I should just stick with regular bulbs and use some outdoor string lights for color instead...

Honestly, string lights are fine for vibe, but you lose a lot of control. With smart colored bulbs (rated for outdoors), you can schedule, dim, or group them - way more flexibility for events or just mood lighting. I’ve had a set outside under an awning for two years - no issues yet, even through some nasty storms. The key is making sure they’re actually rated for wet locations, not just “damp.” It’s easy to miss that detail on the box. Regular bulbs + string lights work, but you’ll be swapping out dead strings more often than you’d think... those cheap ones don’t last long in the rain either.


Reply
dobby_nomad

Honestly, I get the appeal of smart bulbs for all the control, but sometimes it’s just overkill. I’ve seen people go all-in and then barely use the features after a while.

Regular bulbs + string lights work, but you’ll be swapping out dead strings more often than you’d think...
Maybe, but if you invest in higher quality string lights (the commercial-grade ones), they actually last way longer outside - even in rain. Plus, there’s something about that old-school glow that feels cozier than the techy vibe of colored LEDs everywhere. Just depends on the mood you want, I guess.


Reply

I’ve flipped a few houses and tried both routes for yard lighting. Here’s what I found: smart bulbs are cool until you have to replace one in a weird fixture or high spot - then it’s just a pain. Smart switches, on the other hand, let you keep using whatever bulbs you want, even those vintage-style string lights. I wired up a smart switch for my patio last year and honestly, it’s been way less hassle than messing with individual smart bulbs. Plus, if you ever want to swap out the lights for something more classic or seasonal, you’re not locked into one system.


Reply
maggiebaker300

I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve actually had the opposite experience with my yard. For me, the smart bulbs have been way more flexible, especially when I want to tweak colors for holidays or just set different moods. The switches are great for keeping things simple, but I feel like you lose out on some of the fun features - like dimming or color changes - unless you go all-in with compatible bulbs anyway.

“if you ever want to swap out the lights for something more classic or seasonal, you’re not locked into one system.”

That’s true, but honestly, I just stash a few different colored smart bulbs and swap them as needed. Not a huge deal for me, even if it’s a little more effort now and then. Plus, from an energy use standpoint, a lot of the newer smart bulbs are super efficient compared to some of the older string lights I used to run through a switch. Maybe it depends on how often you actually want to change things up... For me, the extra control is worth the occasional hassle.


Reply
mythology609

I hear you on the flexibility - being able to set the mood for Halloween or just chill out with some warm lighting is pretty cool. I’ve definitely been tempted by all the color options, but I always get hung up on the idea of having to replace a bunch of bulbs if one brand stops updating their app or something. Maybe I’m just paranoid after that one time my “smart” garden lights turned into “dumb” ones overnight after a firmware update... Still, energy efficiency is a big plus, and I can’t argue with that. Guess it comes down to how much you want to tinker versus just flipping a switch and forgetting about it.


Reply
film909

Honestly, that’s why I went with smart switches instead of bulbs for my place. The wiring was a pain, but now I don’t have to worry about any one brand’s app or bulbs going obsolete. If the switch works, everything works - doesn’t matter what kind of bulb I screw in. Plus, it keeps the look more traditional, which fits my house better anyway. The color stuff is neat, but I’d rather not swap out a dozen bulbs every few years just to keep up with tech.


Reply
poetry_matthew8662

Can’t argue with the convenience of switches, especially for outdoor setups. I do get folks asking about color-changing for holiday lights, though - ever run into that? Sometimes I’ll suggest a mix: smart switches for the main stuff, then a couple smart bulbs where you want color flexibility. Wiring outside can be tricky, but at least you only have to do it once.


Reply
matthewdancer

Mixing it up is honestly the way to go. I’ve had folks want their whole yard to look like a disco ball for Christmas, but then they get tired of the app juggling. You’re right - wiring’s a pain, but once it’s done, you can just swap bulbs for holidays. Ever tried running conduit in frozen ground? That’s a workout I don’t recommend...


Reply

Honestly, I hear you on the wiring - it’s a hassle up front, but being able to just change bulbs later is a nice payoff. Conduit in frozen ground? Been there, done that, never again... Still, it saves money in the long run, especially if you’re not buying new fixtures every season.


Reply
mleaf76

Conduit in frozen ground? Been there, done that, never again...

Man, that line hit home. I remember one winter trying to run conduit for some path lights - thought I’d outsmart the frost by digging early. Nope. Ended up with a pickaxe and a sore back for a week. In hindsight, I probably should’ve just gone with smart bulbs and called it a day, but I get the appeal of switches too. Swapping bulbs is easy, but when the wiring’s already there, it’s tempting to just upgrade the brains at the switch instead of messing with every fixture. Still not sure which is less hassle long-term...


