Remodeling discussions and local services.

Finally got through a whole project on one charge - anyone else surprised by their batteries lately?

78 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

baking_duke1643

I’ve actually tried one of those cheap battery testers from the hardware store - honestly, it’s been more useful than I expected. I just toss it in my toolbox and check my batteries every month or so. It’s not super high-tech, but it gives me a heads-up before a battery totally craps out mid-project. Way better than guessing, especially when I’m halfway through something messy like drywall work. Not a miracle gadget, but definitely not gathering dust here.


Reply
sonicparker666

I get where you’re coming from - those testers are handy for sure. But I’ve found they’re not always super accurate, especially with rechargeable batteries. Sometimes mine will say a battery’s still good, but then my drill just dies halfway through. For stuff like lighting or remotes, though, I totally agree... better than guessing. If it’s for tools I really rely on, I usually just rotate in fresh ones before I start anything big.


Reply

Yeah, those testers are a bit of a gamble with rechargeables. I’ve had a few “fully charged” batteries fizzle out halfway through hanging drywall - super fun. For anything critical, I just swap in a fresh one and keep the old as backup. Learned the hard way not to trust the tester alone... especially when you’re halfway up a ladder. Remotes and flashlights? Sure, tester’s good enough. Power tools? Not risking it.


Reply

Learned the hard way not to trust the tester alone... especially when you’re halfway up a ladder.

- Been there, done that - except my “halfway up” was on a rickety step stool in a rental kitchen. Battery died mid-cabinet install. Tenants got a good laugh.
- I keep a “mystery box” of half-charged batteries for emergencies. Never fails: the one time I trust it, it’s dead as a doornail.
- Anyone else notice some brands just seem to last longer? Or is it just me getting lucky (for once)?


Reply

Some brands definitely hold up better - my DeWalt batteries outlast the Ryobi ones every time, at least for me. I’ve started labeling my “mystery box” batteries with dates, just to keep track. It’s wild how much difference a year makes in performance.


Reply

I’ve started labeling my “mystery box” batteries with dates, just to keep track.

Funny you mention that - I started doing something similar after I accidentally grabbed a battery that wouldn’t hold a charge for more than ten minutes. It’s wild how some just seem to give up overnight. Ever tried reviving an old one with those “battery reset” tricks? I’ve had mixed luck, but sometimes it actually works...


Reply

I’ve had those “miracle recoveries” with battery reset tricks too, but honestly, it’s hit or miss for me. Sometimes a deep discharge and recharge cycle brings one back from the dead, other times it’s just toast. I started writing the purchase month on mine after grabbing a dud mid-project - nothing kills momentum like swapping batteries every ten minutes. It’s weird how some last years and others just quit out of nowhere... I guess it depends on how hard they’ve been pushed.


Reply

I started marking my batteries with a Sharpie too, but then I realized I can't read half of my own scribbles when I'm crawling around in the crawlspace. Still, it's better than playing "guess which one is about to crap out" mid-project. That said, I swear there's some kind of battery lottery going on. Bought two packs from the same store, same day, same brand - one's still kicking after three years, the other barely survived a weekend of hanging drywall. Go figure.

I've tried those deep drain-and-recharge voodoo rituals, but honestly, I think my batteries just like to mess with me. Sometimes it works and I feel like a genius; other times, nothing but disappointment and a lot of muttering under my breath. My neighbor swears by the freezer trick - he sticks dead ones in the freezer overnight and claims it gives them a second wind. I tried it once and all I got was a cold battery and a weird look from my wife when she found it next to the frozen peas.

Honestly, if these things weren't so dang expensive, I'd just swap 'em out every year and call it good. But until someone starts handing out free batteries at the hardware store (not holding my breath), I'll keep squeezing every last drop out of mine - even if it means doing the battery shuffle halfway through a project. At least it's good cardio...


Reply
sartist86

Man, the freezer trick cracks me up - my buddy tried that too and just ended up with condensation in his charger. I’ve had batteries that outlasted my interest in a project, and others that died before lunch. It’s like they know when you’re on a roll and decide to bail. At this point, I just rotate them like I do tenants - keep the good ones close and hope for the best. If only they appreciated rent payments as much as a full charge...


Reply

Batteries are a total mystery sometimes. I’ve had some that just keep going, and others that tap out halfway through a paint touch-up. I’ve never trusted that freezer trick either - seems like more hassle than it’s worth. Lately, I just label the good ones with tape and hope for the best. It’s wild how inconsistent they can be... maybe it’s just luck?


Reply
finance998

Batteries are a total mystery sometimes.

I’ve had the same experience - sometimes a battery just keeps going, and other times it’s like it gives up halfway through the job. I’m with you on the freezer trick; never made much sense to me either. I’ve read that extreme cold can actually damage certain battery types, so I avoid that altogether.

