Lime and clay paints really do have a vibe you can’t get with anything else. I’m just starting out with this stuff, and yeah, it’s a bit more work, but honestly feels worth it. The air in the room just seems fresher somehow. I tried one of those “eco” acrylics once—looked okay but felt weirdly shiny. Glad to hear others are sticking with the old-school options too.
I’ve noticed the same thing with lime and clay paints—there’s just something about the way they interact with light and air. I started using them in a couple of my rental properties, mostly older homes where the walls need to breathe. The difference is subtle but real. Tenants have actually commented on how the rooms “feel” better, which surprised me since most folks don’t notice that kind of thing.
I get what you mean about the “eco” acrylics. Tried those too, thinking they’d be a good compromise, but they always end up looking a bit too perfect? Like, almost plastic-y. Plus, I’ve had issues with touch-ups not blending well over time.
One thing I will say—lime paint can be a pain if you’re not careful with prep or humidity. Learned that the hard way after a patch job went streaky in one place. Still, for old houses especially, it’s hard to beat for both looks and indoor air quality.
Totally get what you mean about the “feel” of lime and clay paints. I’m in the middle of my first reno and decided to try limewash in the living room—honestly, I was nervous about messing it up, but there’s something really satisfying about how it looks once it dries. It’s not just the color, it’s like the walls have a bit more life? Hard to explain until you see it.
I had a similar issue with streaks at first. What helped me was doing super thin coats and letting each one dry longer than I thought necessary. Also, I learned (the hard way) that humidity can totally mess with the finish... had to redo a whole section after a rainy week.
I hear you on the eco acrylics too. They’re fine for some spaces, but yeah, they just don’t have that same vibe. If you’re willing to put in a little extra prep, these natural paints really do make a difference—plus, no weird chemical smell lingering for days. Kind of makes all the effort worth it.