Budgeting reclaimed vs. recycled vs. certified-new materials for a small remodel

I’m pricing a small bathroom remodel with about 55 sq. ft. of floor tile, 35 linear feet of vanity shelving, and roughly 80 sq. ft. of wall framing and backing material. I’m comparing:

- Reclaimed wood for the shelving
- Recycled-content porcelain or ceramic tile
- FSC-certified new lumber for the framing and backing

The greener options may cost more upfront, but I’m also wondering whether local availability, fewer defects, easier cutting, or reduced waste could narrow the installation gap. Reclaimed wood may need extra preparation, while certified-new lumber could be more predictable and recycled-content tile might have limited matching stock.

For anyone who has priced a similar project through Home Depot, Lowe’s, salvage suppliers, or independent tile shops, could you break estimates into:

- Material cost
- Delivery or pickup
- Expected waste and overage
- Preparation, cutting, or sealing
- Installation labor

I’m trying to compare total installed cost rather than assume an eco-label automatically means a lower lifetime cost. Which material was financially sensible for durability and availability, and where did the greener choice create unexpected labor or waste?