Remodeling discussions and local services.
If You Had to Redo Your Kitchen Lights, What Would You Pick?
- Honestly, the “fancy” lighting trends seem like overkill unless you’re doing it for resale value or just want a showpiece kitchen.
I get the appeal of keeping things simple, but I’ll admit I’m a sucker for a little “fancy” if it’s functional. In my 1920s kitchen, I actually went with toe-kick lights - hear me out! They’re on a motion sensor, so at night, I don’t have to fumble for a switch. Cleaning hasn’t been a big deal since I picked a style with a smooth lens. If you’re careful with placement and pick the right fixture, they can be more practical than folks think. Sometimes a little extra is worth it for the right space.
I totally get where you’re coming from with the toe-kick lights. I used to be a “just give me a single overhead and call it a day” type, but after flipping a few houses, I’ve realized lighting is one of those things buyers notice way more than you’d think. Under-cabinet LEDs, toe-kick strips, even those fancy pendants - if they’re done right and not just thrown in for show, they really do add both function and a little wow factor.
Motion sensors are genius, by the way. In one project, I put them in the pantry and it was an instant hit - people love hands-free anything these days. My only caution is to avoid going overboard (like color-changing lights everywhere... unless you’re running a nightclub out of your kitchen). But yeah, if the “fancy” stuff actually makes life easier or safer, I say go for it. Sometimes practical and pretty can actually coexist.
I totally relate to the “don’t go overboard” part. I tried to DIY some under-cabinet lights on a shoestring budget and, honestly, it made a bigger difference than I expected. Even my kids started using the kitchen more (maybe just for late-night snacks, but still). It’s wild how a little practical lighting can make a space feel special without breaking the bank.
If You Had to Redo Your Kitchen Lights, What Would You Pick?
I get what you mean about the under-cabinet lights - those little things are game changers. But I’ll be honest, I’m always torn between “keep it simple” and “go big or go home.” I once flipped a place where the previous owner had installed these wild, color-changing LED strips everywhere. Looked like a nightclub at midnight, not a kitchen. It was... a lot.
That said, I do think people underestimate how much lighting shapes the vibe. I’m all for practical upgrades, but sometimes a statement pendant or even just swapping out those old yellow bulbs for something brighter can make the whole space feel new. I’d probably go for a mix - some subtle under-cabinet LEDs for function, but also a bold fixture over the island just to give it some personality.
Kids raiding the fridge at 2am is just proof you did something right, honestly. But hey, maybe don’t let them pick the colors unless you want your kitchen looking like a rave.
Honestly, I learned the hard way that too many lighting “features” just end up being a hassle. I once tried smart bulbs everywhere - fun at first, but the novelty wore off fast. Now I stick to dimmable LEDs and basic under-cabinet strips. Clean, simple, and way less drama when something breaks.
the novelty wore off fast. Now I stick to dimmable LEDs and basic under-cabinet strips. Clean, simple, and way less drama when something breaks.
You’re speaking my language. My 1920s kitchen practically revolted when I tried “smart” anything - Alexa nearly started a mutiny with the toaster. Dimmable LEDs are the unsung heroes. Sometimes, old-school just works better... and you don’t need a PhD to change a bulb.
I get the appeal of keeping it simple, but I’ve actually had good luck with smart switches - way less finicky than bulbs or hubs. If you wire them right, you can still use regular bulbs and just get the convenience upgrade. Not for everyone, but worth considering if you’re already opening up walls.
If you wire them right, you can still use regular bulbs and just get the convenience upgrade.
I hear you on the smart switches - definitely a cleaner look than a bunch of smart bulbs, and you don’t have to worry about someone flipping the switch and killing your automation. But honestly, I’ve seen a few headaches with them too, especially in older homes where the wiring isn’t always straightforward. Not every box has a neutral wire, and sometimes folks end up tearing up more wall than they planned just to get things working.
Personally, I still lean toward sticking with good quality dimmers and standard LEDs for kitchens, unless there’s a real need for automation. Less to go wrong, and if something does, it’s usually a quick swap. Plus, if you ever sell, nobody’s left scratching their head over how to turn on the lights.
That said, if you’re already opening up walls and running new wire, then yeah, it’s a good time to consider smart switches or even adding extra circuits for under-cabinet or accent lighting. Just wouldn’t call it a must-have for everyone. Sometimes simple is just... easier to live with.
Yeah, I get that. I’d rather not rip into walls just to add “smart” features that might break or get outdated. I’m all about simple and cheap - dimmers and decent LEDs do the trick for me. Has anyone actually saved money long-term with smart switches, or is it mostly for convenience?
I hear you on not wanting to tear into walls, but honestly, I’ve put in a few smart switches during remodels and they’re not as much hassle as folks think. If you’re already swapping out boxes or running new wire, it’s barely extra work. As for saving money, yeah, the energy savings are minor - but I’ve noticed the real win is automation. I set mine to turn off everything at midnight, and I swear my electric bill dropped a bit, just from not leaving lights on all night. Plus, being able to tweak the lighting from my phone while I’m elbow-deep in a project is just plain handy. I get the appeal of simple, but sometimes the convenience is worth the upfront fuss.
“the real win is automation. I set mine to turn off everything at midnight, and I swear my electric bill dropped a bit, just from not leaving lights on all night.”
That’s exactly what I found too - automation is sneaky good. When we redid our kitchen, I hesitated about smart switches because it felt a bit techy for my taste, but honestly, being able to dim the lights for dinner or crank them up when we’re cleaning is way more useful than I expected. Plus, I set up a “morning” scene that brings up just the under-cabinet LEDs while the coffee brews. It’s oddly satisfying.
