Remodeling discussions and local services.

locked out drama - what would you do?

1,314 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

marley_thomas

If the frame’s flimsy, it doesn’t matter how fancy the lock is.

That’s so true - my last apartment had a “security” lock on a hollow-core door. Pretty sure a determined squirrel could’ve busted through. About smart locks: I installed one for my parents. It’s cool to unlock with your phone, but if the WiFi goes down, you’re back to using the key anyway. Also, battery died once and we had to climb in through a window... so, not exactly foolproof.


Reply

Locked Out? Been There...

- Had a tenant once who swore by his “unpickable” lock, but the door frame was so weak you could’ve kicked it in with slippers. Security’s only as strong as the weakest link, right?
- Smart locks are cool until you’re standing outside with dead batteries and a pizza getting cold. Been there, done that... not fun.
- Honestly, I keep a spare key with a neighbor now. Tech is great, but sometimes old-school wins.


Reply
literature488

- Totally agree about the weakest link - no point in a fancy lock if the frame is flimsy.
- I’ve seen people mount high-end smart locks on hollow core doors... not ideal.
- Battery backups for smart locks help, but honestly, a well-hidden mechanical key safe is my go-to.
- Neighbor with a spare is good, but I’ve had one move unexpectedly - left me scrambling.
- Sometimes, just upgrading the door and strike plate does more for security than any tech gadget.


Reply
painter41

Locked Out Drama - What Would You Do?

Funny how often people focus on the lock itself and forget about the door and frame... I’ve actually recommended clients invest in a solid wood or metal door before even thinking about smart locks. Hollow core doors just aren’t made for security. Has anyone tried those reinforced strike plates? They’re not the prettiest, but I swear, they make a difference.

Also, I’m all for a key safe, but I worry about hiding spots - do you go for obvious or super sneaky? I always wonder if hiding it too well means I’ll forget where I put it...


Reply

I always wonder if hiding it too well means I’ll forget where I put it...

That’s happened to me - spent half an hour searching for a “genius” hiding spot I’d picked for a spare key. Ended up late for a showing. Anyone ever tried those fake sprinkler head safes? They look goofy but maybe that’s the point. Curious if folks think it’s better to risk a more obvious spot or just trust your memory.


Reply
joshua_dust

I’ve actually tried one of those fake sprinkler heads - picked it up for like $8 on Amazon. It’s not the most convincing thing up close, but honestly, nobody’s crawling around my front yard looking for hidden keys. Here’s what I’ve learned:

- Obvious spots (under the mat, in a flowerpot) are just too risky. First place anyone would check.
- The fake sprinkler worked fine until I forgot which bush I’d put it under... ended up soaked and annoyed after a rainstorm.
- Now I just leave a spare with a neighbor I trust. Not as “spy movie,” but way less stressful.

If you’re set on hiding it outside, maybe snap a photo of the spot and save it somewhere only you can access? Just don’t overthink it - sometimes simple is better than “genius.”


Reply

I get the appeal of leaving a spare with a neighbor, but honestly, that’s not always practical. What if they're out of town or just not home when you need them? I’ve actually had that exact thing happen and ended up paying a locksmith anyway. For me, a combo lockbox (the kind realtors use) is the best bang for your buck. They’re not too pricey, way more secure than fake rocks or sprinklers, and you can change the code whenever. Just mount it somewhere that isn’t screamingly obvious. It’s not glamorous, but it’s reliable - sometimes “simple” just means “not quite secure enough.”


Reply
news805

For me, a combo lockbox (the kind realtors use) is the best bang for your buck. They’re not too pricey, way more secure than fake rocks or sprinklers, and you can change the code whenever.

Totally agree - lockboxes are underrated. I’ve installed a bunch during flips and they’re way more reliable than hoping a neighbor’s around. Just gotta be smart about placement, like you said. I’ve seen people stick them right by the front door, which kinda defeats the purpose. Not perfect, but definitely beats paying a locksmith every time.


Reply
andrewshadow350

I get the appeal of lockboxes, but I’ve actually had one jam up on me in the dead of winter. Ended up just as stuck as if I’d hidden the key under a mat. Not saying they’re bad - just maybe not foolproof. Honestly, I started keeping a spare with a trusted neighbor after that. Might not work for everyone, but it’s saved me more than once. Sometimes old-school backup plans still have their place.


Reply

I’ve run into the same issue with lockboxes - one winter, the mechanism just froze solid and I was left standing outside with groceries and no way in. Not my finest hour. I do like the idea of a backup plan, though. Personally, I’ve started recommending decorative key cabinets inside mudrooms for clients who tend to misplace things. It’s not a solution for being locked out, but it does help keep keys organized and less likely to wander off. Still, nothing beats having a neighbor you trust... sometimes the simplest solutions really are the best.


Reply

Still, nothing beats having a neighbor you trust... sometimes the simplest solutions really are the best.

That’s honestly been my go-to as well. I’ve had clients invest in all sorts of high-tech lock systems, but when it comes down to it, a spare key with a neighbor has saved more headaches than any gadget. I do like your idea about decorative key cabinets - there’s something satisfying about having a dedicated spot for keys, especially if you’re prone to tossing them on whatever surface is closest.

