Remodeling discussions and local services.

If You Had to Redo Your Kitchen Lights, What Would You Pick?

659 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I get the appeal of keeping it simple, but I actually went the other way in my last flip. Layered lighting - recessed cans, under-cabinet strips, pendant over the sink. It felt like overkill at first, but being able to tweak the mood or focus light where you need it? Kinda nice, honestly. Still, I get not wanting to feel like you’re launching a rocket just to scramble eggs...


Reply
melissagamerdev

Still, I get not wanting to feel like you’re launching a rocket just to scramble eggs...

That’s the tricky part - finding balance. I like layered lighting too, but I always go for LEDs with dimmers. Cuts energy use and you can dial it way down when you just want to grab a midnight snack. Overkill if you never use the options, though.


Reply
tech214

I hear you on the “rocket launch” vibe - my last flip had so many switches, I felt like I needed a pilot’s license just to make toast. I’m all for dimmable LEDs, but do you ever find yourself just leaving one setting and never touching it again? Sometimes simple is underrated.


Reply
fitness523

Honestly, I see this all the time - folks get talked into crazy setups with six zones and a remote, but end up using one or two settings max. I’d stick with quality dimmable cans and under-cabinet strips. Keep it simple, make sure it’s bright where you need it, and skip the overkill. Too many bells and whistles just complicate things... and nobody wants to hunt for a manual just to make coffee.


Reply
sky_carpenter

- I get the urge to keep it simple, but honestly, I’ve flipped a few kitchens where layered lighting made a huge difference.
- Task lighting over the island, accent lights in glass cabinets - clients actually use those zones more than you’d think.
- Dimmable cans are great, but sometimes you want mood lighting for a dinner, or just a soft glow late at night.
- Not saying go full spaceship, but a couple extra circuits can be worth it... especially if you plan to sell.
- Manuals are annoying, but most smart switches now are pretty intuitive.


Reply
rubys87

I’m a little wary of overdoing it with layers, especially in older homes. Too many modern fixtures can clash with original details, and extra circuits mean more patchwork in plaster walls - been there, not fun. I lean toward well-placed sconces and a central fixture on a dimmer. Keeps the vibe period-appropriate and still flexible for different moods. Smart switches are tempting, but I’ve had a few that didn’t play nice with antique wiring. Just my two cents...


Reply
charlesarcher

I get where you’re coming from - patching plaster is a pain I wouldn’t wish on anyone. But I’ll admit, I went a little wild with recessed lights in my last kitchen redo. It was a newer house, though, so less guilt about messing with the walls. In my current place (1920s), I’m sticking with a big pendant and a couple of under-cabinet strips. Keeps things simple, and I don’t have to worry about the wiring catching fire... which is always a plus.


Reply

“Keeps things simple, and I don’t have to worry about the wiring catching fire... which is always a plus.”

- Totally get the appeal of keeping it simple, especially in an older house. Less risk, less mess.
- I’ve patched enough plaster to last a lifetime - never seems to look right after, no matter how careful I am.
- Recessed lights are nice, but honestly, the cost adds up fast. Fixtures, cans, bulbs, electrician... it’s a lot.
- Big pendant + under-cabinet strips is a solid combo. You get good task lighting without tearing up the ceiling.
- I did similar in my last place (1940s). Swapped out a dated fluorescent for a big drum pendant and stuck some LED tape under the cabinets. Way cheaper than rewiring everything.
- Only thing I’d add: dimmers. Makes a huge difference for not much money.

Not sure I’d ever go back to recessed unless I was gutting the whole room anyway. Sometimes “good enough” is just right.


Reply
sewist20

Big pendant and under-cabinet LEDs is exactly what I did in a 1950s flip last year. The ceiling was a mess and I just didn’t have the patience (or budget) for recessed. I will say, though, if you ever do open up the ceiling, it’s tempting to add a couple cans just for resale value - buyers seem to love them, even if I think they’re overrated. Dimmers are a must, though. Makes a world of difference when you’re sneaking in for a midnight snack or just want to set the mood for dinner.


Reply

I get what you mean about recessed lights being overrated. In my 1920s kitchen, I actually kept the old school fixture in the center and just added a couple of wall sconces and some plug-in under-cabinet strips. Honestly, I don’t miss cans at all - plus, patching up plaster is a nightmare. Curious if anyone’s managed to hide modern lighting without wrecking their original ceilings? Dimmers are non-negotiable, though. Makes a huge difference when you want low light but not total darkness.


Reply

Honestly, patching plaster is the worst. I tried to fix a spot in our dining room ceiling once and it took me three tries before it didn’t look like a lumpy pancake. I’m with you on keeping the old fixtures - there’s just something about that vintage glow, you know? Plus, not having to cut into the ceiling is a win for my sanity and my wallet.

In our kitchen, I went the budget route and used those LED tape lights under the cabinets. They’re not totally hidden, but if you stick ‘em up behind the lip, you barely notice them unless you crouch down. Not exactly “invisible,” but it gets the job done without drilling or patching. Dimmers are a must for me too. I actually found these cheap plug-in dimmer switches online that work with most lamps or strips. Way easier than rewiring anything.

