Remodeling discussions and local services.

HOW LONG DID YOUR POOL MAKEOVER REALLY TAKE?

108 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

rmeow26

Honestly, ten weeks isn’t bad at all in the world of renos. I get the urge to compromise when delays drag on, but in my experience, waiting for the right materials usually pays off. Had a similar situation with reclaimed wood - took ages, but I’m glad I didn’t settle. The upfront hassle’s annoying, but you’re less likely to regret it later.


Reply
illustrator76

The upfront hassle’s annoying, but you’re less likely to regret it later.

That’s a fair point, but I sometimes wonder if there’s a line where waiting just isn’t worth it. Ten weeks is reasonable, but I’ve seen projects drag on for months just because someone insisted on a specific tile or finish. At what point does the “perfect” material stop being worth the stress? Curious if anyone’s actually regretted holding out for something, or if it really always pays off in the end.


Reply
thomasbirdwatcher

I get where you’re coming from. I’ve been down that rabbit hole myself - spent ages waiting for a custom mosaic that looked incredible in the catalog, but by the time it finally arrived, I was so burned out from delays I almost didn’t care anymore. Honestly, I think there’s a sweet spot. If it’s a feature you’ll see every day and it’ll bug you forever if you compromise, maybe it’s worth the wait. But when it’s something like a grout color or a minor trim, I just don’t see the payoff matching the headache.

Anyone else ever just picked the “good enough” option and ended up happier for it? Or is that just me being impatient? Sometimes I wonder if the quest for perfect just drags things out for no real reason...


Reply
jennifermartinez379

Honestly, I see this all the time. Folks get hung up on the tiniest details - like waiting three months for a specific tile shade that nobody but them will ever notice. Here’s how I look at it:

- If it’s something you’ll see every day and it’ll bug you, yeah, hold out for what you want.
- For stuff like grout color or a trim piece? Most people forget about it after a week.
- Sometimes “good enough” really is good enough. I’ve seen people happier just moving on and enjoying their pool instead of obsessing over the last 2%.

Perfection’s great, but so is actually swimming in your pool before summer’s over...


Reply

Totally get where you’re coming from. I spent way too long agonizing over the exact shade of blue for our pool tiles, and honestly, now that it’s done, I barely notice them. The stuff I see every day - like the steps and the coping - matters way more to me. Sometimes it’s just not worth the stress to chase perfection on every little thing. Enjoying the pool is what really counts, especially after all the waiting.


Reply

The stuff I see every day - like the steps and the coping - matters way more to me.

That’s interesting, because I’ve noticed clients often get fixated on details that end up fading into the background once the project’s finished. I’m curious - did you find yourself second-guessing any of the bigger elements, like the layout or materials for the coping? Sometimes those decisions have a bigger impact on daily enjoyment than we expect. I wonder if focusing energy there might be more rewarding in the long run...


Reply
timmechanic

Funny you mention the coping - I’ve had clients agonize over tile color for weeks, but then barely notice it once the pool’s filled. Meanwhile, the shape of the steps or how the sun hits the shallow end ends up making or breaking their daily swim. I always tell people, don’t underestimate the stuff you’ll interact with every single day. Materials matter, but layout’s what you’ll feel every time you use the pool. I’ve seen folks regret not spending more time on that part.


Reply
gandalfyogi1371

- 100% agree, layout trumps materials every time.
- I spent days picking out the “perfect” tile, but honestly, now that it’s done, I barely notice it unless I’m cleaning.
- What I do notice? The awkward step placement… wish I’d thought more about how we’d actually move around in there.
- Sunlight makes a huge difference too - our shallow end gets way too hot by midafternoon. Didn’t even cross my mind during planning.
- If I could do it again, I’d focus way more on how we use the pool day to day, not just the finishes.


Reply

If I could do it again, I’d focus way more on how we use the pool day to day, not just the finishes.

Couldn’t agree more - function over fancy tiles every time. I got obsessed with eco-friendly pavers, but now it’s the weird bench placement that bugs me. Also, that “sunlight” issue? Solar covers help, but only so much...