If I had to do it over, I’d probably go with even more layered lighting - recessed LEDs on dimmers, pendants over the island (with smart bulbs), and definitely those under-cabinet strips. The combo makes it feel cozy or super bright depending on what’s happening. Not sure the energy savings are massive, but it feels good knowing nothing gets left blazing all night.
I get wanting to keep things simple, but once you live with the convenience for a while, it’s hard to go back.
Layered Lighting Makes All the Difference
“If I had to do it over, I’d probably go with even more layered lighting - recessed LEDs on dimmers, pendants over the island (with smart bulbs), and definitely those under-cabinet strips. The combo makes it feel cozy or super bright depending on what’s happening.”
Couldn’t agree more about layering. I’ve seen so many kitchens where people just throw in a grid of recessed cans and call it a day, but honestly, that’s how you end up with a space that feels like a dentist’s office at night. Layering is where the magic happens - pendants for mood, under-cabinet for task, and then the general overheads for when you’re hunting for that one rogue spatula.
I used to be skeptical about smart switches too. My first thought was, “Do I really need my phone to turn on the lights?” But after living with them for a while, I’m hooked. The ability to set scenes is a game changer, especially if you’re juggling dinner, homework, and a dog that thinks the kitchen is his personal racetrack. I set up a “movie night” scene that drops everything to a warm glow - makes cleaning up popcorn way less depressing.
One thing I’d add: don’t underestimate toe-kick lighting. It sounds fancy, but it’s just LED strips along the base cabinets. At night, it’s enough to sneak in for a glass of water without waking up the whole house. Plus, it looks pretty slick.
Energy savings are nice, but honestly, the real win is just not having to nag everyone about leaving lights on. Automation does the nagging for you. If you’re on the fence about going all-in with smart stuff, maybe start with dimmers and under-cabinet strips - they’re low-commitment but make a big impact.
Funny how something as simple as lighting can totally change how a kitchen feels. It’s one of those things you don’t realize you care about until you get it right... or wrong.
The ability to set scenes is a game changer, especially if you’re juggling dinner, homework, and a dog that thinks the kitchen is his personal racetrack.
Not sure I’m totally sold on all the smart lighting. I get the convenience, but sometimes it feels like adding more tech than needed - especially when "automation does the nagging for you." I’ve had smart switches glitch out and leave us in the dark during a firmware update. If you’re going for efficiency and simplicity, I’d suggest just sticking with high-quality dimmable LEDs and skip the extra gadgets unless you really love tinkering. Fewer points of failure, less e-waste down the line. It’s not as flashy, but sometimes low-tech is just easier to live with long-term.
Honestly, I’m with you on the less-is-more approach. I’ve seen too many kitchens where a fancy system just complicates things. Have you tried layering basic dimmable LEDs with under-cabinet strips? It’s not “smart,” but it covers most needs without the headaches. Sometimes, reliability wins out over bells and whistles... especially when you’re mid-recipe and just need the lights to work.
I hear you on the reliability front - nothing worse than a “smart” system that decides to glitch when your hands are covered in dough. I usually recommend a three-layer setup: recessed dimmable LEDs for general light, under-cabinet strips for task areas, and a pendant or two over the island if you’ve got one. Keeps things simple but flexible. If you want to get fancy, a basic wall dimmer is about as high-tech as I’d go for most folks.
I get where you’re coming from with the “keep it simple” approach, but I’ve seen some folks really regret not adding a few more circuits or zones when they had the chance. Ever run into kitchens where the recessed cans just don’t cut it for chopping or reading a recipe? I always wonder if people end up using those under-cabinet strips as much as they think they will, or if they just collect dust after a while.
Have you tried those newer magnetic track systems? They’re not “smart” in the glitchy sense, but you can slide lights around or swap them out pretty easily - seems like a good middle ground for flexibility without the tech headaches. I’m also curious whether folks actually use dimmers much in the kitchen, or if it’s one of those things that sounds nice but mostly stays on full blast.
I guess my main question is: if you had to pick one thing to splurge on for kitchen lighting, would it be better quality fixtures, more control (like dimming, zones), or just more lights overall?
I always wonder if people end up using those under-cabinet strips as much as they think they will, or if they just collect dust after a while.
Funny you mention that - I've seen a lot of folks install under-cabinet lights and then forget they're even there. But when they're wired to a separate switch, people actually use them more. If I had to pick one thing to splurge on, I'd go for more control - zones and dimmers. You can always swap out fixtures later, but adding new circuits is a pain once everything's finished. Magnetic tracks are cool, but I still like the reliability of hardwired setups for kitchens where you need consistent light.
I totally get what you mean about the under-cabinet strips. I’ve flipped a few houses where the previous owners put them in and, honestly, half the time they were dusty or the bulbs were burnt out. But I agree with this:
If I had to pick one thing to splurge on, I'd go for more control - zones and dimmers.
Having options makes a huge difference. In my own place, I wired the strips to a separate switch and suddenly I’m actually using them for meal prep or late-night snack runs. It’s funny how just a little extra control can turn something from “meh” to “how did I live without this?”
But I agree with this:Having options makes a huge difference.
I get the appeal of zones and dimmers, but honestly, I’ve found them a bit overkill in smaller kitchens. Sometimes too many options just mean more stuff to fiddle with. Last time I remodeled, I went with higher-quality LED pucks - no strips - and just one dimmer. Less wiring, less dust, and still plenty of light for late-night snack missions. Anyone else find simpler setups easier to live with?
Sometimes too many options just mean more stuff to fiddle with.
That’s kind of where I landed too, at least for my 1920s galley kitchen. Tried zones once - felt like I was piloting a spaceship just to make coffee. One dimmer, decent under-cabinet lights, and it’s been totally fine. Less is sometimes… actually less hassle.