Remodeling discussions and local services.

Kitchen Redesign Adventure: Worth the Hype or Not?

748 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

eecho18

I get where you’re coming from. Honestly, I used to think more counters would solve all my problems, but in reality, they just became dumping grounds for random stuff. Bigger drawers and a pull-out pantry sound way more practical - less clutter, less cleaning, and you actually find what you need. Those corner carousels though... every time I see one, I wonder if anyone really uses them or if they’re just a fancy way to lose Tupperware lids forever.


Reply
zeldastar527

I totally get the skepticism about those corner carousels. I put one in during my last reno, thinking it’d be a game changer, but honestly? Half the time stuff just migrates to the back and I forget it’s even there. Drawers and pantries are way easier to keep organized, at least for me. Have you tried deep drawers for pots and pans? That was a surprise win in my kitchen - no more digging around on my hands and knees.


Reply

“Half the time stuff just migrates to the back and I forget it’s even there.”

I get what you mean, but I actually found a way to make my corner carousel work for me. Here’s what I did: 1) I only put stuff I use all the time on it - like oils and baking stuff. 2) I labeled the shelves (sounds dorky, but it helps). 3) Every couple weeks, I do a quick spin and pull out anything that’s hiding. It’s not perfect, but I kinda like the quirky spinny thing. Deep drawers are cool, but for my tiny kitchen, that wasted a lot of corner space. Guess it depends on your layout and what you use most.


Reply
cyclotourist98

Kitchen Redesign Adventure: Worth the Hype or Not?

I hear you on the deep drawers - mine basically turned into a black hole for Tupperware lids and that one weird spatula I never use. The carousel thing is quirky, but honestly, it’s saved me from crawling on my hands and knees into the abyss of the corner cabinet. I did try labeling once, but my family just ignored them and put stuff wherever, so now it’s more of a “spin and hope for the best” situation.

I do think it comes down to kitchen size and how much patience you have for organizing. In my last flip, I tried those fancy pull-out shelves, but they jammed if you even looked at them funny. At least with the carousel, you get a little entertainment while you hunt for the cinnamon. Not perfect, but hey, it beats losing another bottle of olive oil to the void.


Reply

Kitchen Redesign Adventure: Worth the Hype or Not?

Deep drawers are a double-edged sword, for sure. I’ve seen folks get all excited about them during a remodel, but six months later, they’re cursing every time they dig for a measuring cup. I’m with you on the carousels - those lazy Susans aren’t perfect, but at least you’re not risking a pulled muscle just to grab a can of beans.

Funny thing, I once installed those soft-close pull-out shelves for a client who swore they’d change her life. Two weeks in, she called me back because her kids kept overloading them and the tracks jammed up constantly. Sometimes the “fancy” solutions just add more headaches.

Honestly, I think half the battle is figuring out what actually fits your habits instead of what looks cool in a showroom. If your family ignores labels (which is pretty much universal), no amount of organizing gadgets will save you from chaos. At the end of the day, if you can find your cinnamon without breaking a sweat or losing your mind, that’s probably as good as it gets.


Reply

Honestly, I think half the battle is figuring out what actually fits your habits instead of what looks cool in a showroom.

Couldn’t agree more with this. It’s easy to get caught up in the latest gadgets and “solutions,” but if they don’t match how you actually use your kitchen, they just become clutter. Deep drawers are a classic example - great for pots and pans, but not so much for small stuff unless you’re super organized (and let’s be real, most of us aren’t labeling every container).

I’ve seen carousels work well in tight corners, but only if you’re not overloading them. The hardware on those things isn’t always built for heavy cans or stacks of baking dishes. Pull-out shelves can be fantastic, but like you mentioned, they’re only as good as the way they’re used. If kids are involved...well, durability matters more than fancy features.

At the end of the day, function beats form. If your setup lets you cook without hunting for tools or ingredients, that’s a win - even if it’s not “Pinterest perfect.”


Reply

Totally get where you’re coming from about deep drawers. I thought they’d be the answer to my clutter problems, but now I’m just fishing around for lids half the time. And don’t get me started on those corner carousels - mine groans every time I put a Dutch oven on it. Maybe it’s just not meant for heavy lifting, but the idea seemed so good in the showroom.

Pull-out shelves are a bit of a mixed bag too. They’re great until someone (usually my kid) decides to use them as a step stool. Durability definitely trumps fancy features in my house... learned that the hard way after replacing a couple of hinges.

