Remodeling discussions and local services.

Getting smooth drywall joints without losing your mind

1,018 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

pats53

- That 14" knife is a rite of passage, honestly. First time I picked one up, I thought I’d be patching my jeans more than the wall.
- Tack cloth - yeah, skipping it is like skipping primer. Regret every time.
- Old houses, though... sometimes I wonder if the walls are even supposed to be straight. Adds “vintage charm,” right?
- Curious - anyone ever tried those flexible corner tools? Worth it, or just another gadget collecting dust?


Reply
climber57

I get the appeal of the 14" knife, but honestly, I think it’s overkill for most DIYers - especially if you’re working with old plaster or wavy walls. Sometimes a smaller knife gives you more control and wastes less compound. On the flexible corner tools: tried one once, wasn’t impressed. I just use a regular 6" knife and take my time. Less plastic junk in the toolbox, too. And yeah, “vintage charm” is my excuse for every crooked line in this house...


Reply
markc232600

I hear you on the big knives - they look pro, but unless you’re skimming huge flat walls, a 10" or even 8" is usually plenty. I’ve seen folks fight with a 14" and just end up chasing ridges. Corners? I’m old school too... couple passes with a 6" and patience beats most gadgets. “Vintage charm” is my go-to when the light hits a seam just wrong - sometimes you gotta embrace it.


Reply

Corners? I’m old school too... couple passes with a 6" and patience beats most gadgets.

Totally agree - I've tried those fancy corner trowels but always end up grabbing my trusty 6" blade. For me, it’s all about keeping it simple and not overthinking. I actually found that using a damp sponge after the mud dries helps blend any rough spots, especially around those tricky seams. Has anyone tried using lightweight joint compound for the final coat? Curious if it really sands easier or if it’s just marketing.


Reply

Lightweight mud is nice for sanding, but honestly, I find it a bit too soft sometimes.

using a damp sponge after the mud dries helps blend any rough spots
- I’ve had mixed luck with that. Maybe I’m just impatient, but sometimes it just makes a mess for me. Regular compound and a pole sander still win in my book... unless I’m feeling lazy, then maybe I’ll give the lightweight stuff another shot.


Reply

Interesting point about the lightweight mud being too soft - I've noticed that as well, especially when trying to feather out seams. It seems like it can gouge or pill up if I'm not careful, especially with a sponge. I tried the damp sponge method after reading about it online, but honestly, I think my technique needs work. Sometimes it just smears the compound around or pulls it off in chunks, which is frustrating.

I've stuck with regular all-purpose compound lately, but I'm curious - has anyone tried mixing lightweight and regular mud together to get a balance between easy sanding and a bit more durability? Or maybe there's a trick to getting the sponge technique right that I'm missing... I wonder if timing or sponge type makes a difference.


Reply
wildlife_hannah

Mixing lightweight and regular mud - I've wondered about that too. Never actually tried it, but it seems like it could give you the best of both worlds, at least in theory. The lightweight stuff is just so easy to sand, but yeah, it can be a pain when it starts to pill up or gouge, especially if you go at it with a sponge too soon.

Sometimes it just smears the compound around or pulls it off in chunks, which is frustrating.

That’s exactly what happens to me if I try to sponge before the mud’s fully set. Timing seems to be everything. Have you noticed if it works better if you wait longer, or is it just always a mess? Also, what kind of sponge are you using? I’ve tried those big yellow ones from the tile aisle, but they seem too rough. Maybe a finer, denser sponge would help, but I haven’t found the magic one yet.

Curious if anyone’s had luck with eco-friendly or low-dust compounds. Do they behave any differently, or is it just marketing? I’m always looking for something less messy, but not if it means more headaches.


Reply
emilypilot

Timing seems to be everything.

I’ve actually tried a few of the low-dust compounds, and honestly, I’m not convinced they’re worth the extra cost. They do seem to drop less dust, but I found them a bit harder to sand smooth, which kind of defeats the purpose for me. As for sponges, those big yellow ones always felt too abrasive - like you said, they just smear things around. I switched to a denser grout sponge and waited until the mud was almost fully dry. That helped a bit, but it’s still not perfect. Sometimes I wonder if just sticking with regular mud and sanding outside (when possible) is the least headache overall.


Reply
dev469

Funny you mention the big yellow sponges - those things always made me feel like I was trying to polish drywall with a loaf of bread. I’ve had better luck just taking my time with regular mud and a sanding pole, especially on these old plaster walls. The dust is a pain, but if you do it in small bursts and crack a window, it’s manageable. Sometimes I think the “miracle” products just add more steps than they save.


Reply

I know what you mean about those sponges. I tried the “wet sanding” trick once, thinking it’d cut down on dust, but all it did was smear the mud around and leave weird streaks. Ended up having to sand it anyway, just with a soggy mess to clean up first.

Here’s what’s worked for me, especially with old plaster or uneven walls:

1. First coat - don’t stress about perfection. Just fill the gaps and get it mostly flat. I use a 6" knife for this pass.
2. Let it dry fully, then hit it with a sanding pole using 120 grit. I keep the strokes long and even, and don’t press too hard. The goal’s to knock down ridges, not carve grooves.
3. Second coat - switch to a wider knife (10" or 12") and feather out the edges. This is where you want to be a bit more careful, but again, don’t overwork it.
4. Another light sand, maybe 150 grit this time. I like to run my hand over the joint - if I feel a bump, I’ll spot sand or add a touch more mud.
5. Final skim coat if needed, then one last pass with a sanding sponge for touch-ups.

