Remodeling discussions and local services.

Subway tiles vs. hexagon tiles in the bathroom - what’s your pick?

260 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

danielv82

Totally get where you’re coming from - square tiles are underrated. I did hex in my last reno and honestly, the install was a pain. All those little pieces, and the grout lines seemed endless. Sometimes simple just makes life easier, especially if you’re DIY-ing.


Reply
lunabrewer

I hear you on the hex tiles - those things look amazing in photos, but man, the install can turn into a marathon. I’ve had clients fall in love with them, then halfway through the job, they’re questioning their life choices (and mine). Ever tried getting those tiny hexes to line up perfectly around a shower niche? It’s like a puzzle with no picture on the box.

But here’s a thought: do you think the extra effort is worth it for that “wow” factor, or does the classic subway tile just win out because it’s timeless and way less hassle? I’ve seen some folks do cool patterns with subway tiles - herringbone, vertical stack, even basketweave. Makes me wonder if you can get creative without all the extra grout lines.

Curious - if you had to do it again, would you stick with hex, or go for something simpler? Or maybe mix and match? Sometimes I think we overcomplicate things just chasing that Pinterest look...


Reply
environment671

Ever tried getting those tiny hexes to line up perfectly around a shower niche? It’s like a puzzle with no picture on the box.

Man, you nailed it. I once spent an entire Saturday hunched over a bathroom floor, cursing every hex tile that dared to shift even a millimeter. Looked amazing in the end, but my knees still haven’t forgiven me. Honestly, subway tiles are like comfort food - reliable, classic, and way less likely to make you question your sanity mid-project. But I get the temptation for that “wow” factor... sometimes I think we’re all just chasing that one photo that’ll make our friends jealous.


Reply
melissagamerdev

Honestly, subway tiles are like comfort food - reliable, classic, and way less likely to make you question your sanity mid-project.

I get the appeal of subway tiles - there’s a reason they’re everywhere. But I think we sometimes overlook how much waste those “classic” layouts can create, especially if you’re cutting a lot for corners or niches. With hex tiles, yeah, the install can be a pain (my back still remembers my last attempt), but you can often use up more of the sheet and have fewer awkward offcuts. Plus, if you go with recycled glass or porcelain hexes, you’re making a more sustainable choice than most standard subway tiles, which are usually new ceramic.

Also, grout lines. Subway tiles mean longer, straight grout lines that can get grimy fast, especially if you’re not sealing them regularly. The smaller hexes break that up and hide a lot of the day-to-day mess. Not saying it’s easier to clean - just that it looks cleaner for longer, which is a win in my book.

I do agree about the “wow” factor. There’s something satisfying about seeing a finished hex floor or wall, even if it took twice as long and made you rethink your life choices halfway through. But for me, the extra effort feels worth it if I know I’m using materials that are better for the planet and will last longer without looking dated.

Guess it comes down to what you value more: ease of install or long-term impact. For me, I’ll take the puzzle over the predictable, even if my knees complain.


Reply

I hear you on the sustainability angle and the “wow” factor with hex tiles - there’s no denying they look sharp when done right. But I’ve gotta push back a bit on the waste issue with subway tiles. In my experience, if you plan your layout carefully and start from the right spot, you can actually minimize offcuts pretty well, even around niches and corners. I’ve seen just as much scrap come off a hex job, especially when you’re trying to get those sheets to line up in tight spaces or around plumbing.

“Subway tiles mean longer, straight grout lines that can get grimy fast, especially if you’re not sealing them regularly.”

That’s fair, but I’ve also found that cleaning a million little grout joints on a hex floor isn’t exactly a walk in the park either. I did a small bathroom last year with penny rounds (even smaller than hexes), and the homeowner was cursing those grout lines after a few months. Sometimes what hides dirt also hides mildew, and that can sneak up on you.