Honestly, I’ve found that sticking with what actually works for your routine is way less stressful than chasing after the latest “must-have” feature. My kitchen isn’t winning any design awards, but at least I can find my spatula without digging through three drawers. That’s a win in my book - even if it’s not Instagram-worthy.


Reply
business770

I hear you on the deep drawers and carousels - some of those “innovations” just end up being more trouble than they’re worth. But I’ll admit, after years of living with the original 1920s cabinets in my place (tiny doors, shelves so deep you lose things for months), some of these newer features still feel like a step up. My old corner cabinet was basically a black hole for Tupperware lids and potato mashers.

That said, I do think there’s a sweet spot between fancy gadgets and pure practicality. We did add pull-out shelves in our pantry, but went with heavy-duty hardware and skipped the soft-close nonsense. They’ve held up surprisingly well, even with my husband’s habit of stacking canned goods like he’s prepping for the apocalypse.

I guess what I’m saying is, sometimes the “must-haves” are just marketing fluff, but every now and then one actually solves a real problem - if you pick carefully. Still, nothing beats knowing exactly where your spatula is... even if it’s not in a magazine spread.


Reply
riverchef

Honestly, I couldn't agree more about finding that balance.

sometimes the “must-haves” are just marketing fluff, but every now and then one actually solves a real problem - if you pick carefully
- that’s it in a nutshell. I’ve replaced enough busted lazy Susans to know some features just aren’t worth the hassle. Pull-outs with solid hardware, though, really do make life easier. If you know where your stuff is (and it isn’t jammed behind a blender from 1987), you’re winning the kitchen game.


Reply
timphotographer

Totally get what you mean about the lazy Susans - ours was basically a graveyard for expired spices and random kitchen gadgets. I finally gave up and just went with deep drawers for pots and pans, and honestly, I haven’t missed the spinning shelf at all. Pull-outs are a game changer, especially when you’re trying to make the most of a small space without spending a fortune.

I do wonder sometimes if I’m missing out by skipping some of the “cool” features, though. Like, those built-in knife blocks or pop-up outlets look slick, but I can’t help but think they’re more trouble than they’re worth (or just another thing to break). I’d rather put the money into better cabinet hardware or a countertop that won’t stain if you look at it funny.

Curious if anyone’s found a budget-friendly upgrade that actually made a difference? I’m always on the lookout for something that’s not just hype but actually helps day-to-day. For me, swapping out the old fluorescent light for LEDs made a bigger impact than any fancy organizer ever did. Sometimes it’s the little things, right?


Reply

Deep drawers are a huge win - way more practical than those spinning shelves, in my experience. I’ve skipped the built-in knife blocks too; they just seem like a pain to clean and not worth the hassle if you ever want to rearrange things. Swapping to soft-close hinges on all the cabinets was my favorite upgrade so far. Not flashy, but it makes the kitchen feel higher-end and keeps things from slamming shut. Has anyone tried those under-cabinet motion sensor lights? I’m tempted, but not sure if they’re actually useful or just another gadget that’ll break after a year...


Reply

Swapping to soft-close hinges on all the cabinets was my favorite upgrade so far. Not flashy, but it makes the kitchen feel higher-end and keeps things from slamming shut.

Couldn’t agree more - soft-close is one of those upgrades you don’t realize you need until you have it. As for the under-cabinet motion lights, I was skeptical too, but honestly, they’ve been a game changer for late-night snack runs or when your hands are full. Just make sure to get a decent brand; the cheap ones really do die fast. Deep drawers over spinning shelves any day, by the way... those lazy Susans always seem to jam up or hide stuff in the back forever.


Reply

Deep drawers over spinning shelves any day, by the way... those lazy Susans always seem to jam up or hide stuff in the back forever.

I hear you on the deep drawers - way more practical than chasing a can of beans around a spinning shelf. Funny thing, I once thought lazy Susans were a “must” for resale value, but honestly, buyers seem more impressed by smooth-gliding drawers and clever pull-outs these days. And yeah, motion lights are underrated... nothing like hands-free illumination when you’re juggling groceries and trying not to wake everyone up.


Reply
rayj55

“nothing like hands-free illumination when you’re juggling groceries and trying not to wake everyone up.”

Totally agree on the motion lights - didn’t even think about them until I was halfway through planning. Now I wish I’d put them everywhere, honestly. As for deep drawers, I was skeptical at first (thought they’d be a mess), but turns out they’re way easier to keep organized than those corner spinning things. My old lazy Susan just collected expired spices and mystery lids... never again.


Reply

Deep drawers are a game changer, right? I used to think they’d just turn into a black hole for Tupperware, but now I’m convinced they’re the only way to go. The lazy Susan thing cracks me up - every time I’d spin mine, it was like playing “what expired first?” roulette.

