Remodeling discussions and local services.

Finally found a quiet garage opener that won't wake the neighbors

340 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

gardener872840

I've been debating this myself lately, because our garage opener sounds like a freight train rolling through at 6am... neighbors probably think we're running a secret mechanic shop in there, lol. Anyway, about the quieter models - my brother-in-law installed one last summer and swears by it. But funny enough, he's had a couple of minor hiccups with sensors and alignment issues. Nothing major, but enough to make me wonder if quieter sometimes means more sensitive or delicate?

I'm all for fewer noise complaints (and less side-eye from next door), but I'm also not looking to add another thing to my 'finicky home appliance' list. Did you notice if yours needed more fine-tuning or adjustments after installation? Or maybe it was just his luck...


Reply

Been wondering the exact same thing lately since we're about to replace ours - it's currently doing a solid impression of a jet engine every morning. 😂 Interesting about the sensor issues though... makes me think quieter models might be a bit more finicky. Did your brother-in-law mention if it was tricky to install himself, or was it more of a random thing that popped up later? I'm all for quiet, but I don't wanna spend my weekends babysitting garage door sensors...


Reply

"Did your brother-in-law mention if it was tricky to install himself, or was it more of a random thing that popped up later?"

Funny you mention sensor issues - I ran into something similar last month. Installed one of those whisper-quiet belt-driven openers for a client, and the installation itself was straightforward enough (just follow the manual step-by-step, nothing too crazy). But about two weeks later, the sensors started acting up randomly. Turned out it was just alignment sensitivity - took maybe 10 minutes to tweak and hasn't been an issue since. Quiet's great, but yeah... sensors can be picky little things.


Reply

Had a similar thing happen when we upgraded ours last year. Installation was pretty smooth, but about a week later the sensors randomly decided they didn't like each other anymore. One minute fine, next minute refusing to close the door without a dramatic blinking tantrum. Turned out a spider had built a tiny web right in front of one sensor... took longer to find a broom than to fix the issue. Sensors definitely have a mind of their own sometimes.


Reply

Had something similar happen, except mine wasn't spiders - it was leaves blowing around. Every windy day, the sensors would randomly freak out and refuse to close. Took me forever to figure out what was going on. Ended up rigging a little shield out of scrap wood to block the wind and debris. Worked like a charm since then. Ever had issues with weather messing up your sensors, or is it just my luck?


Reply

I've had weather issues mess with sensors too, so you're definitely not alone. Mine was actually sunlight - believe it or not. Late afternoon sun would hit the sensor at just the right angle, and the door would refuse to close. Took me ages to pinpoint the issue because it always happened at random times. Ended up sticking a small cardboard flap above the sensor to shade it slightly... problem solved. Sometimes it's just these quirky little fixes that do the trick, huh? Glad your scrap wood shield worked out!


Reply
mythology_tigger

"Ended up sticking a small cardboard flap above the sensor to shade it slightly... problem solved."

Cardboard might work temporarily, but honestly, I'd be cautious about relying on it long-term. Moisture, dust, or even insects can degrade cardboard pretty quickly - especially in a garage environment. A simple metal or plastic bracket would probably hold up better and look cleaner. I get the appeal of quick fixes, but sometimes spending an extra 10 minutes on something sturdier saves headaches down the road.


Reply

Cardboard's definitely a quick fix, but I've seen it turn into a soggy mess after a few months - especially if your garage gets humid or damp. Had a client once who did something similar, and it ended up attracting spiders (they love cardboard for some reason...). Swapping it out for a small plastic shield or even bending a scrap piece of aluminum flashing would probably hold up better. Did you notice any difference in sensor sensitivity after shading it?


Reply

Cardboard's handy in a pinch, but yeah, dampness can turn it nasty quick. Good call on the aluminum flashing - it's cheap and holds up way better. I've used plastic covers myself, no issues yet. About the sensor sensitivity, shading mine actually seemed to help a bit with false triggers from sunlight reflections. Curious if anyone else noticed that too...


Reply
swimmer999989

I've noticed shading helps too, especially if your garage faces south or west. Mine used to trigger randomly late afternoons - drove me nuts until I figured out it was sunlight bouncing off my neighbor's windows. Aluminum flashing is solid advice; I tried plastic covers once, but squirrels chewed right through them (little monsters...). Metal's definitely the way to go if wildlife's an issue in your area.


Reply

"Mine used to trigger randomly late afternoons - drove me nuts until I figured out it was sunlight bouncing off my neighbor's windows."

Had the exact same issue a couple years back. Thought my opener was possessed or something, until I realized the sensor was catching reflections from passing cars. Aluminum flashing definitely sorted it out for me too - easy to install and zero issues since.

