Remodeling discussions and local services.
If You Had to Redo Your Kitchen Lights, What Would You Pick?
- Under-cabinet LEDs are a total game changer, especially in these old houses where the wiring is... let’s just say “quirky.”
- I went with battery-powered puck lights under my cabinets. No rewiring, no fuss, and if one dies, I just swap out the batteries. Not as fancy as hardwired, but they get the job done and nobody’s tripping a breaker.
- Warm tone is key. Anything too cool and my kitchen starts looking like a hospital cafeteria - not exactly the vibe I’m going for with all this 1920s woodwork.
- Only hiccup: sometimes the adhesive strips don’t love textured plaster. Had a couple lights take a nosedive mid-dinner party. Adds excitement, I guess?
- If I ever do a full reno, I’d probably spring for proper under-cabinet lighting wired in by someone who actually understands knob-and-tube. Until then, these little LEDs are holding down the fort.
Honestly, it’s wild how much difference a bit of light makes when you’re trying to read Grandma’s recipe in the evening.
Battery-powered puck lights are definitely easy, but I’ve got to say, they’re not my top pick from a sustainability angle. Here’s why:
- Swapping out batteries constantly just feels wasteful, especially if you’re using disposables instead of rechargeables. Those things add up in the landfill.
- Adhesive strips on textured walls - yeah, been there, and it’s a pain. Plus, all that plastic and packaging for short-lived lights isn’t great for the planet either.
- For old houses, I actually prefer plug-in LED strips with a timer or motion sensor. You can run the cord along the back of the cabinets, avoid battery waste, and still skip the rewiring headache.
- Warm light is non-negotiable though. Totally agree there - nobody wants “surgical suite” vibes in a kitchen with vintage charm.
Honestly, if you’re renting or just not ready for a reno, plug-in LEDs seem like the best middle ground. Less waste, more reliable, and you can still read those hand-written recipes without squinting.
I get where you’re coming from with the battery waste, but I’ve actually had decent luck with rechargeable puck lights in my 1920s kitchen. Maybe it’s just me, but I don’t mind charging them every few weeks, and it saves me from running cords everywhere (which always seem to get tangled with my toaster or kettle). Do you find the plug-in strips are easy to hide? I always worry about cords looking messy against old plaster walls.
Hiding cords in these old houses is a nightmare, honestly. I tried running a plug-in strip along the top of my cabinets once - looked like a snake had moved in. Ended up just embracing the rechargeable lights too. Less hassle, and I don’t trip over anything when I’m half-awake making coffee.
Hiding cords in these old houses is a nightmare, honestly.
You’re not wrong - old plaster walls and weirdly placed outlets make it a real puzzle. I get the appeal of rechargeable lights, but I’ve found they don’t always give off enough light for actual cooking, especially if you’re chopping or reading recipes. Have you ever looked into hardwiring LED strips under the cabinets? It’s a bit of work upfront, but once it’s done, you never have to think about charging or tripping over anything again. Curious if anyone’s tried that in a place with tricky walls - did it end up being worth the hassle?
Hardwiring LEDs under the cabinets was a game changer for me, even with plaster walls. It took some creative routing, but the consistent light is worth it. Rechargeables never lasted through dinner prep anyway. If you can swing it, it’s worth the hassle.
- Totally agree on the hardwired LEDs - once you’ve got them, it’s hard to go back.
- Plaster walls are a pain, but honestly, I found fishing the wires behind my 1920s lath less stressful than constantly recharging those stick-on lights.
- Only thing I’d add: dimmer switches. Game changer for late-night snack raids when you don’t want to wake the whole house.
- If you’re worried about patching plaster, painter’s caulk and a steady hand go a long way... trust me, I’ve made my share of “oops” holes.
- Rechargeables are fine for closets, but for kitchens? Nah, I need something that actually lasts through a Sunday roast.
- Hardwired LEDs all the way - no contest. I tried those rechargeable puck lights in my last place and spent more time charging them than actually using them.
- Plaster walls are brutal, but I found a flexible drill bit made things way easier. Still ended up with a few “extra” holes, though... painter’s caulk definitely saved me there.
- Dimmer switches are underrated. My partner is a light sleeper, so being able to sneak in for a midnight snack without blinding everyone is key.
- Only thing I’d add: under-cabinet lighting. Makes chopping onions at 7am way less dangerous.
Ever tried running low-voltage LED tape under the cabinets? I’ve seen folks go with the hardwired puck lights, but the tape gives such a clean, even glow - no weird shadows when you’re slicing stuff. Curious if anyone’s run into issues with those over time, though... like, do they start to peel off or lose brightness after a couple years?
On the plaster wall front, did you patch your “extra” holes before painting, or just caulk and call it good? I’ve had clients who get pretty particular about wall texture matching, especially in older homes where nothing’s flat. Sometimes I wonder if it’s worth chasing that perfect patch or just living with a little character.
And about dimmers - do you go for smart switches or stick with the old-school ones? I’ve had mixed results with smart dimmers glitching out, but maybe that’s just me.
Honestly, I’m not sold on LED tape for under-cabinet lighting long-term. I’ve had to replace a few installs after a couple years - adhesive just doesn’t hold up in kitchens with all the heat and humidity, and yeah, you’ll notice dim spots over time. Hardwired pucks might cast more shadows, but they’re way more reliable if you want something that lasts.
