Remodeling discussions and local services.
Subway tiles vs. hexagon tiles in the bathroom - what’s your pick?
Funny you mention the mesh sheets - I learned the hard way during our last reno that they can be more trouble than they’re worth if you’re not super careful. I thought I was saving myself time, but I ended up spending a chunk of it nudging tiles back into place. Dark grout with hex is a lifesaver though, especially if you’ve got kids or pets. I was skeptical at first, but it hides so much grime compared to the lighter stuff. Subway on the walls just feels classic, but yeah, any crooked lines and it’s all I see when I walk in... drives me nuts.
- Totally get what you mean about the mesh sheets - ran into the same issue on a flip last year. Ended up redoing a chunk of the floor because the spacing was all over the place.
- For rentals, I almost always go with subway tile. It’s a safe bet, looks sharp, and most tenants like that clean, classic vibe.
- Hex tiles look amazing but I agree, dark grout is a must. White grout just doesn’t hold up in high-traffic bathrooms.
- One thing I’ve noticed: if the subway lines aren’t dead straight, it bugs me every time I walk in... but buyers don’t seem to care as much as I do. Maybe I’m just picky?
Subway tiles are definitely the “can’t go wrong” option, but I’ll admit - I’m a sucker for hex tiles when it comes to making a bathroom feel special. There’s just something about that pattern that makes the space pop, especially if you go with a bold grout color. I totally get what you mean about white grout being a nightmare in busy bathrooms. Tried it once and regretted it after about two weeks - scrubbing grout lines is not my idea of fun.
One thing I’ve noticed: if the subway lines aren’t dead straight, it bugs me every time I walk in... but buyers don’t seem to care as much as I do. Maybe I’m just picky?
You’re not alone there. Crooked subway tile drives me nuts, too. My partner thinks I’m overreacting, but once you see it, you can’t unsee it. That’s one thing about hex tiles - they’re more forgiving if things aren’t perfectly lined up, at least to my eye.
If I’m doing a rental or something budget-focused, yeah, subway all day. But for my own place? Gimme those hexes and some dark grout - less cleaning and way more personality.
Honestly, I get the love for hex tiles - they do add a cool vibe. But I’ve found that hex patterns can be just as tricky to install cleanly, especially if your walls aren’t perfectly square. Any weird angle or bump in the wall and suddenly the lines look off, even with dark grout. I’ve had to redo a section before because the pattern started drifting and it bugged me every time I walked in.
Subway tile might be “safe,” but there’s something classic about it that buyers seem to gravitate toward, at least in my experience flipping places. Plus, if you want personality, you can play around with layout - vertical stack, herringbone, whatever. Sometimes simple is actually what stands out when everyone else is going bold.
And yeah, white grout is a pain... but mid-tone gray has saved me more than once. Not too dark, not too light - hides a lot of sins and doesn’t scream for attention.
Any weird angle or bump in the wall and suddenly the lines look off, even with dark grout.
Yeah, this is exactly why I chickened out on hex tiles. My walls are nowhere near straight and I just didn’t have the patience. Subway tiles are way more forgiving for a newbie like me. Plus, mid-gray grout is basically my new best friend - hides all my “learning moments.”
Subway tiles really are the MVP for older houses, aren’t they? I tried hex tiles once in my last place, thinking I’d get that “boutique hotel” vibe, but the moment I realized my walls were more wavy than straight, I knew I was in trouble. Ended up with a lot of creative caulking and some very strategic plant placement to hide the worst bits. Subway tiles just seem to forgive those little bumps and dips, especially with a grout that’s not bright white. I went with a soft gray too - totally agree, it hides a multitude of sins.
I do love the look of hex tiles, but unless you’ve got laser-straight walls or a ton of patience (and maybe a therapist on speed dial), subway is just less stressful. Plus, if you mess up a cut, it’s way easier to replace a single rectangle than a weird little hex.