I did see some folks on YouTube using picture rail molding to run wires for sconces or even little pendant lights, then painting it to match the trim. Looked pretty slick and barely touched the original plaster. Has anyone actually tried that? I’m tempted, but kind of worried about making it look “tacked on” instead of intentional.

I’ve also wondered if there’s a clever way to do more dramatic lighting, like a small chandelier or cluster of pendants, without needing to rewire the whole ceiling. My kitchen’s got this awkward nook that could use something more interesting than just a bulb on a cord… but then again, maybe I’m overthinking it. Anyone else get analysis paralysis with lighting choices? Sometimes I think I spend more time scrolling than actually doing anything.

Curious if anyone’s had luck with battery-powered options lately? The last ones I tried were pretty weak, but maybe they’ve improved. Trying to avoid running extension cords everywhere, but I’m not above a little DIY hack if it saves me from patching more plaster.


Reply

Totally get the analysis paralysis - lighting choices are weirdly stressful. I’ve stared at the same “inspiration” photos for weeks before actually buying anything. The picture rail trick is clever, and I’ve seen it look really seamless if you paint it to match, but I get your worry about it looking tacked on. Sometimes the “imperfections” end up giving a space more character anyway. Battery lights have gotten a bit better, but I still find them dim or needing constant recharging. I’d rather deal with a visible cord than patch plaster again, honestly.


Reply
dancer99

I totally relate to the cord vs. plaster debate - sometimes I wonder if we’re all just picking our battles with these old houses. Have you ever tried running cords along the top of the baseboard instead of up high? I’ve seen it done in a few historic homes and it sort of blends in, especially if you paint the cord cover. But then again, maybe that’s just trading one “imperfection” for another.

Curious - do you think the character of a space is more about those little quirks, or is it worth going through the hassle to hide everything? I keep going back and forth. Also, has anyone found battery lights that are actually bright enough for kitchen tasks? I keep seeing ads for “super bright” ones, but I’m skeptical...


Reply
kmitchell43

Honestly, I think those quirks are what give old places their soul, but I get why people want things tidy. I’ve run cords along the baseboard using low-profile raceways - if you paint them, they pretty much disappear unless you’re crawling around on the floor. Hiding everything behind plaster gets expensive fast, and if you ever need to upgrade wiring (hello, future-proofing), it’s a pain. As for battery lights, I’ve tried a couple brands that claim to be “daylight bright” - most barely cut it for chopping veggies. Has anyone had luck with rechargeable puck lights that actually last more than an hour or two?


Reply

Those quirks are half the charm, I agree. I’ve tried a handful of those rechargeable puck lights too - most of them are just glorified nightlights, in my experience. Even the ones with “high lumens” barely last through a meal prep session. Honestly, I think hardwiring is worth the hassle if you can swing it, but your raceway trick is a solid workaround. Sometimes you just have to pick your battles with these old houses.


Reply

I hear you on the rechargeable puck lights - they’re just not up to the task for anything more than a midnight snack run. I’ve been debating whether to go all-in with hardwired LED strips or stick with something less invasive. Has anyone had luck with the plug-in under-cabinet bars? I’m curious if they’re actually bright enough for real cooking, or if it’s just another half-measure. Old wiring makes me nervous, but tearing up walls isn’t high on my list either...


Reply
joseph_robinson

I hear you on the rechargeable puck lights - they’re just not up to the task for anything more than a midnight snack run. I’ve been debating whether to go all-in with hardwired LED strips or st...

I get the hesitation about tearing up walls - been there. I tried the plug-in bars in a rental flip once, and honestly, they surprised me. Not as seamless as hardwired, but way brighter than puck lights. Have you thought about using smart plugs to control them? That made a difference for me.


Reply
lisabaker440

Funny you mention smart plugs - I actually use them for my under-cabinet plug-in bars, too. My house is from the 1920s, so I’m always nervous about messing with the original plaster. The plug-ins aren’t as hidden as I’d like, but being able to just say “lights on” while my hands are full is a game changer. Ever notice how the color temp on some of those bars can be a bit harsh, though? I had to try a couple brands before finding one that didn’t make my kitchen look like a hospital...


Reply
ldavis85

That “hospital” vibe is exactly what drove me nuts with my first set of bars.

Ever notice how the color temp on some of those bars can be a bit harsh, though?
I ended up swapping mine for a warmer 2700K model - still not perfect, but way less clinical. I’m always torn between hiding the cords and just living with them for the sake of not drilling into old walls. Have you found a good workaround for cord management that doesn’t risk damaging the plaster?


Reply
cathydavis530

A flush panel can work without making the counters shadow-free. Spacing and placement matter: a broad, even ceiling layout can soften shadows, but the cabinet overhang can still leave the back of the counter shaded. Under-cabinet lights help fill that gap; I’d think of them as task lighting that complements the panels, not a guarantee that every shadow disappears.


Reply
Scroll to Top