Remodeling discussions and local services.

If You Had to Redo Your Kitchen Lights, What Would You Pick?

659 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

mario_fluffy4378

I totally get what you're saying about LEDs feeling a bit too clinical for older homes. When I renovated the kitchen in one of my investment properties - a charming 1920s bungalow - I initially went with recessed LEDs thinking it'd be a no-brainer. But once installed, the place lost some of its cozy charm. It felt like I'd accidentally turned a vintage cafe into a dentist's waiting room.

Ended up compromising by mixing lighting types: kept some subtle LED under-cabinet strips for practicality (because tenants love good task lighting), but added vintage-style sconces and a couple of Edison bulb pendants to warm things up. Honestly, that combo worked wonders. It balanced efficiency and aesthetics nicely, and renters seemed to appreciate the character.

Sometimes it's not about picking one or the other, but finding that sweet spot between modern convenience and preserving the home's original vibe. Plus, there's something oddly satisfying about seeing those old-school bulbs glowing softly at night...


Reply

Your lighting combo sounds spot-on. I had a similar experience when we redid our kitchen a couple years back. Went all-in on LEDs at first, thinking brighter was better, but it felt like cooking under stadium lights - way too harsh. Ended up swapping a few out for warmer bulbs and added a vintage pendant over the breakfast nook. Made a huge difference. You're right, there's something comforting about that softer, warmer glow, especially in older homes.

Mixing modern and vintage lighting like you did is probably the best way to keep things functional without losing character. Plus, Edison bulbs just have that cozy vibe that's hard to replicate with pure LEDs. Glad your tenants appreciate it too - makes all the effort worth it, doesn't it?


Reply
aaronc51

Had a similar issue when we flipped a mid-century ranch last year. Initially went with sleek recessed LEDs everywhere, but the kitchen felt cold and sterile. Ended up bringing in a couple vintage-style sconces and a warmer pendant above the island. Totally changed the vibe - felt inviting instead of clinical. LEDs are practical, sure, but mixing in softer, warmer fixtures really balances things out, especially in spaces like kitchens where you spend lots of time. Glad I'm not the only one who learned this the hard way...


Reply
dev_katie

Went through something similar with a kitchen remodel a while back. Initially, I was all-in on recessed LEDs because they're clean, modern, and energy-efficient. But after installation, the room felt oddly clinical - like a dentist's office or something. I ended up swapping out a few fixtures for warmer, softer lighting too.

One thing I've found helpful since then is paying close attention to color temperature. LEDs come in different warmth levels (measured in Kelvin), and choosing bulbs around 2700K-3000K can really soften the atmosphere without losing brightness. Also, dimmers are your friend. Being able to adjust brightness depending on the time of day or what you're doing makes a huge difference.

I do like your idea about mixing in vintage-style sconces though...haven't tried that myself yet. Did you go with actual vintage fixtures or new ones designed to look vintage? Curious how hard it was to match them with the rest of your decor.

Lighting's one of those things you don't realize matters so much until you get it wrong, haha. Glad I'm not alone in learning this lesson the hard way...


Reply
hiking_donna

I get what you're saying about recessed LEDs feeling clinical, but honestly, I think placement matters just as much as color temp. I've found that spacing them differently or adding under-cabinet lighting can totally change the vibe...might be worth experimenting before swapping fixtures again.


Reply

I hear you on placement making a difference. When we redid our kitchen, I thought recessed LEDs would be perfect, but after installation, it felt a bit like a dentist's office. We ended up adding some warm pendant lights over the island, and suddenly the whole room felt cozy again. Makes me wonder - has anyone tried mixing recessed lighting with pendants or sconces? Curious if that combo worked out for others or if it just ends up looking cluttered...


Reply

Mixing recessed lights with pendants can actually work really well if you plan it out thoughtfully. I've done several kitchens where we combined recessed LEDs for general lighting and pendants to add warmth or highlight certain areas. The key is spacing - don't crowd them together. Keep recessed lights evenly spaced for overall illumination, then use pendants strategically, like over islands or dining spots. If you're worried about clutter, dimmers help a ton...you can adjust brightness and create different moods easily.


Reply

I get the appeal of recessed lights and pendants, but honestly, after renovating a few properties, I've found under-cabinet lighting to be the unsung hero. It's subtle, practical, and saves you from accidentally chopping veggies in the dark...trust me on that one.


Reply
megancollector

Under-cabinet lighting is handy, but have you tried toe-kick lighting? I've seen it in a few kitchens lately - seems kinda gimmicky at first, but apparently it's great for late-night snack raids without blinding yourself...anyone have experience with it?


Reply

"seems kinda gimmicky at first, but apparently it's great for late-night snack raids without blinding yourself..."

I've installed toe-kick lighting in a couple of kitchen remodels recently. It's subtle and practical - especially if you choose a warm LED strip with a diffuser to avoid harsh shadows. One thing to consider though: placement matters. Too bright or poorly angled, and it can highlight every crumb on your floor...not ideal. Curious if anyone's tried motion sensors with theirs? Seems like that could be handy for midnight trips without fumbling for switches.