At the end of the day, both have their headaches. I guess I lean toward subway for the sheer predictability - less chance of running into weird alignment issues halfway through. But hey, if your knees can take it and you love the look, more power to you.


Reply

I get the appeal of subway tiles for predictability, but I’ve run into alignment headaches with old walls that aren’t square - especially in pre-war homes where nothing is level. Hex tiles (or even penny rounds) can actually be more forgiving on wavy surfaces since the joints break up the eye lines. Sure, grouting takes forever, but I’ll take that over staring at a crooked subway line every time I walk in. Just my two cents from too many hours spent cursing 1920s plaster...


Reply

- Totally feel you on the old house quirks - my bathroom walls are about as straight as a bowl of spaghetti.
- I went with subway tiles because I thought, “hey, classic and easy, right?” Wrong. Trying to line them up on my not-so-level walls had me questioning my life choices.
- Hex tiles looked intimidating at first (all those little pieces!), but now I kinda wish I’d gone that route. The way the grout lines break things up seems like it’d hide my less-than-perfect tiling skills.
- Grouting a million hexes sounds like a pain, but honestly, staring at my slightly slanted subway lines every morning is worse.
- If I ever do this again, I’m team hex - or maybe even penny rounds if I’m feeling brave. At least then any mistakes look “artsy” instead of just... crooked.


Reply
nick_quantum

Definitely hear you on the “not-so-level walls” issue. I’ve worked on more than a few bathrooms where nothing is square, and lining up subway tiles can turn into a real headache fast. That “classic and easy” reputation only holds up if your walls are actually straight, which is rarely the case in older homes.

“The way the grout lines break things up seems like it’d hide my less-than-perfect tiling skills.”

You’re right about hex tiles (or penny rounds) being more forgiving visually. The smaller shapes and extra grout lines do a nice job of camouflaging minor imperfections - you can get away with quite a bit before anything looks off. Subway tile, on the other hand, really punishes any deviation from level or plumb; even a few millimeters out and suddenly every line looks wonky.

One thing to keep in mind with hex or penny rounds: grouting is tedious, but cleaning all those extra grout lines down the road can be a chore too. That said, I’ll take that over staring at uneven subway tile joints every day. Sometimes “artsy” is just code for “I made it work with what I had,” which honestly is half the battle in these old houses.


Reply
zelda_adams

Honestly, I’m right there with you - sometimes “artsy” is just what happens when you’re working with walls that have a mind of their own. I picked hex tiles for my first reno and yeah, grouting took forever, but I barely notice the little mistakes. It’s kind of freeing not having to obsess over every line being perfect. In the end, it feels more like *my* bathroom, quirks and all.


Reply
science928

Totally get where you’re coming from. I went with subway tiles in my last bathroom because, honestly, they were cheaper and seemed easier to line up. But after seeing a friend’s hex tile job - imperfections and all - I kind of wish I’d been braver. There’s something cool about a space that doesn’t look like it came straight out of a catalog. Those little quirks make it feel lived-in and personal.

And yeah, grouting hex tiles is a pain (I helped my friend for a day and my knees still remember), but you’re right: once it’s done, you barely notice the tiny flaws. I think sometimes we get too hung up on perfection, especially when we’re on a budget. At the end of the day, it’s your bathroom, and if you love it, that’s what matters. Plus, nobody else is going to get down on their hands and knees to inspect your grout lines... unless they’re really weird.


Reply
photo964569

Honestly, I think you nailed it with this:

There’s something cool about a space that doesn’t look like it came straight out of a catalog. Those little quirks make it feel lived-in and personal.

I totally agree - perfection is overrated, especially in spaces you use every day. I’ve done both subway and hex tiles, and while subway is definitely easier (and my back thanked me), the hex tiles just have this vibe you can’t fake. The little imperfections almost become part of the story of the house.

And yeah, grouting hex tiles is no joke... I remember thinking, “Why did I do this to myself?” halfway through. But now, every time I walk in there, I’m glad I pushed through. It’s got character, and honestly, nobody notices the tiny mistakes except me.