Reply

Frozen ground and conduit is a combo I wouldn’t wish on anyone. Reminds me of the year I tried to trench for irrigation lines in January - let’s just say the shovel didn’t survive. I’ve leaned toward smart switches lately, mostly because I hate tossing out perfectly good bulbs when tech changes. But honestly, if you’re already rewiring or starting fresh, smart bulbs are so much less hassle for those random spots you can’t easily reach. It’s a toss-up... depends how much you like crawling around in the dirt, I guess.


Reply
ai551

Frozen ground and conduit is a combo I wouldn’t wish on anyone. Reminds me of the year I tried to trench for irrigation lines in January - let’s just say the shovel didn’t survive.

I get where you’re coming from about not wanting to toss good bulbs, but I’ve actually found smart bulbs more flexible in the long run. If a tenant wants a different vibe or color, it’s just a quick swap - no need to mess with wiring or switches. Plus, if you’re dealing with older properties, sometimes the wiring is a bigger headache than just screwing in a new bulb. That said, I do agree that crawling around in frozen dirt is nobody’s idea of fun...


Reply
carolgardener

I hear you on the wiring headaches - older houses can be a real mixed bag. I’ve run into more than a few “creative” electrical solutions from previous owners, and sometimes it’s just not worth the hassle to mess with switches. Smart bulbs are definitely the path of least resistance in those cases.

That said, I’ve had a couple of issues with smart bulbs outside, especially in fixtures that aren’t fully weatherproof. Cold snaps seem to mess with the connectivity, or maybe it’s just my luck. For permanent setups, I still lean toward smart switches - less to worry about if a bulb burns out, and you don’t have to keep track of which ones are “smart” and which aren’t. But for rentals or places where people want to change things up a lot, bulbs make sense.

And yeah, frozen ground is the worst. I tried to dig a post hole in February once and ended up with what looked like a broken garden fork and a bruised ego...


Reply
archer34

Frozen ground is a special kind of misery, isn’t it? I’ve snapped more than one tool trying to trench for low-voltage wire in January - at some point you just have to admit defeat and wait for the thaw. On the smart lighting front, I totally get where you’re coming from with the “creative” wiring. I’ve opened up switch boxes in 1920s bungalows and found everything from cloth-wrapped wires to mystery junctions that go nowhere. Sometimes it’s just not worth the risk or the time to retrofit a smart switch.

I do lean toward switches for long-term setups, though, mostly because tenants will inevitably swap out bulbs and forget which ones are supposed to be “smart.” But for quick upgrades or when the wiring is a total unknown, bulbs are a lifesaver. Outdoor fixtures are tricky - humidity and cold seem to mess with connectivity, and I’ve had Zigbee bulbs drop off the network until spring. It’s always a bit of a gamble, but sometimes you just have to pick your battles and accept that not every solution is perfect.


Reply
running_joshua

That bit about “creative” wiring is way too familiar.

I’ve opened up switch boxes in 1920s bungalows and found everything from cloth-wrapped wires to mystery junctions that go nowhere.
Same here - my place was built in 1915 and every time I open a box, it’s like a weird electrical time capsule. Sometimes I just have to close it back up and pretend I never saw it.

I get the argument for switches, especially with tenants or guests who don’t want to mess with apps or voice controls. But honestly, I’ve had more headaches with smart switches in these old walls than with bulbs. Half the time the neutral wire is missing, or the box is too shallow, or there’s something else funky going on. Ever tried to wedge a modern smart switch into a metal box that’s barely big enough for the old toggle? Not fun.

Outdoor stuff is a toss-up too. My Zigbee bulbs drop off when it’s cold, but the WiFi ones just eat bandwidth and don’t always reconnect. Is there even a reliable option for outdoor setups in old homes, or are we all just making do?


Reply
cyclotourist40

Honestly, I feel this in my soul. My 1928 place is basically a museum of “what not to do” wiring. I’ve had smart switches that just flat-out refused to fit, or needed a neutral that’s apparently lost to history. For outdoors, I’ve had better luck with those outdoor-rated smart plugs - just plug ’em in and let ’em do their thing. Not perfect, but at least I’m not rewiring the whole house just to get the porch light on a schedule. Still waiting for the day someone invents a smart switch that’s actually made for old houses...


Reply
rdiver29

Yeah, the neutral wire thing is such a pain with older homes. I ran into the same issue in my 1940s place - half the boxes are just mystery meat wiring. Here’s what worked for me:

- Outdoor smart plugs: Agreed, these are a lifesaver. No need to mess with ancient wiring or try to cram oversized switches into tiny boxes.
- Bulb-based solutions: I tried smart bulbs for the porch and garage. Not ideal if you want to keep using the wall switch, but at least you don’t have to touch the wiring.
- Switch covers: There are a few battery-powered “switch” covers that stick over your old toggle and control a smart bulb. Not perfect, but it’s an option if you can’t rewire.

Honestly, I wish more manufacturers would think about old houses. The “no neutral required” switches exist but seem finicky or overpriced. For now, outdoor plugs + smart bulbs are my go-to... not elegant, but at least I’m not tearing out plaster walls just to automate a light.


Reply
Scroll to Top