Reply
kimd25

"Curious if anyone's tried motion sensors with theirs? Seems like that could be handy for midnight trips without fumbling for switches."

Tried motion sensors in mine and they're pretty convenient overall. But sometimes they trigger randomly if the pets wander through at night...which can be a bit annoying. Wondering if there's a good way to calibrate them better or a brand that's less sensitive to small movements?


Reply
dev_john

I've been looking into motion sensors myself and heard some brands let you adjust sensitivity levels or even set height angles to avoid pet-triggered lights. Maybe tweaking the placement or angle could help? Either way, sounds like you're on the right track - motion sensors seem like a smart choice for convenience, despite the occasional midnight pet disco...


Reply
dancer22

I installed motion sensors in my own kitchen remodel last year, and yeah, the pet disco was real at first. My labrador kept setting it off every night, drove me nuts. Eventually, I repositioned the sensor higher up and angled it slightly downward - problem solved. Also found that adjusting sensitivity settings helped a ton. They're great now, but I'd probably pair them with dimmable under-cabinet lighting if I did it again...just for those late-night snack runs without waking everyone up.


Reply
daisygamer

I feel your pain with the pet disco - my cat triggered ours constantly at first. I ended up tweaking the sensitivity too, but honestly, if I could redo it, I'd probably skip motion sensors altogether and just go straight for smart dimmers. Being able to control brightness from my phone or voice assistant has been a lifesaver for midnight snack raids. Plus, no more accidental dance parties at 2 AM...


Reply
dennisleaf720

Smart dimmers are great, but honestly, I've been loving my under-cabinet LED strips. They're subtle enough to leave on low overnight (no more stubbed toes!), and I can crank them up when cooking. Plus, installation was surprisingly easy for a newbie like me. Motion sensors sounded cool at first, but after hearing your cat stories, I'm glad I skipped them...my dog would have a field day!


Reply

Under-cabinet LEDs definitely have their perks, but honestly, after flipping a few homes, I've come to appreciate recessed lighting a lot more. I get the appeal of subtle lighting overnight - no one likes bruised shins - but recessed lights with adjustable brightness can give you similar comfort without cluttering your cabinets. Plus, they're pretty versatile when you're staging a home or just changing up your kitchen layout.

Funny you mention motion sensors and pets...I once installed them in a house I was renovating, thinking it'd be a cool selling point. Big mistake. Every time I walked past the kitchen window at night, the lights would flicker on and off like some haunted house - turns out the neighbor's outdoor cat had claimed my porch as his midnight hangout spot. Lesson learned: motion sensors are great in theory, but not always practical in real life.

Still curious though, did anyone try those toe-kick lights? They seem subtle enough to avoid pet-triggered chaos...but maybe I'm underestimating animal ingenuity here.


Reply

I've been tempted by those toe-kick lights myself, but after my experience with pets and lighting, I'm hesitant. A while back, I put in some subtle floor-level LEDs thinking they'd be perfect for late-night snack runs. Turns out my dog thought they were fascinating and spent hours pawing at them - ended up scratching the cabinets pretty badly.

"motion sensors are great in theory, but not always practical in real life."

Exactly this! Sometimes the simplest solutions (like dimmable recessed lighting) end up being the most practical...


Reply

I had a similar issue with motion sensors - thought they'd be perfect for midnight kitchen trips, but my cat kept triggering them at all hours. Ended up feeling like a disco in there. Switched to simple under-cabinet lights with a dimmer, and honestly, it's been hassle-free since. Sometimes basic really is best...especially with pets around.


Reply
dieselw44

Had a similar thought process when planning our kitchen lighting. Motion sensors seemed futuristic and convenient, but then I remembered our dog, who has a talent for midnight snack patrols. Didn't want to turn our kitchen into a rave every night either, haha. Ended up going with warm LED strip lights under the cabinets and a dimmable pendant over the island. Honestly, the flexibility is amazing - you can create mood lighting for dinner, brighter task lighting for cooking, or just a soft glow for late-night fridge raids. Sometimes simplicity paired with a little creativity is the sweet spot. Plus, it doesn't hurt that it looks pretty sleek too...


Reply
josephdavis375

Your setup sounds really practical. I went through something similar with our kitchen renovation last year. We considered motion sensors too, but we have a cat who's basically nocturnal and loves midnight adventures - didn't want her triggering lights constantly.

Ended up choosing:
- Soft recessed LED ceiling lights for general brightness.
- Under-cabinet lighting similar to yours, because honestly that's a game changer for meal prep or just grabbing snacks late at night without blinding yourself.
- Added a small adjustable wall sconce near the coffee maker area for early mornings when you don't want full brightness yet (pre-coffee eyes, anyone?).

Have to admit, I was skeptical about needing multiple lighting sources at first, but now I wouldn't change it. Being able to adjust the mood or brightness depending on what you're doing really makes the kitchen more comfortable and inviting. Sometimes simpler setups actually give you more flexibility than tech-heavy ones.


Reply
Scroll to Top