About those plastic covers... yeah, learned that lesson the hard way myself. I tried some cheap plastic shields thinking they'd do the trick, but the local raccoons treated them like chew toys. Switched to metal mesh guards and haven't had a problem since. If critters are persistent in your area, metal's pretty much your only reliable option. Also, if you're into DIY, a quick coat of matte black spray paint on the flashing can help reduce glare even more.

Glad you got it sorted - nothing worse than a garage door randomly opening when you're not home.


Reply
baking_karen

About those plastic covers...

Interesting you mention the metal mesh guards - I went the opposite route and stuck with plastic covers, and surprisingly they've held up fine. Maybe our raccoons are just lazier around here? Also, about the matte black spray paint... I tried that once, but it seemed to absorb heat and warp slightly after a hot summer. Did you notice anything similar, or did I just pick the wrong paint?


Reply
pdavis14

I've had pretty good luck with matte black spray paint myself, but I think it really depends on the brand and type you pick. Some paints are definitely more heat-resistant than others. I used a high-temp automotive matte black (the kind you'd use on grills or engine parts), and it's held up great even through some brutal summers. Regular spray paint, though... yeah, I've seen it warp or bubble up a bit when things get hot.

As for the plastic covers, glad they're working out for you! Honestly, I think raccoons just have their own personalities - some neighborhoods seem to have ninja-level raccoons that can break into anything, while others are just chill and lazy. Mine are somewhere in between; they test things occasionally but usually give up pretty quick if there's no easy snack involved.

If you ever decide to retry the paint route, maybe look into something specifically labeled as heat-resistant or automotive-grade. Might cost a couple bucks more, but it's worth it to avoid repainting every summer...


Reply
mythology_james

"Honestly, I think raccoons just have their own personalities - some neighborhoods seem to have ninja-level raccoons that can break into anything..."

Haha, this is so true. Our neighborhood raccoons are definitely the ninja type - I've had to upgrade my trash bins twice already. Good call on the automotive-grade paint, by the way. I've used it on outdoor metal furniture, and it's been rock-solid through heatwaves and storms. Definitely worth the extra few bucks to avoid repainting every year or two...


Reply

Haha, ninja raccoons are no joke. Had one pry open a supposedly "raccoon-proof" bin last summer - still not sure how he managed it. Speaking of quiet garage openers, did you notice any difference in wildlife activity after installing yours? I've heard quieter openers might attract fewer curious critters...but maybe that's just wishful thinking on my part. Might have to test this theory myself soon.


Reply

• Ninja raccoons are definitely a thing - had one scale my porch railing like it was nothing. Still baffled.
• Installed a quieter opener last fall, and honestly, wildlife-wise, not much changed. Squirrels still think my garage is their Airbnb.
• But hey, maybe your raccoons have higher standards than mine...worth a shot at least.
• Good luck with the experiment - let us know if you crack the code on raccoon deterrence.


Reply

• Ninja raccoons? Try ninja possums...had one casually strolling along the garage door tracks while I was testing the new opener. Didn't flinch, didn't care. Guess quiet openers just mean stealthier wildlife visits.


Reply

"Guess quiet openers just mean stealthier wildlife visits."

Ha, been there. Quiet openers are great, but they do seem to invite curious critters in for a closer look. Had a similar issue with squirrels deciding the garage rafters were prime real estate after I installed mine. Quick heads-up: double-check your weather stripping and seals around the door edges. A quieter opener means less vibration, so animals might get bolder about squeezing through tiny gaps they used to avoid. Also, a motion-activated LED near the tracks can help discourage nighttime visitors - worked wonders for me after my squirrel invasion...


Reply
collector85

Hadn't thought about the vibration angle, interesting point. I installed a quieter opener last summer and ended up with birds nesting right above the door tracks. Wonder if ultrasonic repellents actually work or if they're just gimmicks...


Reply
jameshall385

I had a similar issue last year when I upgraded my garage door opener to one of those belt-driven quiet models. Thought I was solving one problem, but ended up creating another - birds decided the quietness meant it was a perfect place to nest. Had to clear out nests twice before finally figuring out something that worked.

About those ultrasonic repellents...I tried one briefly in my garden area to keep squirrels away from my plants. Honestly, didn't notice much difference. Maybe it depends on the brand or the animal you're targeting? I've heard mixed reviews from others too. Might be worth giving it a shot since they're not terribly expensive, but I wouldn't rely solely on them. For the birds in my garage, I ended up installing some discreet bird spikes along the track ledge - doesn't look too bad and solved the issue completely. Have you thought about trying something physical like that instead?


Reply
Scroll to Top