Remodeling discussions and local services.

 
karenskier7091
Discussion options
Discussion options
[#733]

Dealing with old pipes during a bathroom overhaul - worth replacing or just patching up?

Tearing into my 1970s bathroom and, honestly, I’m kinda stuck on the whole plumbing situation. The pipes are that old copper (maybe some galvanized in there too), and they look… well, let’s say “vintage.” I’ve read a bunch about full repipes vs just fixing what’s leaking, but it seems like everyone has a different take. Some folks say “replace it all while the walls are open,” others are like “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”

Thing is, my budget isn’t endless and I really don’t want to get in over my head if I don’t have to. I’m handy-ish (can sweat a joint, but not a pro), but the thought of redoing every line is a little intimidating. Also, PEX vs copper - still can’t decide. PEX seems easier but I’ve heard mixed things about long-term reliability.

Anyone been through this and regretted not going all in? Or maybe went all out and thought it was overkill? Curious if there’s a middle ground here - like, just swap out the worst runs or focus on certain spots? Would love to hear what actually worked for real people, especially if you’ve got any “wish I’d known” stories.


Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

33 replies

Been there with my 1920s place - those pipes were practically antiques. I ended up doing a “greatest hits” approach: replaced the worst sections (the ones that looked like they’d spring a leak if you stared too hard), left the rest for another day. Honestly, I wish I’d swapped out a bit more while the walls were open, but budget’s budget. PEX was way easier for me, and so far, no regrets. If you’re handy-ish, it’s not too bad, just take your time and double-check those connections.


Reply
melissatail10

Honestly, I wish I’d swapped out a bit more while the walls were open, but budget’s budget.

Totally get that feeling. Once those walls are closed up, you start second-guessing every old pipe you left behind. I’ve done the “just the worst bits” routine too, and yeah, it’s a gamble sometimes. But honestly, if PEX is working for you and you haven’t had issues, that’s a win. No shame in pacing it out - sometimes you just gotta work with what you’ve got.


Reply

Once those walls are closed up, you start second-guessing every old pipe you left behind.

I get that, but sometimes I wonder if we overthink it. I left some original copper in my last reno and it’s still fine years later. Is it always worth ripping everything out if there’s no sign of leaks or corrosion? Sometimes “if it ain’t broke...” really does apply.


Reply
jonrain444

I get where you’re coming from - sometimes it feels like we’re just making more work for ourselves, tearing out perfectly good copper. But here’s how I usually break it down when I’m flipping a place or doing a gut job:

1. Age of the pipe. If it’s original and you’re talking 40+ years, even if it looks good now, you’re rolling the dice. Copper can last a long time, but pinhole leaks can show up quick, and they’re a nightmare behind new tile.

2. Water quality. Some areas have water that eats through copper faster (high acidity, minerals, etc). If you’ve had green stains or blueish water at any point, that’s a red flag.

3. Accessibility. If you’ve got the walls open and access is easy, I lean toward replacing anything questionable. Once those walls are closed, repairs get expensive fast.

4. Budget and timeline. Sometimes it just doesn’t make sense to rip everything out if you’re on a tight budget or schedule. In those cases, at least swap out any obvious trouble spots - like joints or sections with visible corrosion.

5. Resale value/peace of mind. If you’re planning to sell soon or just don’t want callbacks from buyers down the line, new plumbing is a good selling point.

I’ve left old copper in place before too - especially if it looked solid and there were no signs of trouble after pressure testing. But I’ve also had to go back and fix leaks in spots I thought were fine... Murphy’s Law seems to love old pipes.

Bottom line: If it’s easy and affordable while the walls are open, do it now. If not, at least inspect every inch and replace anything even slightly sketchy. “If it ain’t broke” works - until it is, and then it’s a headache.

Just my two cents from too many late-night leak chases...


Reply
karenskier7091
karenskier7091 Topic starter

Title: Dealing With Old Pipes During A Bathroom Overhaul - Worth Replacing Or Just Patching Up?