Reply
kevin_carter

I hear you on the bench placement - ours ended up right where the afternoon shade hits, so it’s basically useless after 3pm. I spent ages picking out “period-appropriate” coping to match the house, but honestly, I wish I’d prioritized a better spot for the steps and benches. The sunlight thing is tricky...we tried solar covers too, but if your pool’s in a shady spot, there’s only so much you can do. Sometimes I think the practical stuff just gets lost in the excitement of picking finishes.


Reply
zeusfire510

Funny how the little things like bench placement end up mattering way more than the fancy finishes, right? I’ve seen folks get really hung up on tile color or coping style, but then realize later that the sun and shade patterns totally change how they use the pool. Happens all the time. Sometimes I’ll suggest mapping out where the sun hits at different times before finalizing anything, but it’s easy to get swept up in the design details.

Curious - did your project run into any delays because of changes to the layout, or did you stick with your original plan? I’ve had jobs where moving a bench or steps mid-build added a couple weeks, but sometimes it’s worth it for long-term usability.


Reply

Totally agree about the importance of those “invisible” details. I’ve seen people obsess over mosaic tile samples for weeks, but then end up frustrated when their favorite bench is in full sun all afternoon. Funny how nobody thinks about where they’ll actually want to sit until it’s too late. For my own pool, we ended up moving a step after the first layout because we realized it would be in shade all morning - which sounded great until we remembered that’s when the kids use the pool most.

That little change set us back almost three weeks, but honestly, I’d do it again. The fancy finishes are fun to pick out, but if you’re not comfortable using the space, it just doesn’t matter. Sometimes I think folks underestimate how much those tweaks can impact the schedule. It’s a pain in the moment, but way better than regretting it every summer.


Reply
ruby_echo3610

TITLE: HOW LONG DID YOUR POOL MAKEOVER REALLY TAKE?

Man, you nailed it with the “invisible” details. I swear, I spent more time pacing around my backyard with a tape measure and a folding chair than I did picking out tile colors. My family thought I’d lost it, but after living with our old pool layout for years, I knew exactly how much a misplaced bench or step can mess up the whole vibe.

We hit the same snag - had this grand plan for a sun shelf right off the deep end, but after laying it out with string and some chalk, I realized it would be in direct sun from noon till dinner. Great if you’re a lizard. Not so much if you’ve got pale kids who turn into lobsters at the first hint of summer. Ended up shifting the whole thing over by about four feet. That meant reworking some plumbing and pushing back the finish date by almost a month. At first, I was annoyed (and my wallet wasn’t thrilled either), but now? No regrets. The kids can splash around without sunscreen melting off their faces every five minutes.

Funny enough, the tile we spent hours agonizing over is just... there. Looks nice, but nobody ever comments on it. People always talk about how comfortable and usable the space is, though.

I do think sometimes folks underestimate how much those little tweaks snowball into extra weeks (or months) on the schedule. But honestly, once you’re floating around with a cold drink and not roasting or shivering in some weird corner, you forget all about those delays.

If I had to do it again, I’d probably obsess even more over shade and sightlines than finishes. Learned that one the hard way...


Reply
jack_trekker

- Totally relate to this:

“I spent more time pacing around my backyard with a tape measure and a folding chair than I did picking out tile colors.”

- My pool reno took 11 weeks, but honestly, half that was me second-guessing where the shade sails would go.
- Ended up moving the steps three times just to avoid afternoon glare.
- Used recycled pavers for the deck - took longer but worth it for the lower impact.
- If I could do it again, I’d plan even more for natural shade. Trees > umbrellas every time.
- Funny how nobody notices the eco-friendly stuff, but everyone loves the comfy layout.


Reply
writing_hunter

“I spent more time pacing around my backyard with a tape measure and a folding chair than I did picking out tile colors.”

That’s so real - my “planning phase” was mostly me dragging lawn chairs around at different times of day, trying to figure out where the sun would hit. If I could do it over, I’d definitely budget more for mature trees instead of fancy fixtures. Umbrellas are fine, but they never seem to last. Recycled pavers are a great call too. Took me forever to source enough, but the savings added up.