At the end of the day, the best spaces are the ones that feel like *you*, not like a showroom. If you’re happy with your choice, that’s what matters most.


Reply
fitness997

Man, you’re not kidding about grouting hex tiles. I swear, my knees still haven’t forgiven me for that job last year. But you’re right - those little quirks and “oops” moments end up giving the space some soul. Subway tiles are classic and way easier on the patience (and the joints), but sometimes you just want something with a bit more personality, you know? Ever notice how guests always comment on the unique stuff, not the perfect lines? Makes you wonder if we stress over the wrong details...


Reply
zeldajoker901

Ever notice how guests always comment on the unique stuff, not the perfect lines?

That’s spot on. In my experience, folks rarely notice if a tile line is off by a hair, but they’ll always ask about that funky pattern or unusual shape. Subway tiles are forgiving and efficient, but hex tiles - yeah, they leave your knees barking, but they do make a statement. I’ve had clients who regretted the hassle but loved the end result. Sometimes it’s worth trading a little pain for a lot of character.


Reply
architecture728

Honestly, I lean toward hex tiles, even if they’re a pain to install. There’s just something about that geometric pattern that feels fresh and a little daring, especially when you pair it with natural materials or recycled glass. Subway tiles are classic - no denying their appeal - but sometimes they feel a bit too safe for me. I’ve had projects where we used handmade hexes in muted tones, and even with the extra work (and, yeah, sore knees), the end result had so much personality.

That said, if you’re thinking about environmental impact, both can be sustainable if you source them responsibly. Recycled-content subway tiles are easier to find, but there are some cool eco-friendly hex options out there too. In terms of cleaning and maintenance, hex grout lines can be trickier - just something to keep in mind if you’re not a fan of scrubbing.

At the end of the day, character wins in my book. A little imperfection just adds to the story of the space... and guests always seem to remember those unique touches over anything else.


Reply
jeffgamer

Honestly, I get the appeal of hex tiles - they do have that “wow” factor, especially when you go for something handmade or with a unique finish. But as someone who’s always watching the budget, I keep coming back to subway tiles. They’re not just classic, they’re practical. The cost difference can be pretty significant, especially if you’re hiring out the install. And if you’re DIY-ing, subway tiles are way more forgiving for beginners (trust me, my first attempt at tiling was... not pretty).

You mentioned,

“hex grout lines can be trickier - just something to keep in mind if you’re not a fan of scrubbing.”
That’s honestly what tipped the scales for me. I’ve got two kids and a dog - less grout to clean is a win in my book. Plus, subway tiles don’t have to be boring. You can stack them vertically, do a herringbone pattern, or use colored grout for a twist.

I totally get wanting character and personality, but sometimes simple is just easier to live with day-to-day. And hey, there’s nothing wrong with “safe” if it means less stress and more money left over for other upgrades.


Reply
csniper56

Subway Tiles Are Reliable, But Hex Tiles Have Their Place

“hex grout lines can be trickier - just something to keep in mind if you’re not a fan of scrubbing.”

That’s a point I’ve run into more than once. In one of my earlier flips, I went with small hex tiles for a 1920s-style bathroom floor. Looked fantastic - at first. But after about six months, the owner called me back because the grout lines were already showing wear and discoloration, even though we’d sealed them twice. The sheer number of grout joints on hex tiles is no joke, especially with pets or kids tracking in moisture and dirt.

Subway tiles are just easier to work with all around. The rectangular shape means you get longer runs and fewer cuts, which is a big deal if you’re tiling around awkward corners or plumbing fixtures. And like you said, there’s a lot more flexibility than people think - vertical stack bond, offset, herringbone... I’ve even seen some creative basketweave layouts that look high-end without the high price tag.

One thing I will say: if someone’s set on hex tiles for the “wow” factor, larger format hexes (like 4” or 6”) are a bit more forgiving than the tiny mosaics. Less grout to deal with and easier to keep level during install. Still not as simple as subway tile, but it’s a compromise.