I’ve run into this dilemma on a few projects, and it always feels like a balancing act. When I’m planning a bathroom refresh, I tend to think about the “hidden” details as much as the finishes - because nothing ruins a gorgeous tile job faster than a leak behind the wall. If you’re already opening things up, it’s an opportunity to future-proof, but I get that not everyone has the budget for a full overhaul.

One thing I’ve noticed: even if pipes look decent, sometimes there’s unseen buildup or corrosion that doesn’t show until it’s too late. I’d focus on replacing anything that looks even remotely questionable, especially around fixtures you’re updating. As for PEX vs copper, PEX is definitely easier to work with and less disruptive to install, especially in tight spaces. I’ve specified it for several remodels and haven’t had any complaints yet, but I do make sure it’s high quality and properly supported.

If you’re keeping some old lines, maybe document exactly where they run before closing up - just in case. It’s not glamorous, but it can save headaches down the line.


Reply
literature_steven

“nothing ruins a gorgeous tile job faster than a leak behind the wall.”

That hits home. I once spent weeks on a mosaic shower wall, only to have a pinhole leak in an old copper line show up a year later - total heartbreak. Ever since, if I’ve got the walls open and the pipes are even a little sketchy, I just bite the bullet and swap them out. It’s not the fun part, but it’s way better than tearing out your hard work down the road. PEX has been a lifesaver for me in tight spots, too.


Reply

“if I’ve got the walls open and the pipes are even a little sketchy, I just bite the bullet and swap them out.”

I hear you, but sometimes I wonder if we’re being too quick to replace. Ever pressure test old copper before deciding? I’ve seen 60-year-old lines hold up fine, but then again, one hidden pinhole and it’s game over. How do you decide when it’s worth the risk?


Reply
athlete614023

Ever pressure test old copper before deciding?

Yeah, I’ve pressure tested plenty, but honestly, if the pipes look rough or have green spots, I just swap them. You’re already in there - no sense risking a leak behind new tile. Seen too many callbacks from “good enough” lines.


Reply
jenniferpainter

Couldn’t agree more about not trusting “good enough” when you’re already tearing things up. I’ve seen folks try to save a few bucks by leaving sketchy copper in place, only to end up ripping out fresh tile six months later. If it looks suspect - especially with those green crusty spots - it’s just not worth the gamble. You’ll sleep better knowing it’s all new behind the walls.


Reply
running855

I get where you’re coming from, but sometimes I wonder if we’re a bit too quick to rip everything out. I mean, if the copper’s solid and there’s no corrosion or weird smells, is it always necessary? I replaced mine because of pinhole leaks, but my neighbor’s pipes are 40 years old and still kicking. Maybe it depends on what you find once the walls are open?


Reply

I hear you - my dad’s house still has the original copper from the ‘70s, and it’s never given him grief. Meanwhile, my place sprung a leak after just 20 years. Sometimes I think it’s a bit of a gamble... depends on your luck and what you find behind those walls.


Reply
psychology_joshua

That’s the thing - sometimes those old copper lines are like tanks, and other times you get a lemon. I’ve opened up walls in houses from the ‘60s where the copper looked brand new, barely any corrosion. Then you get newer stuff with pinhole leaks or weird green buildup. I guess it depends on water chemistry, how well things were grounded, maybe even the quality of copper back then versus now.

When I redid my bathroom, I figured since everything was open anyway, I’d just swap out the old pipes for PEX. It wasn’t leaking yet, but honestly, I didn’t want to gamble and have to rip out fresh tile down the road. It’s not always necessary if your pipes look solid, but if you’re already gutting things... sometimes it’s worth the peace of mind. That said, I know folks who patch and keep rolling for decades without issues. Just comes down to how much risk you’re willing to live with - and maybe a little bit of luck too.