Reply
jerrym87

POOL MAKEOVERS: THE “PLANNING” PHASE IS A TRAP

Dragging chairs around the yard is basically a rite of passage, right? I swear, I spent more hours just staring at the sun’s path and second-guessing where to put the deep end than on any actual design choices. But honestly, I think people underestimate how much that “wandering and wondering” phase matters. It’s not wasted time if it saves you from regretting a shady pool or a blindingly hot patio.

I do have to push back a bit on the mature trees thing, though. I get the appeal - instant shade, less waiting - but unless you’re really careful about species and placement, they can wreck your pool with roots or endless leaf drop. We went with native saplings and yeah, it’s a slower payoff, but they’re way less thirsty and don’t mess with the plumbing. Plus, there’s something satisfying about watching them grow up alongside your new space.

Recycled pavers are underrated for sure. Sourcing them was like a weird treasure hunt - half my weekends were spent scrolling classifieds or driving to random yardsales. But the character you get from mismatched old bricks is worth it. And honestly, why buy new when there’s so much good stuff out there already?

If I could do it again, I’d skip most of the “fancy” stuff (water features, LED lights) and put that money into better soil prep and drought-tolerant landscaping. Fixtures date fast; healthy plants just get better with time. Umbrellas? Yeah...they’re basically disposable at this point.

Curious if anyone else ended up rethinking their priorities halfway through? It feels like every pool project is just one long series of compromises between what looks cool and what actually works in real life.


Reply
susany59

Curious if anyone else ended up rethinking their priorities halfway through? It feels like every pool project is just one long series of compromises between what looks cool and what actually works ...

We spent way too long in the “wandering and wondering” phase, but honestly, it saved us from a lot of regrets. I agree on skipping the fancy extras - our LED lights barely get used. Native plants were a good call for us, too. The only thing I’d do differently is not underestimate how much time goes into sourcing used materials. It’s worth it, but man, it drags things out.


Reply
jonmitchell698

Our project ended up taking almost double what we’d planned, mostly because of that same “should we or shouldn’t we” dance over every little detail. I totally get what you mean about the extras - those waterfall features and fancy lighting look amazing in photos, but in real life? We just wanted a spot to relax, not host a Vegas pool party every weekend.

I’ll admit, I was stubborn about the recycled pavers. Thought I could score a deal and keep things eco-friendly, but tracking them down was like a part-time job. Worth it in the end, but yeah... if you’re not patient, it’s a headache.

Funny thing is, the stuff we obsessed over (tile color, deck shape) barely matters to us now. The native landscaping though? That’s been the real win - low maintenance and it actually looks better as it grows in. If I had to do it again, I’d focus way more on function than flash.


Reply
rperez62

Totally relate to the “should we or shouldn’t we” spiral. It’s wild how those little decisions can drag things out way longer than expected. I’ve seen a lot of people get caught up in the flashy stuff - those Instagrammable features are tempting, but honestly, most folks just want a chill spot to unwind.

Funny you mention the recycled pavers. I’ve had clients go down that route thinking it’ll be simple and green, but sourcing them can be a real pain. Still, there’s something satisfying about using materials with a story.

Couldn’t agree more about native landscaping. It’s one of those things that pays off over time - less fuss, and it actually gets better as it settles in. Sometimes I wish more people would focus on how they’ll actually use the space instead of getting hung up on trends or what looks good in photos... Function first, always.


Reply

Sometimes I wish more people would focus on how they’ll actually use the space instead of getting hung up on trends or what looks good in photos... Function first, always.

That’s exactly it. I’ve seen folks spend weeks debating tile colors or water features, but then barely use the pool because there’s nowhere comfortable to sit or enough shade. It’s wild how priorities get flipped once you’re knee-deep in decisions.

Curious - did anyone here actually stick to their original plan, or did you end up changing things mid-project? I find that most of my projects go off-script at least once, usually because something “looked better on Pinterest.” Sometimes it works out, sometimes it just drags the timeline out way longer than expected.

Also, for those who went with native landscaping - did you do it all at once, or phase it in over time? I’m always torn between getting everything done in one go versus letting things evolve naturally.


Reply
Scroll to Top