I do think labeling is smart, but even then, I’ve noticed batteries from the same pack behaving totally differently. Might be storage conditions or just manufacturing quirks. Have you noticed if certain brands hold up better for you over time? I’ve started keeping track, and it seems like some of the older name brands actually last longer than the bargain ones, even though they cost more upfront.

Curious if anyone else has tried those rechargeable ones for small projects. I’ve had mixed results - sometimes they’re great, sometimes they lose charge just sitting in the drawer. Maybe it’s just the age of my chargers...


Reply
hunteryoung537

I’ve noticed batteries from the same pack behaving totally differently. Might be storage conditions or just manufacturing quirks.

Right? Drives me nuts. I swear I’ve had “identical” batteries where one powers through a day of drilling and its twin taps out before lunch. As for rechargeables, I’m with you - they’re hit or miss. Sometimes they’re amazing, but sometimes they just sit there losing juice like they’re on vacation. I do think the older name brands last longer, but man, the price difference stings. Maybe it’s just luck of the draw... or maybe batteries just like messing with us.


Reply

Funny, I’ve had the same thing happen with my drill batteries. Two from the same set, one’s a champ and the other’s just lazy. I’ve started marking the “good” ones with a bit of tape so I know which to grab first - probably overkill, but it saves me some frustration mid-project.

I do think storage makes a difference, especially with rechargeables. Left a couple in my garage over winter and they never really bounced back after that. Now I keep them inside if I remember. As for brand names, yeah, they seem to last longer, but sometimes I wonder if it’s just better quality control or pure luck. Either way, nothing beats getting through a whole job without swapping batteries... feels like winning the lottery some days.


Reply
chessplayer345484

Marking the good batteries is smart - saves a lot of hassle mid-task. I’ve noticed the same thing with winter storage; cold temps just kill battery life. Bringing them inside definitely helps, though I still get the odd dud even with the pricier brands. Sometimes I wonder if it’s just random luck, but keeping them out of the cold seems to make a difference. Getting through a whole project on one charge really does feel like a small victory... doesn’t happen often enough for me.


Reply
susanrain487

Getting through a whole project on one charge really does feel like a small victory... doesn’t happen often enough for me.

That’s the truth. I’ve got a drawer full of “maybe” batteries - never quite sure if they’ll last or not. I started dating mine with a Sharpie, which helps a bit, but even then, the cold seems to zap them faster than you’d expect. Last winter, I left a couple in the garage by mistake and they were toast by spring. It’s funny, the older NiCads from my dad’s old drill seemed to put up with more abuse, but these new lithium ones are picky. Still, when you do get that rare uninterrupted run, it feels like you’ve won the lottery.


Reply
jessica_perez

I hear you on the battery roulette. I used to just toss mine in a bin and hope for the best, but after a couple mid-project failures, I started keeping them inside the house, especially over winter. It’s not perfect, but I’ve noticed they hold up better - maybe the cold really is the enemy. Also, I try to run them down before recharging, which supposedly helps. Not sure if that’s just something people say, but can’t hurt, right?


Reply

I’ve actually read that running lithium-ion batteries all the way down before charging isn’t ideal.

“I try to run them down before recharging, which supposedly helps.”
With most modern tool batteries, partial charges are fine and might even extend their lifespan. Cold storage definitely seems to make a difference, though - I’ve had a couple packs act weird after being left in the garage over winter.


Reply
frodocyclotourist7520

- You’re right about lithium-ion batteries - running them all the way down isn’t necessary.
- Most tool manuals now actually say to recharge whenever you want, partial charges are totally fine.
- I used to drain mine out of habit from the old NiCd days, but with lithium, it’s just not needed and can even shorten their life if you go too low too often.
- Cold storage is a tricky one. I left a drill battery in my shed last winter and it acted up for weeks after... wouldn’t hold a charge right. Now I just bring them inside if it’s going to freeze.
- Quick tip: If you’re storing them for a while, leave them at about half charge - not full, not empty. That seems to help longevity.
- Honestly, these newer batteries are way better than what we had ten years ago. Getting through a whole project on one charge still surprises me sometimes.

It’s wild how much less babysitting they need now, but yeah, I’d avoid letting them get too cold or run down to zero if you can help it.


Reply

Cold storage is a tricky one. I left a drill battery in my shed last winter and it acted up for weeks after... wouldn’t hold a charge right.

Yeah, learned that lesson the hard way too. Left a couple batteries in the truck overnight last January - next morning, they were basically bricks. Took forever to get them working normal again. These new batteries are great, but they still don’t like freezing their butts off.


Reply
Scroll to Top