“the moment I realized my walls were more wavy than straight, I knew I was in trouble. Ended up with a lot of creative caulking and some very strategic plant placement to hide the worst bits.”
That’s a pretty common scenario with older homes - those walls have seen a lot, and they rarely play nice with precise tile shapes. You nailed it about subway tiles being forgiving. The rectangular shape lets you cheat a little here and there, and that soft gray grout is a smart move. It really does hide imperfections and doesn’t show every speck of dust or stain.
Hex tiles look fantastic in photos, but in real life, unless you’re working with new construction or you’re ready to spend hours fussing over every joint, they can be a headache. I’ve seen folks get halfway through a hex install and just want to rip it all out. Subway tiles are just more practical for most situations, especially if you want to keep your sanity.
That said, if someone’s set on hex, I’d say invest in a good tile leveling system and be prepared for some trial and error. But for most older homes? Subway’s the way to go - less stress, cleaner look, and way easier fixes down the line.
Subway Tiles Just Make Life Easier in Old Houses
I totally get what you mean about those wavy walls. When we first moved into our 1920s place, I had grand plans for a fancy hex tile floor in the upstairs bath. The Pinterest inspiration was strong. But once I started pulling up the old linoleum and saw just how uneven everything was - walls, floor, even the corners - I realized I’d be fighting a losing battle trying to get all those little hexes to line up. There’s just no way to fudge it when every edge is visible.
Ended up going with classic white subway tiles for the shower surround and honestly, no regrets. Like you said, they’re so much more forgiving. I could nudge them a bit here and there, and with slightly wider grout lines in spots where things got weird, you’d never know unless you’re really looking for it. Plus, if one cracks or chips down the line (which happens more than I’d like to admit with kids), it’s a breeze to pop out and replace.
I do love the look of hex tiles - don’t get me wrong - but unless you’ve got perfectly square walls or a pro installer with infinite patience, it’s just not worth the headache in these old houses. Maybe on a small accent floor or niche where you can control the edges, but for big surfaces? Subway all day.
Funny thing is, after all that stress about hiding imperfections, now I kind of appreciate the quirks. The slightly crooked lines just add character... or at least that’s what I tell myself when I spot another wonky corner.
I get the subway tile appeal, but I’ve actually had decent luck with hex tiles in old houses - if you use a flexible, eco-friendly adhesive and a leveling system, it’s not as bad as it seems. Yeah, it takes more time, but the end result can really highlight the quirks instead of hiding them. Plus, smaller tiles can sometimes “bend” with the floor a bit more than big rectangles. I guess it depends on how much patience you’ve got... and how much you care about perfect lines.
Totally get what you mean about hex tiles showing off the quirks - my 1920s bathroom floor is basically a funhouse mirror, and those little hexes just roll with it. Straight lines are overrated anyway... adds character, right? Stick with it, the payoff’s worth the hassle.
Hex tiles definitely hide a lot of the weirdness in old floors. I like how they sort of embrace imperfections instead of fighting them. Subway tiles look sharp, but every little uneven spot stands out more. For me, hex wins for older houses.
I totally get what you mean about hex tiles being more forgiving. I’m in the middle of my first bathroom reno and honestly, the idea of lining up subway tiles perfectly on my old, slightly wavy walls is kinda intimidating. But at the same time, I love that crisp, classic subway look. Has anyone tried mixing both styles in one space? Like hex on the floor and subway on the walls? Wondering if that helps balance out imperfections but still gives you that clean vibe...
Subway tiles on wavy walls aren't as bad as people think - imperfections can actually add some character, especially if you embrace a bit of unevenness. I've done a reno where the slight wonkiness made the space feel less sterile. Mixing hex and subway is cool, but don't stress over perfect lines too much. Sometimes a little imperfection makes it feel more lived-in and real.
Sometimes a little imperfection makes it feel more lived-in and real.
