Remodeling discussions and local services.

Kitchen Redesign Adventure: Worth the Hype or Not?

748 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

mobile_holly7586

Structure doesn’t have to mean sterile or expensive, just practical for the space you’ve got.

I get where you’re coming from, but I’d actually push back a bit on the idea that structure always has to be “practical” in the sense of adding more stuff - even if it’s DIY. Sometimes, especially in these old kitchens, less really is more. I tried making custom dividers too (mine were cardboard and duct tape, not as classy as scrap wood), but after a while I realized I was just organizing clutter.

What worked better for me was pulling everything out and only putting back what I actually use every week. The rest went into a box in the basement. If I didn’t go looking for it after a month, it got donated. Not saying everyone should go full minimalist, but sometimes those weird old drawers are telling us we don’t need as much as we think.

That said, totally agree that you don’t need to spend big bucks on fancy organizers. Old jars, boxes, even cut-down cereal boxes can do the trick. Just gotta find what fits your groove - and your kitchen’s quirks.


Reply
kathytrader

I totally get what you mean about just organizing clutter. I’ve been there - spent a Saturday afternoon cutting up old Amazon boxes to make drawer dividers, only to realize I was just shuffling around stuff I never actually used. Your method of boxing up the “maybes” and seeing if you miss them is honestly genius. It’s like a trial run for minimalism without the panic of tossing everything at once.

Not saying everyone should go full minimalist, but sometimes those weird old drawers are telling us we don’t need as much as we think.

That hits home. My kitchen’s got these deep, awkward drawers that seem designed for mystery utensils and random gadgets. I used to think I needed to fill every inch with something useful, but now I’m leaning more toward open space - even if it looks a little empty at first.

One thing that helped me was doing a “use it or lose it” week. Every time I cooked, if I reached for something and it wasn’t there, I’d go grab it from the box. If I didn’t need it by the end of the week, it probably wasn’t essential. It’s surprising how few things actually made their way back into the kitchen.

I’m curious - did you find yourself missing anything after your month-long test? Or did you ever regret donating something? Sometimes I worry about getting rid of that one weird tool and then needing it six months later... but so far, hasn’t happened.

Also, totally agree on using what you have for organizers. My favorite “hack” is using old glass jars for utensils and cutlery - looks kind of rustic and costs nothing. Anyone else have clever ways to repurpose stuff for storage?


Reply
productivity683

Sometimes I worry about getting rid of that one weird tool and then needing it six months later... but so far, hasn’t happened.

Funny you mention that - once I donated a melon baller and then, months later, tried to make those fancy fruit salads for a party. Had to improvise with a teaspoon. Didn’t really miss it, though; just made me laugh at myself for thinking I’d use it more. For storage, I’ve used old baking pans as drawer trays. Not pretty, but they keep all the measuring spoons from vanishing into the abyss. Anyone else find deep drawers just swallow stuff no matter what you do?


Reply

Deep drawers are like black holes for kitchen gadgets. I swear, I’ve lost more spatulas to the depths than I care to admit.

“they keep all the measuring spoons from vanishing into the abyss.”
That’s exactly it - no matter how many organizers I try, something always escapes. Honestly, I’m all for open shelving or shallow drawers. It’s not just about looks; it actually helps you see what you have and use it more. Deep drawers are overrated unless you’re storing baking sheets or giant pots.


Reply
mollyharris884

I hear you on the deep drawer dilemma. It’s funny - people always rave about them, but in practice, they can be more hassle than help.

“no matter how many organizers I try, something always escapes.”
That’s been my experience too. Shallow drawers or even pull-out trays inside cabinets make a world of difference for smaller tools. Deep drawers do have their place, but only if you’re storing big stuff. Otherwise, it’s just a game of hide and seek with your utensils.


Reply

Couldn’t agree more with this:

“no matter how many organizers I try, something always escapes.”
Deep drawers look sleek in the showroom, but in real life? I feel like I’m always digging for that one spatula. I’ve started using more shallow drawers for utensils and gadgets, and honestly, it’s just less stressful. Deep drawers are perfect for pots or bulkier stuff, but for anything small, they’re just a black hole.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve actually had the opposite experience with deep drawers - at least when they’re set up right. I use adjustable dividers and trays, and it’s made a huge difference. Instead of stacking, I lay utensils flat, which keeps things visible. Sure, if you just toss stuff in, it’s chaos, but with a bit of planning, deep drawers can be surprisingly efficient. Maybe it’s just a matter of finding the right system for your stuff?


Reply
sports661

Deep drawers can be a bit of a gamble, honestly. I’ve seen them work wonders in some kitchens - especially when folks actually use those dividers and organizers you mentioned. In a couple of my rentals, tenants either loved them or just let them turn into a black hole for random gadgets. I guess it really does come down to how you set them up and what you’re storing. When they’re dialed in, though, they’re super handy.


Reply
rivermountaineer9704

Deep drawers are one of those things I thought would be a game-changer when we redid our kitchen, but honestly? Mixed bag. In my old house, they just ended up full of random baking pans and stuff I forgot I even owned. Now, with some organizers, they’re actually useful - pots and lids finally have a home. Still, if you’re not careful, they turn into a junk pit fast. Guess it’s all about staying on top of the clutter... which is easier said than done around here.


