Remodeling discussions and local services.

Digging up the backyard: a suburban adventure gone wild

367 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Digging up the backyard: a suburban adventure gone wild

Totally get where you’re coming from. I used to be all about those crisp edges - spent a small fortune on edging materials, too. But honestly, once the plants filled in, half the borders disappeared under foliage anyway. Now I just let the mulch and groundcovers mingle a bit. It saves money and time, and honestly, it’s less stress when things aren’t “perfect.” Sometimes those blurred lines look way better than the rigid ones, especially if you’re not aiming for that magazine look. Plus, less stuff to maintain means more time to actually enjoy the yard.


Reply
history_matthew

Now I just let the mulch and groundcovers mingle a bit. It saves money and time, and honestly, it’s less stress when things aren’t “perfect.”

That’s actually a relief to hear - I always felt pressured to keep everything tidy, but the cost of all those edging materials adds up fast. I’ve started using leftover bricks and even some old wine bottles as borders, which isn’t exactly “crisp,” but it gets the job done and keeps things from spilling too much. Has anyone tried using natural logs or rocks for edging? Wondering if they hold up over time or just end up looking messy.


Reply
bcarter53

I’ve used logs for edging - grabbed a bunch from a neighbor’s tree that came down. They looked great for the first year, but after two winters, they started to rot and break apart. Rocks have held up way better for me, though they shift around if you don’t set them deep enough. Honestly, nothing’s ever as “maintenance-free” as it sounds, but at least rocks don’t disappear on you after a season or two. The wine bottle idea is pretty creative, by the way... never seen that in my neighborhood.


Reply

Yeah, logs look awesome at first, but they just can’t handle the weather long-term. I tried cedar rounds once, thinking they’d last a bit longer, but even those started to go soft after a couple wet seasons. Rocks are definitely more durable, though like you said, they have a mind of their own if you don’t dig them in deep enough. I’ve had to reset mine every spring - kind of an annual ritual at this point.

The wine bottle edging is wild - I saw it on Pinterest and figured it was all for show, but apparently people actually do it. Not sure how it’d hold up if you get a lot of freeze-thaw cycles, but it’s definitely got style points over the usual options. Maintenance-free is such a myth... everything outside needs babysitting eventually. Still, there’s something satisfying about figuring out what works in your own yard, even if it takes a few tries (and a few failed log borders).


Reply
cycling_jeff

Maintenance-free is such a myth... everything outside needs babysitting eventually.

Couldn’t agree more - “maintenance-free” is just code for “see you next season.” I’ve been through the log border heartbreak too. Tried sealing them, tried elevating them, but moisture always wins in the end. Rocks are stubborn, but at least they don’t rot. The wine bottle thing looks cool, but I’d be nervous about glass chipping with the freeze-thaw swings here. Still, half the fun is experimenting and seeing what survives your backyard’s personality, right?


Reply
emilyarcher

I get where you’re coming from, but I think “maintenance-free” isn’t always a total myth - it’s more about minimizing the hassle. For example:

- Composite edging holds up way better than logs or untreated wood, even with our wild weather swings.
- Gravel borders can look sharp and don’t need much attention, just a little weed patrol now and then.
- As for glass bottles, I’ve seen them last surprisingly well if they’re buried deep enough, but yeah, freeze-thaw is always a wildcard.

It’s not zero effort, but some materials really do cut down on the annual headache. Just depends on how much time you want to spend out there tinkering...


Reply
christopherpainter

Totally agree - nothing’s ever truly “set it and forget it,” but you can get pretty close with the right stuff. Here’s what’s worked for me on a tight budget:

- Mulch borders: Cheap, easy to refresh, and keeps weeds down for a good while.
- Recycled bricks: Scored some from a neighbor, and they’ve held up way better than I expected, even through winter.
- For edging, I tried those plastic rolls once... never again. They warped after one summer.

It’s all about finding that sweet spot between cost, looks, and how much you want to mess with it later.


Reply
dcloud55

Yeah, those plastic rolls are a pain - mine buckled and popped out after the first freeze. I’ve had better luck with old concrete pavers, honestly. Not the prettiest, but they’re solid and you can usually find them cheap or free if you keep an eye on local listings. Mulch is a lifesaver for weeds, but I always end up topping it off every spring... guess that’s just part of the deal.

Curious if anyone’s tried using metal edging? I’ve seen it in a few yards around here and it looks sharp, but I wonder if it’s worth the extra cost or if it just ends up rusting out after a couple seasons.


Reply

- Plastic edging: lasted about as long as my New Year’s resolutions.
- Concrete pavers: heavy, but at least they don’t run away when it rains.
- Mulch: yeah, it’s like a subscription service for your yard - renew every spring or the weeds take over.

Metal edging looks cool, but I’m worried about mowing too close and dinging it up. Anyone ever tried those recycled rubber borders? Wondering if they’re just as much of a hassle or actually worth the hype...


Reply
sports200

- Tried the recycled rubber edging last year - honestly, it’s holding up better than I expected.
- Super easy to install (I did it solo, and my back only mildly hated me after).
- Doesn’t shift around like the plastic stuff, and it’s flexible enough to handle weird curves.
- Only thing: if you’re a neat freak, it can look a bit “bouncy” in spots over time. Not as crisp as metal or brick.
- Mower blades haven’t had any issues so far - rubber just kind of shrugs it off.
- Bonus: doesn’t rust, and the squirrels seem totally uninterested.