On plaster, I never just caulk and paint. Texture matching is a pain, but if you skip it, those patches stick out like a sore thumb. Clients might say they don’t care, but once the light hits it wrong, they always notice.
As for dimmers, I stick with old-school every time. Smart switches are cool until they aren’t - too many callbacks for random glitches or connectivity issues. Sometimes simple is just better.
I’ve been eyeing those LED tape lights because they look so sleek in photos, but hearing about the adhesive issues makes me second guess it. Are the hardwired pucks tricky to install if you’re not super handy? I’m kinda nervous about cutting into cabinets.
Honestly, pucks aren’t too bad if you’re comfortable using a drill and measuring things out, but the hardest part is usually fishing the wires neatly and figuring out where to put the switch. Cutting into cabinets can feel intimidating, but it’s usually just a small hole for the wire. Have you thought about wireless puck lights as a middle ground? They’re not as bright, but no drilling required...
I get what you mean about the wires - that part always takes me longer than I think it will. I tried the wireless puck lights in my pantry once, and honestly, they were a bit underwhelming brightness-wise. If you don’t mind changing batteries every so often, though, it’s a pretty stress-free install. For my kitchen redo, I ended up going with LED strips tucked under the cabinets. They’re surprisingly easy to hide and give off a nice even light without much fuss.
I tried the wireless puck lights in my pantry once, and honestly, they were a bit underwhelming brightness-wise.
Ha, I had the same experience with those puck lights - felt like I was lighting my pantry with a couple of birthday candles. My house is old enough that every time I touch the wiring, I half expect to find a squirrel’s nest or something. Ended up running LED strips too, but getting them to stick to my slightly lumpy plaster was... let’s just say, gravity won that round a few times. Still, way better than swapping batteries every month.
Honestly, puck lights are just not it for pantries or kitchens. I tried them under my cabinets and they barely made a dent - felt more like mood lighting than anything actually useful. I ended up biting the bullet and putting in hardwired under-cabinet LEDs. The difference is wild, especially for chopping or reading recipes. Installation was a pain with all the weird angles in my 1950s kitchen, but totally worth it. If I had to redo things, I'd go even brighter and maybe add a dimmer for those late-night snack runs...
I get where you’re coming from - puck lights just don’t cut it for actual task lighting. I tried the stick-on battery ones in my rental and honestly, they were more of a hassle than a help. But hardwiring LEDs isn’t always in the budget, especially if you’re not planning to stay long-term. I ended up using LED strip lights that plug in, and while they’re not as sleek, they’re surprisingly bright and way cheaper. If I ever own a place, though, I’d probably go all-in on hardwired with a dimmer too... nothing beats being able to actually see what you’re doing when you cook.
Hard agree on the puck lights - they look cool at first, but you end up squinting just to chop an onion. I’ve installed a bunch of different setups over the years, and honestly, plug-in LED strips are a solid workaround if you can’t hardwire. Not as tidy, but way better than those battery things that die after a week. If it’s your own place though, hardwired under-cabinet LEDs with a dimmer is the way to go. Makes a huge difference when you’re actually trying to cook instead of just making the kitchen look nice for photos.
Couldn’t agree more about the battery puck lights - those things are a pain. I’ve swapped out so many dead ones for folks who thought they’d be a quick fix. Hardwired LEDs with a dimmer really do make the space feel pro, and you actually see what you’re doing. Even the plug-in strips are miles ahead of the old battery setups. It’s wild how much proper lighting changes the vibe (and safety) in a kitchen.
Yeah, those battery puck lights really are the worst - mine lasted like two weeks before they started flickering and dying. I thought I was being clever going the “easy install” route, but nope.
- Hardwired LEDs with dimmers sound like a dream. I love the idea of adjusting the mood depending on what you’re doing (midnight snack vs. chopping onions).
- Plug-in strips seem like a solid middle ground too, but I’ve wondered if they look clunky or mess with the vibe. Do they actually blend in, or do you always notice the cord?
- Also kinda curious about those under-cabinet LED tape lights - are they bright enough for real cooking, or just for show?
If you had to pick just one spot to really upgrade lighting, would it be over the counters, sink, or maybe even inside cabinets? I’m torn between function and just wanting everything to look awesome...
If I had to pick just one spot, I’d say under-cabinet lighting over the counters makes the biggest difference, hands down. I’ve installed a lot of those LED tape lights for clients (and in my own place), and honestly, the good ones are plenty bright for actual cooking - just make sure you check the lumens and color temperature. Warm white is cozier, but a neutral white (around 4000K) is way better for chopping and reading recipes.
Plug-in strips are hit or miss. Some brands have really slim cords you can tuck up behind the cabinets, but if you’ve got an open backsplash or glass-front cabinets, you might always see the wire. It bugs some people more than others. Hardwired is obviously cleaner, but not always worth the hassle if you’re renting or just want a quick fix.
Inside cabinets looks cool, but unless you’re always rummaging at night or showing off fancy dishes, it’s more “wow” than useful. I’d focus on counters first - makes everyday stuff way easier, and it just looks sharp.