Reply

Funny, I see this all the time - deep drawers seem like a no-brainer, but they really do need a plan. I usually suggest folks map out what’s actually going in each drawer before the remodel even starts. Did you end up measuring your pans and pots ahead of time, or just wing it? Sometimes that makes all the difference...


Reply
space330

- Measured everything down to the weird oval roasting pan - still ended up with the colander stuck at a diagonal.
- Deep drawers are awesome for hiding chaos, but if you don’t plan, they turn into black holes for spatulas and lids.
- I actually taped out spots on the floor to “pretend” load the drawers before we ordered anything. My partner thought I was nuts, but hey, now our Dutch oven fits without scraping the sides.
- Funny thing, though - no matter how well you plan, there’s always that one mystery kitchen gadget that refuses to fit anywhere.
- Worth the hype? For me, yes, but only because I like a little drama with my storage solutions.


Reply

Taped spots on the floor - now that’s dedication. I once tried to map out my cabinet space using cardboard cutouts, but the 1920s built-ins had other ideas. Ended up with my stand mixer living in the coat closet for a year. Deep drawers are a blessing and a curse, especially when you’re fishing for a potato masher and come up with a gravy boat instead. I’d say the hype is real, but only if you’re prepared for a little chaos to sneak in no matter how much you plan.


Reply
drummer62

I hear you on the deep drawer chaos, but honestly, I think a little planning can go a long way - even with those unpredictable old cabinets. One trick I swear by: drawer dividers and tiered organizers. It sounds fussy, but it’s saved me from digging past the tangle of whisks and ladles every time. And about the stand mixer - sometimes it’s worth sacrificing some “prime real estate” for the stuff you use daily, even if it means less symmetry. Kitchens rarely end up as tidy as the plans, but I do think you can keep the chaos mostly in check with a few tweaks.


Reply
hollyv14

“sometimes it’s worth sacrificing some ‘prime real estate’ for the stuff you use daily, even if it means less symmetry.”

Couldn’t agree more on that one - function over form, every time. Here’s what I’ve seen work (and what I tell clients who are tired of the “utensil avalanche”):

- Drawer dividers are a lifesaver, but don’t forget about vertical storage. Pegboards or wall rails can get those awkward tools out of the drawer entirely.
- For deep drawers, try stacking shallow bins inside. It’s not fancy, but it keeps the potato masher from hiding under the rolling pin.
- Stand mixer? If you use it all the time, give it a home on the counter. I know, it messes with the “magazine look,” but honestly, nobody’s kitchen stays photo-ready for long.

I’ve seen people stress over matching everything and then end up frustrated when they can’t find the garlic press. A little chaos is normal - embrace it, just corral it where you can. And hey, if your kitchen looks “lived in,” that’s a good sign you’re actually using it.


Reply
politics448

“nobody’s kitchen stays photo-ready for long.”

That’s the truth. I tried to keep my old farmhouse kitchen “magazine perfect” for about a week - gave up after tripping over the bread box twice and realizing I’d hidden the coffee grinder behind a stack of vintage tins. At some point, practicality wins out over aesthetics, especially in a space that gets as much use as the kitchen. Symmetry is nice, but being able to grab the spatula without a treasure hunt? Much nicer.


Reply
sailing_ryan1687

Totally get where you’re coming from. I always tell folks: design for how you actually live, not just how you want it to look in photos. A kitchen that works for your daily routines is way more satisfying than one that just looks good on Instagram. Sometimes a little clutter just means you’re actually using the space.


Reply

I get what you mean, but honestly, I’m kinda over the “lived-in” look. I want my kitchen to look nice, even if it means hiding the toaster every morning. I just like coming home to a clean, uncluttered space... even if it’s not super practical.


Reply
apollo_fisher

I totally get the appeal of a spotless, “magazine-ready” kitchen, but I always wonder how sustainable it is day-to-day. Like, hiding the toaster every morning? That’s some commitment. I tried that for a week and ended up just leaving it on the counter again because I was running late (and honestly, who has the energy before coffee?).

I want my kitchen to look nice, even if it means hiding the toaster every morning.

I’m curious - do you think the extra effort actually pays off in terms of stress or happiness? Or does it just add another thing to your mental checklist? For me, I’ve found that a little clutter is almost like proof that people actually live here. But then again, maybe I’m just making excuses for not tidying up more often...

Also, have you found any budget-friendly storage solutions that make it easier to keep things hidden away? Some of those Pinterest ideas look amazing but cost a small fortune.


Reply

Like, hiding the toaster every morning?

I hear you on the “proof that people actually live here” part. Our kitchen’s in a 1920s house, so it’s never going to look like a showroom, and honestly, I kind of love that. I did try one of those rolling carts from IKEA to stash appliances - super cheap, fits under the counter, and no fancy installation needed. But hiding the toaster every day? That lasted about three days before I gave up. Sometimes a little visible clutter just feels right.


Reply

Honestly, I see this all the time - people get excited about “minimalist” kitchens, but real life just doesn’t work that way. Those rolling carts are a lifesaver for older homes with limited storage. Still, daily appliance hide-and-seek gets old fast. Sometimes function wins over form, and that’s totally fine. A lived-in kitchen has its own charm, even if the toaster’s always out.


Reply
Scroll to Top