If you’ve got an older house like mine with uneven ground and roots everywhere, the rubber’s pretty forgiving. Not perfect, but less drama than concrete pavers or re-mulching every few months... My two cents!


Reply
dwhite26

Rubber edging’s definitely a practical choice, especially if you’re dealing with roots and uneven ground. I’ll admit, the “bouncy” look bugs me a little - guess I’m one of those neat freaks you mentioned. But honestly, not having to worry about rust or mower damage is a huge plus. Have you noticed any fading or color changes over time? That’s my one hesitation with some of the recycled stuff. I’ve seen a few yards where it goes kind of grayish after a couple summers, but maybe that’s just the cheaper brands...


Reply
ldust69

Funny you mention the color shift - my neighbor’s edging started out a nice deep brown and after a couple summers, it was more like “mystery taupe.” I think some brands are just better at holding their color. If you’re picky, I’d grab a sample and leave it in the sun for a bit before committing. That bouncy look does take getting used to, but I’ll trade it for not having to untangle my mower every other week...


Reply

If you’re picky, I’d grab a sample and leave it in the sun for a bit before committing.

That’s actually a solid move. I learned the hard way with some “UV-resistant” composite edging that faded to a weird gray-green after just one season. The manufacturer swore it wouldn’t, but… nature had other plans. If you want to get really technical, check if the product lists any ASTM colorfastness ratings - some of the higher-end brands will.

About the bouncy look: I get what you mean. It’s not exactly “classic English garden,” but honestly, after wrestling with metal edging that warped every winter, I’ll take a little flex over fighting with bent stakes and mower jams. One trick I found is to anchor the flexible stuff with extra stakes at the curves - keeps it from wandering when the ground shifts.

Funny how much time we spend thinking about something most people never even notice unless it’s gone wrong...


Reply
philosophy228

I get the frustration with metal edging, but I’m actually leaning toward it for my own project - mainly because I’m worried about the flexible stuff shifting over time. Is it really that much of a pain to deal with in winter? I’ve seen some people use thicker gauge steel or even corten, and they claim it holds up better. Maybe it’s just the cheaper stuff that warps?

Also, about color fading - does anyone know if stone edging has the same issues? I like the look, but I’m not sure if it’ll end up looking dingy after a couple years. The “UV-resistant” label seems kind of meaningless after reading your experience… makes me wonder how much of this is just marketing.

It’s wild how these tiny details end up taking over your brain once you start a project. I used to think edging was just, like, a strip in the ground. Now I’m over here debating ASTM ratings and stake placement.


Reply
davidwood32

Digging up the backyard: a suburban adventure gone wild

Yeah, it’s wild how deep down the rabbit hole you can go with this stuff. I’ve used both metal and stone edging, and honestly, the thicker steel (like 1/8" corten) is way sturdier than the cheap rolled stuff. Winter’s not too bad if you get it in deep enough - just watch for frost heave if your soil’s clay-heavy. Stone does fade a bit, but it’s more like it gets a patina than actually looking bad. The UV-resistant thing is mostly marketing fluff in my experience... everything fades eventually, just depends how much you care.


Reply

I’m right in the middle of figuring out edging for my own backyard redo, and I keep second-guessing the materials. The steel stuff looks solid, but I’m worried about rust stains - does corten actually avoid that, or is it just less noticeable? My soil’s a weird mix, not pure clay but definitely holds water, so frost heave is a concern. I’ve seen some people use composite edging, but it feels flimsy to me. Is the extra cost of stone really worth it for durability, or does it just come down to looks?


Reply

I’ve gone down this exact rabbit hole in my own yard. Corten steel does develop a rust patina, but it’s designed to be stable - meaning, it shouldn’t keep rusting through or flaking off, but you can still get some staining where water runs off. I’ve had a few clients who were fine with that “weathered” look, but if you’re worried about stains on concrete or lighter stone, it’s something to watch for. Composite edging is hit-or-miss - some brands are sturdier than others, but yeah, in wetter soils it can flex or pop up with frost. Stone’s pricey up front, but I’ve yet to see properly installed stone edging fail before the rest of the landscaping needs a refresh. If budget allows and you want low maintenance, I'd lean stone... but it does come down to how much you care about aesthetics vs. function.


Reply
jerryc42

Stone edging really does seem to be the “set it and forget it” option, but man, that upfront cost can sting. I went with composite last year thinking it’d be easier, but

“in wetter soils it can flex or pop up with frost”
- yep, learned that the hard way. Honestly, whatever you pick, just getting out there and making a decision is half the battle. You’re doing great.


Reply

- I get the appeal of stone, but I’ve actually had good luck with brick pavers as edging.
- They’re a bit cheaper upfront, and you can usually find them on sale or even secondhand.
- Yeah, they can shift a little over time, but it’s not too hard to reset a few here and there.
- Plus, if you change your mind down the road, it’s way easier to move than stone or composite.
- Just my two cents - sometimes “good enough” is better than “forever” when you’re figuring things out.


Reply
mthinker94

I hear you on the brick pavers - definitely easier to swap out if you get bored or, in my case, accidentally run over one with the mower (don’t ask). But I gotta say, I tried the “good enough” route and ended up chasing those bricks around every spring after the frost heave party. Stone’s a pain to move, sure, but once it’s in, it doesn’t wander off on its own. Guess it depends how much you like rearranging your yard every year...


Reply
Scroll to Top