Budget-wise, subway tile almost always wins out. Even factoring in colored grout or specialty patterns, it’s hard to beat the price per square foot - and mistakes are less costly to fix if you’re learning as you go.

I get why people want something different, but after seeing how much maintenance those intricate grout lines can add over time, I tend to steer folks toward subway unless they’re really committed to the upkeep. Sometimes “safe” just means fewer headaches down the road... and more time actually enjoying your space instead of scrubbing it.


Reply
business_phoenix

- Totally agree on the grout issue - hex tiles look awesome but those tiny joints are a pain to keep clean.
- Subway tiles just feel more forgiving, especially if you’re not a pro installer.
- I’ve seen some folks use dark grout with hex tiles to hide stains, but it changes the whole vibe.
- Curious - has anyone tried epoxy grout for hex floors? Supposedly it’s way more stain-resistant, but I’ve never used it myself.


Reply
athompson80

Subway Tiles Vs. Hexagon Tiles In The Bathroom - What’s Your Pick?

- You’re spot on about the hex tile grout. Those little joints look killer when they’re fresh, but man, they can be a magnet for grime. I’ve seen folks get pretty creative with toothbrushes and steamers, but it’s definitely more upkeep than subway tiles.

- Subway tiles are way more forgiving, especially if your walls aren’t perfectly flat or you’re not used to tiling. The bigger joints and straight lines just hide little mistakes better. Plus, if you ever need to swap out a tile down the road, it’s a lot less hassle.

- Dark grout with hex tiles is a bold move. It hides stains, sure, but it totally shifts the vibe - suddenly it’s got that retro or industrial feel. Not bad, just different. I’ve had clients love it and others regret it after a few months because it made the space feel busier.

- Epoxy grout is a game changer for bathrooms, especially on floors. It’s pricier and a bit trickier to work with (sets up fast, so you gotta move quick), but once it’s in, it’s super stain-resistant and doesn’t crack like cement-based grout. I’ve used it on a couple of hex floors - one in a kids’ bathroom where toothpaste and muddy shoes are daily guests - and it still looks sharp years later. Just make sure to clean up any haze right away or you’ll be cursing at yourself for days.

- Honestly, both tile styles have their place. If you love the look of hex and don’t mind a little extra maintenance (or want to splurge on epoxy grout), go for it. If you want something classic and low-fuss, subway’s hard to beat.

At the end of the day, pick what makes you happy every time you walk in there. The rest is just details...


Reply
ashley_chef

I’ve always leaned toward subway tiles for the sheer practicality, but I get the appeal of hexagons - there’s something about that geometric pattern that just feels a bit more playful. The grout situation is real, though. I’ve seen a friend’s hex floor go from crisp white to “permanently off-white” in less than a year, even with regular cleaning. Epoxy grout does help, but it’s not exactly a DIY-friendly option unless you’re comfortable moving fast and dealing with the cleanup.

One thing I’m curious about: has anyone tried larger-format hex tiles? I wonder if that strikes a balance - fewer grout lines, but you still get the visual interest. Or maybe it just loses the charm of the smaller ones? I’ve only ever worked with the classic small hex, so I’m not sure how the bigger ones hold up, both in terms of looks and maintenance.


Reply
jack_johnson

I wonder if that strikes a balance - fewer grout lines, but you still get the visual interest.

I’ve actually used the larger hex tiles in a couple of my rentals, and I think they’re a solid middle ground. You get fewer grout lines, which definitely helps with maintenance - less scrubbing, more sanity. But I’ll admit, they don’t have quite the same “vintage charm” as the tiny hexes. Still, for high-traffic bathrooms, I’ll take easier cleaning over nostalgia most days. And yeah, epoxy grout is a beast to work with... I learned that the hard way on a tight timeline.


Reply
Scroll to Top