Totally get this. I did a bathroom last year with subway tiles on a wall that was anything but flat. At first, I tried to fight the waves, but honestly, once I stepped back, the slight unevenness just made it feel more like an old-school European bath than a showroom. It’s way less stressful if you stop chasing perfection.
I’ve mixed hex and subway too - hex on the floor, subway on the walls. The lines don’t always match up perfectly, but that’s kind of the charm. Honestly, obsessing over every grout line just takes the fun out of it. A little wonkiness gives the space some soul. If everything’s too perfect, it starts to look like nobody actually lives there... or worse, like a hospital.
I hear you on the “lived-in” vibe - my last bathroom reno taught me that lesson the hard way. I spent hours trying to get every subway tile lined up like a Tetris master, but my 1920s walls had other plans. At some point, I just shrugged and let the tiles do their thing. Now, every time I see that little dip by the window, it kind of makes me smile. It’s like a reminder that real people actually use this space.
Mixing hex and subway is such a classic move. I’ve done hex on the floor too, and yeah, those grout lines never want to play nice with the wall tiles. But honestly, I think that’s what keeps it from looking like a hotel lobby. There’s something about a little mismatch that feels more welcoming.
I do get why some folks chase that perfect grid though. There’s a certain satisfaction in seeing everything line up just right... but at the end of the day, I’d rather have a bathroom that feels like home than one that looks like a catalog page. Plus, if you ever drop something and chip a tile, it’s way less heartbreaking when things aren’t already “perfect.”
Curious - do you ever find yourself noticing the imperfections more at first, then forgetting about them after a while? I swear, the stuff I obsessed over during install is invisible to me now. Maybe it’s just part of the process. Or maybe I’m just getting lazier with age.
Either way, I’ll take a little character over sterile any day.
That’s the thing about old houses - perfection is a moving target. My bathroom walls are about as straight as a politician’s promise, so I gave up on perfect lines pretty quick. I used to notice every little crooked tile, but now I barely see them. It’s funny how your eye just adapts. Honestly, I think a bit of wonkiness just adds to the charm. If everything was flawless, it’d feel like I was living in a showroom, not a home.
I totally get what you mean about the charm of imperfection. I picked hex tiles for our bathroom reno, and let me tell you, trying to line them up on our wavy old walls was a trip. At first I obsessed over every little gap, but now I barely notice. Honestly, the quirks just make it feel more “ours.” If I wanted everything perfect, I’d just go to a hotel, right?
I get the appeal of “quirks,” but honestly, I think there’s something satisfying about crisp lines and symmetry, especially in a bathroom.
For me, it’s not about perfection - it’s about craftsmanship. Subway tiles might seem basic, but when they’re lined up just right, they give a space this timeless, intentional look. Hex tiles are cool, but if the walls are wavy, sometimes the imperfections just look... unfinished rather than charming. Maybe I’m just picky, but I’d rather spend the extra time getting things as close to perfect as possible.If I wanted everything perfect, I’d just go to a hotel, right?
I get what you mean about craftsmanship.
Have you ever tried recycled glass subway tiles? They’re super crisp but also eco-friendly. I do like hex tiles, but if the walls aren’t straight, it can drive me nuts trying to get them to look right. Do you think the extra effort is worth it for the symmetry, or would you ever go for something more forgiving like handmade zellige?“Subway tiles might seem basic, but when they’re lined up just right, they give a space this timeless, intentional look.”
Subway Tiles Vs. Hexagon Tiles In The Bathroom - What’s Your Pick?
“I do like hex tiles, but if the walls aren’t straight, it can drive me nuts trying to get them to look right.”
Totally hear you on that. I once spent hours trying to get hex tiles to line up in a 1920s bungalow - nothing was square, and it nearly broke me. But when it’s done right, the symmetry is gorgeous. Zellige is way more forgiving, though, and the imperfections actually add character. Ever had a client insist on perfect grout lines with zellige? That’s a battle you just can’t win... Curious if you’ve found any tricks for getting hex tiles to play nice with wavy old walls?