Curious if anyone’s tried those pull-out corner drawers instead of the spinning ones? I’ve installed a few and folks seem to love them, but I haven’t lived with one myself. Also, what’s the verdict on under-cabinet lighting - worth the extra wiring hassle, or just another thing to dust? Sometimes I wonder if we’re all just chasing the next kitchen gadget that’ll end up in the junk drawer...


Reply
animator44

Curious if anyone’s tried those pull-out corner drawers instead of the spinning ones? I’ve installed a few and folks seem to love them, but I haven’t lived with one myself.

Deep drawers: 100% agree, they’re a lifesaver for pots and pans - no more crouching to dig stuff out.

Pull-out corner drawers? I’ve seen them in action. Way less “lost Tupperware” than the lazy Susan, but you do lose a bit of space in the corners. Trade-off, I guess.

Under-cabinet lighting - honestly, I’m on the fence. It looks great and helps with prep, but yeah, it’s another surface to wipe down. If you cook a lot at night or have a dark kitchen, probably worth it. Otherwise... maybe not essential.

And yeah, half my “space-saving gadgets” end up in the back of a drawer. Some things never change.


Reply
eharris57

Way less “lost Tupperware” than the lazy Susan, but you do lose a bit of space in the corners. Trade-off, I guess.

Yeah, that’s been my experience too. Pull-out corners are smoother to use, but you’re giving up some storage. If you’re tight on space, it might bug you. Deep drawers are a must - can’t imagine going back. Under-cabinet lighting is nice, but honestly, I barely notice it after a while. Most gadgets just end up collecting dust anyway...


Reply
musician10

Title: Kitchen Redesign Adventure: Worth the Hype or Not?

I get where you’re coming from about deep drawers - those things are game changers for pots, pans, and all the random kitchen stuff that never seems to have a home. But I’ve actually seen a few folks regret giving up corner cabinets entirely, especially in smaller kitchens. Sometimes it’s not about maximizing every inch, but more about how you use the space you do have. Ever tried those corner drawers that sort of zig-zag out? They’re quirky, but surprisingly functional if you don’t mind a little oddball engineering.

On the under-cabinet lighting - funny thing, I used to think it was just a “nice to have” too, until I worked on a kitchen where the main light was always blocked by someone standing at the counter. Suddenly, those little LEDs made all the difference. Maybe it depends on how much you cook at night or if your kitchen gets decent daylight. I’d say it’s one of those features you don’t appreciate until you’re chopping onions in your own shadow.

As for gadgets, yeah, most end up in the graveyard drawer... but every now and then, someone swears by their bread maker or air fryer. I guess it comes down to what actually fits your routine. I’ve seen people design whole pull-out shelves just for their stand mixer because they use it daily. Others just want more counter space and less clutter.

Curious if anyone’s found a way to make those awkward corner spots actually useful without feeling like you’re sacrificing too much? Or maybe there’s a clever hack out there that doesn’t involve another spinning tray. Always feels like there’s some new trick I haven’t seen yet...


Reply
dennisw75

Curious if anyone’s found a way to make those awkward corner spots actually useful without feeling like you’re sacrificing too much? Or maybe there’s a clever hack out there that doesn’t involve another spinning tray.

Here’s what’s worked for me: I ripped out the old lazy Susan and built a custom pull-out with two deep trays on heavy-duty slides. It’s not fancy, but I can stash my slow cooker and a stack of mixing bowls in there - way more practical than spinning trays that always jam. Takes a bit of DIY patience to get the slides lined up, but it’s solid. Has anyone tried those corner pantries that use the dead space for vertical storage? Wondering if they’re worth the hassle or just another gimmick.


Reply

I’m right there with you on the lazy Susan frustration - mine always felt like a relic from another era, and I swear it ate more Tupperware lids than it ever helped me find. I swapped mine out for a recycled-wood pull-out, similar to what you described, and honestly, it’s made that corner finally feel intentional instead of just “oh, here’s where stuff goes to die.”

About those tall corner pantries: I’ve seen a few in eco-conscious remodels, where folks use vertical cubbies for baking sheets or cutting boards. It looks tidy, but I’m not convinced it’s the best use of space unless you’re really short on cabinets elsewhere. Plus, unless you’re careful with materials and ventilation, mold can sneak in since corners tend to be cooler and damper.

Has anyone figured out a way to use those awkward spots for compost bins or recycling storage? I keep thinking there’s potential there, but haven’t cracked it yet...


Reply
Scroll to Top