Reply

- If you’ve already got the walls open, I’d just swap out the old pipes. Like you said, it’s not always “necessary,” but ripping up new tile later sounds like a nightmare.
-

“sometimes those old copper lines are like tanks, and other times you get a lemon.”
100% - my neighbor’s place had copper from the ‘70s that looked fine, but mine had green gunk and pinholes everywhere.
- PEX is way easier to work with if you’re new to this stuff. Less joints to mess up, too.
- If budget’s tight and the copper looks solid, maybe patch. But if you’re already spending on a reno, why risk it?


Reply
ewriter73

Dealing With Old Pipes During A Bathroom Overhaul - Worth Replacing Or Just Patching Up?

“if you’re already spending on a reno, why risk it?”

I get where you’re coming from, but I’d actually push back a little on the “just replace everything” approach. If your copper’s in good shape - no green corrosion, no weird smells or leaks, and solid joints - it can last decades more. I’ve seen houses from the ‘60s where the copper is basically pristine. Sometimes patching makes sense, especially if you’re not touching every wall.

- Opening up every wall just to chase pipes can make a small job way bigger (and pricier).
- If you’re careful with your inspection (like really look for pinholes or pitting), you might be fine with just replacing sections that look sketchy.
- PEX is great, but if your water’s hard or you’ve got tight bends, sometimes copper still wins out.

I guess it comes down to how much risk you’re willing to take. For me, I’d rather save my budget for stuff I actually see - like tile or fixtures - unless the pipes are obviously toast. Different strokes...


Reply
toby_explorer

Honestly, I get wanting to save money for the visible stuff, but if you’re already tearing into walls, it feels like a missed opportunity not to swap out old pipes. I’ve had a “looks fine” copper line spring a leak a year after a reno - total headache. Sometimes peace of mind is worth the extra cost, especially if you don’t want to rip things up again down the road.


Reply
kimpaws655

I totally get the peace of mind angle, but sometimes the budget just doesn’t stretch that far, especially with all the other reno costs piling up. When we did our bathroom, I was worried about the pipes too, but here’s what worked for us:

1. Check the age and type of your pipes. If they’re not super old or showing signs of corrosion, you might be okay leaving them for now.
2. Have a plumber do a pressure test or inspection while the walls are open. Sometimes they can spot weak spots or issues you’d never notice otherwise.
3. Replace only the sections that look sketchy or are most likely to fail (like joints or areas with visible wear). It’s way cheaper than a full swap.
4. Take lots of photos and notes about what’s behind the walls for future reference.

It’s not a perfect solution, but it let us put more money into the stuff we actually see every day. Knock on wood, no leaks yet... but I guess there’s always a bit of risk either way.


Reply
psychology384

Honestly, I’m with you on the “patch what you can see” approach.

“Replace only the sections that look sketchy or are most likely to fail (like joints or areas with visible wear). It’s way cheaper than a full swap.”
That’s exactly what we did in our last place - just tackled the worst bits and hoped for the best. I will say, labeling photos of what’s behind the walls saved my butt when we had to fix a leaky valve later. Not perfect, but sometimes you gotta pick your battles (and your budget).


Reply

That’s a smart move with the labeled photos - wish I’d thought of that the first time I had to hunt for a shutoff valve behind drywall. I’ve always leaned toward full replacement when budget allows, just because hidden leaks can lead to bigger headaches down the line (especially if you’re thinking resale value). Curious - have you found buyers care about whether pipes are original or not? Or is it more of a “don’t ask, don’t tell” situation in your experience?


Reply

I’ve actually had buyers ask about plumbing during open houses, especially if the place is older. One couple even brought a flashlight and checked under the sinks - caught me off guard. I think it depends on the buyer, but in my experience, folks who are eco-conscious or planning to stay long-term care a lot about what’s behind the walls. That said, I’ve also seen plenty of people shrug it off if everything looks tidy and works. Funny how much peace of mind a new shutoff valve can bring, though...


Reply
Scroll to Top