I’ve found that working in smaller sections keeps me from getting overwhelmed by the dust. I’ll open a window and put a box fan blowing out if I’m doing a lot at once. And yeah, those “miracle” tools always seem to promise more than they deliver... The basics just work.

One thing I do differently from some folks: I vacuum between sanding passes. It keeps the dust from building up and helps me see what still needs work. Not sure if that’s overkill, but it saves me headaches later.

Anyway, patience seems to be the real secret ingredient - no fancy gadgets required.


Reply
huntershadow833

Vacuuming between sanding passes isn’t overkill at all - I do the same thing. Makes a huge difference, especially if you’re working in a small room where the dust just hangs in the air. I’ve tried those “dustless” sanders with the little bags, but honestly, they never seem to catch much. The shop vac is way more effective.

I’m curious - have you ever tried using setting-type joint compound (like the powder stuff you mix yourself) for your first coat? I started using it for repairs and patches because it dries faster and seems to shrink less, but it’s definitely harder to sand if you don’t get it smooth right away. Sometimes I wonder if it’s worth the hassle compared to the pre-mixed stuff, especially for bigger jobs. What’s your take on that?


Reply
crafts_emily

I hear you on the setting-type compound - I've used it for taping seams and patches, mostly when I need to move fast or avoid those annoying shrinkage cracks. But yeah, if you don't feather it out just right, sanding is a pain. For big jobs, I usually stick with pre-mixed for the later coats since it's easier to sand and gives me more working time. Have you ever tried mixing the two - like hot mud for the first coat, then topping with pre-mixed? Curious if that combo works better for anyone.


Reply

Mixing hot mud for the first coat and switching to pre-mixed for the finish is pretty much my go-to, especially in these old houses where nothing’s square and you’re always patching over weird stuff. Hot mud grabs quick and locks down the tape, but I’ve learned the hard way not to try sanding it too much - just knock down the ridges and move on. Pre-mixed is way easier to feather out, so the final result looks smoother, and you don’t have to fight the clock.

I’ve never had any issues with adhesion or cracking when switching between the two, as long as the hot mud’s fully set before topping it. Honestly, it’s saved me a lot of frustration, especially when I hit a patch of old plaster that wants to crack or crumble. Just don’t try to get fancy with the hot mud on your last coat... you’ll regret it when you’re sanding.


Reply
jerrym87

I get the appeal of hot mud for that first coat, especially when you’re dealing with old plaster that’s falling apart. But I’ve actually had better luck sticking with setting-type compounds all the way through, just using a slower set time for later coats. Less shrinkage, and I don’t have to worry about weird chemical interactions or off-gassing from pre-mixed stuff - plus, it cuts down on plastic waste from those buckets. The sanding is a pain, yeah, but if you keep your knife clean and don’t overload it, it’s not too bad. Anyone else lean this way?


Reply

I’ve flipped a few older houses where the plaster was basically dust, and I get what you mean about sticking with setting-type mud. I usually start with 20-minute for the first coat, then switch to 45 or even 90 for the rest - gives me more time to feather things out. The sanding is still a drag, but if you hit it while it’s just barely set, it’s way easier. I do miss the convenience of pre-mixed sometimes, but those buckets pile up fast... and honestly, the finish seems tighter with hot mud anyway.


Reply

- Totally agree on hot mud giving a tighter finish - pre-mixed just doesn't seem to bond as well, especially on crumbly old plaster.
- I’ve found that if I mix the 20-minute stuff a little thicker for the first coat, it helps fill those deep gaps better.
- Sanding is brutal, but I’ve started using a vacuum sander attachment... makes a huge difference, though it’s a pain to lug around.
- Ever tried mesh tape instead of paper for those sketchy spots? Not perfect, but sometimes it saves me from a redo.


Reply
metalworker21

Mesh tape’s been a lifesaver for me on those weird, crumbly corners - though I swear it’s a magnet for bubbles if I’m not careful. Hot mud is definitely less forgiving, but the finish is worth it. That vacuum sander is a workout, but way better than dust everywhere. You’re definitely not alone in the struggle... drywall finishing is basically an art form.


Reply

Mesh tape’s been a lifesaver for me on those weird, crumbly corners - though I swear it’s a magnet for bubbles if I’m not careful.

Honestly, I’ve had more luck with paper tape on corners. Mesh always seems to rebel on me - bubbles, frayed edges, you name it. Maybe it’s just my luck, but I’ll take a little extra time with paper if it means fewer touch-ups later. And don’t get me started on hot mud... I blink and it’s already set.


Reply
jenniferking916

Paper tape’s definitely less temperamental for me too, especially on inside corners. Mesh just doesn’t want to lay flat sometimes, and if you miss a spot with the mud underneath, it’s bubble city. I’ve found if I really press the mesh in and use a thinner first coat, it helps, but honestly, paper’s just more forgiving. Hot mud’s a race against the clock - if I’m not prepped, I end up sanding way more than I want to. Ever tried the premixed stuff for final coats? It’s slower but way easier to feather out.


Reply
cheryl_echo

I get what you mean about paper tape being easier, but I actually kinda like mesh for repairs and patches. Maybe it’s just me, but I feel like it’s less likely to crack down the line, especially over old seams. The bubbling is a pain, though - totally agree there. I’ve only used hot mud a couple times and yeah, that stuff sets up fast... I always end up rushing and making a mess. As for premixed, is it just me or does it take forever to dry in humid weather? Sometimes feels like I’m waiting days before I can sand.


Reply
Scroll to Top