One thing I’ve seen work (especially in colder climates where lockboxes freeze) is installing a small, weatherproof key safe in an inconspicuous spot - like behind a planter or tucked under a deck rail. Not foolproof, but better than standing outside with melting ice cream and no way in. That said, I’ve also had clients who swear by those keypad deadbolts. No keys to lose, just remember the code... though I guess that opens up a whole new can of worms if you forget numbers instead of keys.

Funny how much drama a little piece of metal can cause.


Reply

You nailed it - sometimes the old-school methods just work better. I’ve seen folks spend a fortune on smart locks, only to get locked out when the batteries die or the app glitches. A neighbor with a spare key has saved my bacon more than once. And yeah, those keypad deadbolts are great until you’re standing there blanking on your own code... been there, done that. At the end of the day, whatever keeps you from breaking a window is a win in my book.


Reply
donnaarcher

- Had a house once with a fancy WiFi lock - thing glitched during a storm and I was stuck outside in the rain, phone dead, no backup key.
- Now I just hide an old-school spare in a combo lockbox. Not high-tech, but it’s never let me down.
- Honestly, sometimes simple is just less headache.


Reply

I hear you - technology’s great until it isn’t. I’ve always wondered about those WiFi locks, especially with old houses like mine where the doors sometimes swell or stick after a rain. Wouldn’t trust a fancy lock to handle that gracefully. I keep a spare key in the shed, tucked behind some old garden tools... not exactly high security, but at least I know it’ll work if I’m ever caught out. Ever worry about someone finding your combo lockbox? Or is that just me being overly cautious?


Reply
jgreen67

I once hid a spare key under a fake rock - looked so fake, even I couldn’t find it when I needed it. Ended up climbing through a window in front of my neighbor. Honestly, I trust old-school keys more than any WiFi gadget.


Reply
thomasmusician

Locked Out Drama - What Would You Do?

That fake rock trick is classic, but honestly, those things always look like props from a low-budget movie. I tried the same once, except mine was one of those hollowed-out garden gnomes. Thought I was clever until my dog decided it was his new chew toy. Long story short, the key ended up somewhere in the backyard, and I spent an hour with a metal detector looking like a wannabe pirate.

I get the hesitation with WiFi gadgets - tech can be glitchy, and nothing kills your confidence like an app that decides to update right when you’re standing in the rain. But I’ve actually switched over to a keypad deadbolt for my place, and it’s been a game changer. No more hiding keys, no more climbing through windows (which, let’s be real, is just asking for a pulled hamstring at my age). Plus, I can give temporary codes to friends or contractors and change them whenever I want. If the batteries die, there’s still a backup keyhole.

Old-school keys have their charm, but they’re not exactly foolproof either. I’ve had locks freeze up in winter, keys snap off in the cylinder, you name it. At least with the keypad, worst case, I’m swapping out a couple of AA batteries instead of calling a locksmith at midnight.

Not saying tech is perfect - nothing is - but sometimes it’s less about trusting gadgets and more about picking your battles. For me, not having to crawl through shrubbery or explain to the neighbors why I’m breaking into my own house is worth the occasional software quirk.


Reply
scotts79

No more hiding keys, no more climbing through windows (which, let’s be real, is just asking for a pulled hamstring at my age).

That’s a good point about the physical risks - seen plenty of folks try to “break in” to their own homes and end up with a sprained wrist or worse. I’ve installed a bunch of those keypad deadbolts for clients, and most seem happy, but I do get questions about durability. Have you noticed any wear and tear on the buttons or weather issues? Sometimes the cheaper models get sticky after a couple winters.

Also, curious if you went for a model with WiFi or just the basic keypad? Some people like the remote access, but I’ve had clients who got locked out when the app glitched or their phone died. Just wondering if you’ve run into any of that, or if the backup keyhole has saved you yet.

Anyone else tried those fingerprint locks? I’ve only put in a couple, but always wondered if they’re actually reliable, especially with dirty hands or in cold weather.


Reply

Keypad deadbolts really do take a lot of the drama out of getting locked out, but yeah, durability can be hit or miss. I’ve noticed the cheaper ones get that “sticky button” thing after a couple years, especially if they’re in direct sun or get hit with a lot of rain. The higher-end models seem to hold up better, but nothing’s perfect. I usually recommend sticking with a backup keyhole just in case - tech is great until it isn’t. Haven’t had much luck with fingerprint locks myself; cold weather and dirty hands seem to mess with them more than I’d like.


Reply
climbing444

Title: Locked Out Drama - What Would You Do?

I get the concern about keypad durability, but honestly, I’ve had better luck with them than with traditional locks in my old house. The keyholes always seemed to freeze up or get jammed with dust. I do agree about the backup key though - tech can be finicky, but so can old-school locks. Sometimes it’s just picking your poison.


Reply

I’ve had similar issues with traditional locks - especially in winter, when the keyhole would freeze and I’d be out there with a lighter trying to thaw it. Keypads seem more reliable, but I do wonder about battery life and what happens if you forget to change them. Has anyone factored in the long-term costs of replacing batteries or repairing keypads compared to just maintaining a regular lock? It feels like both options have their hidden expenses.


Reply
Scroll to Top